2 ms·
I wonder how much of the difficulty was in performing the transplant itself, and how much was in justifying the procedure (i.e. working out the ethics). There
by HPsquared 5y ago
I wonder how much of the difficulty was in performing the transplant itself, and how much was in justifying the procedure (i.e. working out the ethics).
There must be a lot of experimental procedures ruled out on ethical grounds because they are untested and therefore are too dangerous to be tested. How common is this type of Catch-22 situation, and how is the deadlock typically broken?
- egeozcan 5y ago> how is the deadlock typically broken A war breaks out and human life becomes less important, or someone/some government does it in secret, or there is something potentially catastrophic that allows some rules to loosen up a bit (like a pandemic).
- BurningFrog 5y agoI've come to think the modern medical "ethics" and "Ethicist" are a huge problem. That gatekeeping kills a lot of people.
- Ginden 5y agoIn Poland, any major medical study on living patients must be approved by bioethics commission of local medical self-government. Somehow, almost all of them have Catholic priest as member. He studied ethics on Catholic university, so he is "qualified".
- BurningFrog 5y agoIt does seem that "ethicist" is a reinvention of the priest concept for a secular community.