4 ms·
This is an example of the "you can pay people not to be corrupt" argument. It relies on people who are both willing to be corrupt, and happy to leave money on t
by pessimizer 5y ago
This is an example of the "you can pay people not to be corrupt" argument. It relies on people who are both willing to be corrupt, and happy to leave money on the table.
It's exactly the same argument as paying for media not to include advertisements.
What we should do is stop filtering for trash by having jobs that pay $174K require multi-million dollar application fees (i.e. a campaign.) That's exactly how you would hire for a job if you wanted to make sure that the primary purpose of having that job was personal enrichment. We talk about being saddled with college debt; we can see the results of being saddled with campaign debt.
How does that happen when your government is run by two tiny private clubs fueled by exactly that sort of personal ambition? It doesn't. Getting a handle on corruption in the US is going to take a lot more than a few tiny adjustments. Especially when the people responsible for making those adjustments would be the corrupt class we would be claiming to fix.
Expecting Congress to fix itself when Congress is composed of the people who were good at this process is bizarre. The best a centrist can do is wait for the courts to fix it.
edit: The court broke it more with Citizens United. It simply doesn't believe that self-enrichment from politics is bad in and of itself. It believes that part of democracy is that the elected person has a mandate to do what they think is best, within the rule of law, and helpfully abolishes any laws or norms that would prevent bribery.
https://www.newyorker.com/news/amy-davidson/the-supreme-courts-bribery-blessing-mcdonnell-decision https://www.newyorker.com/news/amy-davidson/the-supreme-cour...
- buu700 5y agoWhat if we substantially raised salaries — let's say to $100m/yr for the president, and lower but proportional amounts for all other major officials at the federal level — while on the other hand treating corruption-related crimes for those officials as tantamount to light treason? (Just a thought experiment, not something I'm seriously proposing.)
- _3u10 5y agoMore income means more leverage.
- gremIin 5y ago> The best a centrist can do is wait for the courts to fix it. That is not how corruption is fixed.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoNo he's right. The courts will fix this. After the people "come up with a solution" that doesn't involve going through the courts. The courts hate that.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoThis is not a US only problem, virtually any country is run by a couple of political parties and their friends and they can do pretty much anything with little repercussions. I agree better pay is not the answer. The only reasonable alternative is to reduce their powers (especially reducing the amount of money they can spend and the laws they can impose on people) and spread them to local entities. Decentralisation is the only antidote to government corruption and waste.
- zzzzzzzza 5y agosortition
- sabellito 5y ago> This is not a US only problem, virtually any country is run by a couple of political parties and their friends and they can do pretty much anything with little repercussions. Citation definitely needed on this one.
- trollski 5y agoreally?
- ValentineC 5y ago> Citation definitely needed on this one. Not the parent, but Singapore comes to mind as a great example of one party having their fingers everywhere, including the supposedly-apartisan civil service, the trade unions, the political grassroots organisations, and most of the mainstream media organisations. Singapore's two sovereign wealth funds invest in a massive number of local and foreign companies, and often install people they're grooming (usually ex-military) in fancy positions to boost their resumes [1]. Quite a few Members of Parliament hold quite a few directorships in supposedly private companies [2], but it's all fine and dandy as long as the affiliations are declared. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/singapore/comments/i2bnzz/how_does_shawn_huangs_20_years_of_saf_experience/ https://www.reddit.com/r/singapore/comments/i2bnzz/how_does_... [2] https://singaporearmchaircritic.wordpress.com/2014/07/23/mps-directorships-and-conflict-of-interest/ https://singaporearmchaircritic.wordpress.com/2014/07/23/mps...
- hsvx 5y agoYet they get randomly replaced every few years. Ask Hilary Clinton how mucb she managed to raise. That randomness keeps a potential American Xi or Putin on their toes.