3 ms·

Per this link, the BMW has more trunk space than the Model Y: https://www.volkswagenofdesmoines.com/model-comparisons/2021-vw-id-4-vs-2021-tesla-model-y/ https

Per this link, the BMW has more trunk space than the Model Y: https://www.volkswagenofdesmoines.com/model-comparisons/2021-vw-id-4-vs-2021-tesla-model-y/ https://www.volkswagenofdesmoines.com/model-comparisons/2021... but it hardly matters, it's comes in 2nd to the Model 3/Y in every other category. If ugliness was a category, the ID.4 would certainly win that though!

ajross 5y ago
I haven't seen that number before, and seems somewhat spun having looked closely at both cars. The most commonly cited metric in EV circles is Bjørn Nyland's "banana box" test[1]. Both cars held 9 boxes in the back in a standard configuration, but the Y went up to 26 with the seats folded vs. 25 in the VW. And the Y has a frunk which holds another, where the ID.4 skipped that feature (somewhat inexplicably). The Tesla is also just a somewhat larger car, to the tune of 8cm of width and 17 in length. It's definitely "bigger" for basically all reasonable consumer use cases. I'm sure there's something that fits in it that won't in the Tesla. [1] So-named because, well, it's obvious. Nyland is probably the single best source for EV comparisons out there Definitely a must-follow youtube channel if you're into this stuff.