4 ms·
If you think computation is undefined, you have a much bigger problem than consciousness. We have a physics of information. Computation is operations performed
by ncmncm 5y ago
If you think computation is undefined, you have a much bigger problem than consciousness. We have a physics of information. Computation is operations performed on information. We build machines to do it, on purpose. But a bacterium moving toward a rising gradient of sugar concentration is seen to be computing and acting on the result. The physics involved is in no way mysterious.
- Jensson 5y ago> Computation is operations performed on information. How would you define an operation that doesn't just makes every process in the entire world a computation?
- ncmncm 5y agoSome computations you are interested in, others you are not. You don't have enough interest to go around to every process in the entire world. Nature doesn't distinguish. But we do, for practical reasons.
- Jensson 5y agoSo basically you are saying that computation is either a meaningless concept or it is subjective and therefore doesn't help. Which was my point.
- ncmncm 5y agoNo, computation is objectively observed. But not all computation is equally interesting. What is subjective is just how interested you or somebody is in a particular instance. If what you imagine to be consciousness is a recognizably interesting computation, the details that make it recognizable are objective, but your interest in it as a topic to talk about is purely subjective.