4 ms·
It's hard to lump Safari into that, even if webkit is open source.
by bane 15y ago
It's hard to lump Safari into that, even if webkit is open source.
- DavidChouinard 15y agoWhy so?
- monochromatic 15y agoBecause Safari isn't?
- wahnfrieden 15y agoNeither is Chrome.
- ugh 15y agoIf you use that criterium, you also can’t lump Chrome into that. I would count the engine, not the browser.
- gmartres 15y agoBut Chromium is, and there's no difference between the two beside branding and Chrome shipping with some non-free stuff: https://code.google.com/p/chromium/wiki/ChromiumBrowserVsGoogleChrome https://code.google.com/p/chromium/wiki/ChromiumBrowserVsGoo...
- ugh 15y agoChrome isn’t open source. Full stop. If you don’t count Safari you also can’t count Chrome. I think it’s equally stupid to not count Chrome and Safari.
- skroth 15y agoWhy do you insist on it being black or white? You wouldn't agree that more of Chrome is open source than Safari?
- ugh 15y agoMore … how? What matters is the engine, who cares about the chassis? It would be truly idiotic to include Chrome but to exclude Safari. That just does not make sense. Sure, more of Chrome’s chassis is open source (though not really), but who the hell cares about that? All things considered, Safari and Chrome are both pretty open source. What matters, anyway.
- skroth 15y agoI do? I think the parts of the browser that aren't the rendering engine are important too. That being said, I honestly don't really care about the original argument. I agree that Safari should be included as open source. My point was just that I think Chrome is measurably more open source. I know that's vague and you can quantify by number of lines, whatever. Since Chrome is "more" open source, wouldn't someone be able to fairly draw a line that includes Chrome but not Safari? In my mind where one draws that line is completely subjective. I think where you draw the line is equally subjective. The part where you were treating Chrome and Safari as equal in terms of open-souce-ness is what I disagree with.
- Pewpewarrows 15y agoIf all that mattered was the rendering engine, then Chrome would never have gotten more than 1% browser marketshare, and Firefox would reign supreme. It's pretty obvious to anyone that's paid attention over the last few years that the surrounding UI, Javascript engine, and experience encapsulating the rendering engine is just as important, if not more so. With Chrome basically the entire UI, including preferences, extensions engine, syncing, and automatic and partial updates are completely open source as part of the Chromium project. Chrome merely puts the Google logo on the cover and packages some pieces of software that can't otherwise be distributed due to licensing constraints. Developers don't consider Ubuntu closed-source just because it has the ability to package closed-source software and drivers with it. In short: there's no way you can consider Safari an open-source project. There are several ways to classify Chrome as open-source, to which many developers agree.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- staktrace 15y agoIt depends on what you care about when you say "open". If you care about security/privacy and the fact that you're running potentially Trojan-infected code on your machine, then any non-open code makes a difference.
- TheAmazingIdiot 15y agoThe fact you use a connection to the internet opens yiu to many nefarious means to "screw you over". I can think of subtle things like changing adservers to backbone providers, router protocol redirections, ssl master cert spoofs (care of us govt), and many others. Unless you were the types that freaked out on mm256.dat and nsakey, use standard security and you're fine. If you did freak out, im sure we can work out a GPS-login script that watches location, bloodtype, retinal scan, passphrase, and voice scan to get a guest account.
- nikcub 15y agoGoogle do not promote builds of Chromium since they want users using Chrome. If you want to run Chromium, the open source browser, but do not want to build it yourself, you can download the latest builds (and older builds) for all the different platforms from the buildbot server: http://build.chromium.org/f/chromium/snapshots/ http://build.chromium.org/f/chromium/snapshots/