4 ms·
The left doesnt really have any power in the US. What passes for the left (the socially liberal corporate elites that run most of the democratic party) are pre
by pydry 5y ago
The left doesnt really have any power in the US.
What passes for the left (the socially liberal corporate elites that run most of the democratic party) are pretty much just as invested in protecting the rentiers as the right wing.
Rentier money is structurally geared towards destroying any populist politicians who threaten their rents. It was a fluke that AOC won given her Democratic opponent (when she was unknown) outspent her something like 7:1. People like her arent supposed to slip through the early stage political filter.
If they do slip through there's also an enormously powerful and effective propaganda machine dedicated to character assassination.
- twofornone 5y ago>The left doesnt really have any power in the US Without debating whether the left has political power (hard to question when the administration and majority of house and senate are left leaning), there's no question that "the left" dominates our media and most of our institutions, and controls (often explicitly as with big tech) the boundaries of allowable discourse.
- thebigman433 5y agoThis is so important and I think a lot of people miss it. The "left" that has power in the US (establishment dems) barely qualify as being left at all. They are very much invested in protecting power and wealth. The only "left" that would push against the rentiers are people who will almost never see power. However, I wouldnt say AOC winning is a "fluke". Its definitely the exception, but progressives have been able to repeat it a few more times in democrat strongholds that have historically kept establishment candidates. Right now the only "power" the real left has is withholding their votes from corporate dem bills like we're seeing with the BBB Act. This only even works because the rest of the party is interested in protecting power/wealth and is pretty inept at actually winning races.
- jjcon 5y ago> The "left" that has power in the US (establishment dems) barely qualify as being left at all So when the left does something you dont like, they must not be left? Smells of no true scottsman to me.
- thebigman433 5y agoIm mostly comparing it to the politics of the "left" in most other first world countries. In my opinion, candidates who arent willing to support guaranteed family leave, single payer healthcare, and more progressive taxes, arent very far left. Of course you could definitely make an argument for that being no true scottsman, so I guess it just depends on opinion.
- pydry 5y agoThere's no good argument for this being a no true scotsman. Being pro-rentier is antithetical to almost every definition of left wing. It's also not like Democrats who wear a left wing mask try to trumpet their pro-rentier behavior.
- throw_nbvc1234 5y agoIt's almost like politics isn't as binary as left or right; at least when you get down to the fundamentals and not the media's portrayal of things.
- pydry 5y agoWhat do you call it when party A and party B were strongly in favor of the Iraq war and the opposition (C) comes solely from protestors who have no political representation? A is "the left" to most people. B is the right. C is (apparently) a logical fallacy represented by 3 congresspeople and a senator.
- aviancrane 5y agoI think the "No True Scottsman" fallacy is confusing here. It's actually really sly. The "No True Scottsman" statement must be used as the argument. It has to say that they're wrong BECAUSE they are not a true Scottsman. What OP did was say there is The Left and there is "The Left". The Left is against rentiers. "The Left" supports rentiers. He's dividing the two, but he's not saying one is wrong because they're not true leftists, he's saying one is wrong because they support rentiers. But then he additionally says they're not true leftists, which is to say that a leftists shouldn't support them because they don't align, which is where the smell comes from. The main argument is not a Scottsman fallacy. But there's definitely some implied Scottsmanism in the additional use of Left and "Left", which if read by the right person who is already weak to Scottsmanism will materialize as the Scottsman fallacy. EDIT: I thought you were wrong, but under more analysis, I realized you were right, it was just complicated.
- ashtonkem 5y agoLiberalism is only left wing if it’s being compared against actual monarchists. Nowadays it’s soft right, since we’ve pretty much run out of monarchists (thank god).
- ashtonkem 5y agoAOC was right when she said in a parliamentary system she and joe Biden wouldn’t be in the same party. It’s only a fluke of voting systems that’s compressed a democratic socialist and a liberal into the same party as compared to a coalition government.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]