3 ms·
In my experience, there is a slight nuance in the frame here. It isn't just that Mr. Luu is "willing to look stupid", it is that he has confidence that his deci
by roenxi 5y ago
In my experience, there is a slight nuance in the frame here. It isn't just that Mr. Luu is "willing to look stupid", it is that he has confidence that his decision making process will on average turn out better decisions than the go-to default strategy that most people employ ("copy the crowd").
Most people, if they rely on their own research and decision making, will do poorly. And even moderately clever people generally do better by copying the rare stray geniuses that float around in polite society. This manifests as an "unwillingness" to "look stupid". It is important to ask "what does stupid mean" and "how do I measure 'looking something'" when this sort of topic is bought up.
I am - and I don't think this is that unusual - willing to go about a decade ignoring the opinions of others if I'm really confident that I have an objectively good idea. It is a high-risk high-reward strategy and not for everyone.
- marginalia_nu 5y ago> It is important to ask [...] "how do I measure 'looking something'" when this sort of topic is bought up. Why is that?
- roenxi 5y ago"Looking stupid" is an assessment of what other people think. Eg, asking for the smallest box isn't stupid - Apple expects all the boxes to be good products. Even picking a product randomly isn't stupid and therefore shouldn't look it. The looking stupid part is an assessment of what the store clerk is thinking. That is a very subtle, fraught and complicated assessment. There is a lot going on to do with the audience, context, risk and the truth. There is a lot going on behind the term "looking stupid" and it undersells the complexity of the social interaction. There are two parties, multiple issues and a lot to think about.
- barrenko 5y agoYes, but in general it's pretty noticeable when someone thinks you're stupid, because when people find a reason to place you "below" so to speak, all kinds of behaviour quickly come out.
- TameAntelope 5y agoPeople are, generally, thinking about you a lot less than you perceive them to be thinking about you. So in general it may seem pretty noticeable, but in reality it's rarely so. > In particular, it's often the case that there's a seemingly obvious but actually incorrect reason something is true, a slightly less obvious reason the thing seems untrue, and then a subtle and complex reason that the thing is actually true. This is a good example of what's in the submission! It's "seemingly obvious" that people are judging you all the time, and slightly less obvious that people aren't actually thinking about you nearly as often as you think, but the few who are thinking about you might be indeed judging you to look stupid for asking "basic" questions.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoYeah, I get that, but why do we need to measure it? (in a context of accepting the possibility)
- dusted 5y agoI think this is a good observation about the impact that confidence can have on some (mine included) peoples ability to learn. In this way, low confidence can have both the direct effect of denying you access to information that would allow you to improve, but also more sinister, it can deny you the mental ability to actually learn something, even if the information was available to you, since the learning itself will mean that there's things you don't know. Being aware that you don't know or can't do something can feel very bad if you lack the confidence in your ability to get to know or do it, and we tend to avoid feeling bad, and so may abandon the endeavor.
- amadeuspagel 5y agoThis is true when it comes to actual decision making, but what about asking questions? Isn't being willing to look stupid clearly important here regardless of how smart you are? Even if you actually are stupid, you'll end up knowing more if you ask stupid questions, then you would have if you tried to hide your stupidity.
- caned 5y ago> Most people, if they rely on their own research and decision making, will do poorly. That's an interesting assertion. I would have guessed the opposite is true.
- genewitch 5y agoHave you never seen a restaurant location that is always changing owners, names, etc? Or downtowns of smaller cities where there's tons of empty shops? Cheesegraters.com ? People are hilariously bad at induction, deduction, and making decisions based on their own research. We're biased because we're already on the internet, on this site, and nothing is on fire in our vicinity.