4 ms·
At least Brave lives up to its name to rid of Google as the default search engine, unlike Mozilla who 14 years ago [0] wanted to move away from them and here we
by rvz 5y ago
At least Brave lives up to its name to rid of Google as the default search engine, unlike Mozilla who 14 years ago [0] wanted to move away from them and here we are they still cannot live without Google's money and support 'privacy'; which to them is a joke.
Feature-wise, everyone knows Firefox is hopeless and far behind and still catching up with the rest of the browsers.
Maybe it's time to move to Brave then.
[0] https://web.archive.org/web/20120105090543/https://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9044160/Mozilla_can_live_without_Google_s_money_Baker_says_ https://web.archive.org/web/20120105090543/https://www.compu...
- perryizgr8 5y agoBrave's operation is all the more impressive when you consider that Mozilla gets $500M every year from Google. I would be surprised if Brave has invested half of that in total over the last several years.
- reducesuffering 5y agoBrave’s total funding has been $42mm. Mozilla burning $500m/yr to accomplish practically nothing is what you get when you push out the technical CEO who is an HN regular, and instead have a lawyer milking it as a resume checkbox. Firefox is losing market share and has no plan B from Google’s generosity. It’s looking inevitable that Google will turn off funding once FF declines a few more years market share. Then it’s Google, Microsoft, Apple as main browsers. SEC has already given the ok for three major players in a market a la T Mobile / Sprint merger.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoYou're comparing apples to an apple orchards. Mozilla produces browser, email client, and calendaring apps (among other things.) Mozilla's nonprofit arm engages in tech advocacy and betterment work, including sponsoring fellowships (looks to be about thirty this year) and innovation awards. The work they fund covers a mind-bogglingly vast range of topics in the humans-and-tech area: https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/what-we-do/ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/what-we-do/ Brave is a browser run by a guy who has done just about every slimy thing he can think of to make money, including donation scamming and affiliate-code insertion.
- Gargyle 5y agoNever heard of any substantial thing there. Most "reports" state obvious things. Never seen anything but vaporware beyond Firefox. Thunderbird does their own thing now. Seamonkey is dead.
- rglullis 5y agoBoth of your accusations of "slimy things done to make money" fail to pass Hanlon's razor. They can be easily attributed to incompetence and even if malicious they would not be that profitable to begin with. Re: Mozilla's "work". What is the point of being so protective of the "apple orchard" and having justification for all the money and resources that it spends, if the results are completely worthless? What is the point of spending HALF A BILLION DOLLARS PER YEAR, and get a web that is increasingly dominated by Big Tech and surveillance capitalism? Who cares about "innovation awards" if all the products they have still depend on the company that exploits consumers and consumer data? I don't want to look at Mozilla and think "oh, but look at all the nice things they are doing". "Niceness" is overrated. We need something that can actually solve the problem. Mozilla is not doing ANY of that, and its CEO is still taking $3M/year home. That is not just slimy, it is diabolical.
- FourthProtocol 5y agoI've been using Firefox since, I don't know, 2006? Maybe 2007? Still use it for everything (note that my web dev ability and interest don't really reach beyond HTML and ASP.Net). My main reasons for using Firefox are it works well and uBlock Origin. What features do other browsers have that Firefox doesn't? What's so compelling about these features? Does Brave still do that ad replacement thing?
- nsonha 5y ago> What features do other browsers have that Firefox this is not a meaningful question. I don't know any major browser that still misses features. If people don't use firefox, it likely that they're not happy with factors such as snappiness, its UI, power usage or synchronization of extensions.
- FourthProtocol 5y agoI agree with you. GP stated "feature-wise".
- rnd0 5y agoWhat's wrong with Ublock Origin on Chrome? Or is there other reasons (read:Google) you don't use Chrome?
- FourthProtocol 5y agoIt is indeed that I will not use anything from Google unless I absolutely have to (doesn't happen often but image search on DDG sometimes misses results Google shows). I'm fortunate in that I have never bought into Gmail, maps or any other product of theirs. I did however sell my London flat without qualms to a Google employee who offered way more money than the asking price.
- TheGoddessInari 5y agohttps://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-works-best-on-Firefox https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-works-b...
- KennyBlanken 5y agoOkay, but...Brave's history includes: * DNS leaks in VPN mode that were reported to them and fixed in nightly builds but not pushed to a public build until the issue attracted attention in social media * inserting referral codes into numerous URLs (most of them cryptocurrency related). They've shifted to silently inserting headers when you hit partner websites that identify you as a Brave browser user * removing ads from sites to put its own ads in place of them * collecting "donations" on content creator's pages, without notice or consent...and pocketing the money if the creator doesn't "claim" the donations * whitelisting Facebook, Twitter, and other tracking * telemetry that cannot be disabled, that includes "non-personally-identifying" usage data * collecting Brave Rewards program crypto-tokens requires providing extensive personal information to their crypto-wallet partners and "may" require fucking biometric verification and authorizing sharing that data with an facial-recognition-based ID verification service. Just use one of the modified builds of Firefox, like Librefox, if you want greater privacy than what Firefox provides out of the box.
- Gargyle 5y agoI currently do not use Brave due to other reasons but still want say: Dns leaks are bad but Brave never was a serious anonymity browser. Just as Firefox never was and Firefox had many real ip behind proxy leaks as well. Firefox also never intendedly prevented dns leaks because it just takes system settings or specific doh settings. Its a dishonest comparison. Still their tor mode is a joke. The referral tags aren't a big thing. They are fixed strings that are the same for every user. They do not identify anyone other than as Brave user, which is trivial anyway due to user agent and fingerprinting. Do you remember that Firefox back in the day did the same when it was underdog? If it makes them money,thats a very privacy and intrusion inexpensive way of getting that. Ad replacement is opt-in only and an actually interesting concept to try fix the spying third party to everything issue. If its not on ads are just blocked. Pocketing money from the Ad-view rewards if not claimed. I can't tell if they are actually pocket or just wait for registration of $creator. How else would they do it? They can't magically find out their bank account. You say they grab donations? Like they actually replace Donation buttons in sites by their own? I haven't heard of that.I only know that you can pay into a Brave Wallet and distribute it to signed up creators. But you have to explicitly pay into Brave and its likely to have read how it works on the way to that. Have a source? Whitelisting Facebook/Twitter tracking? They had a setting for that in main settings. Is it gone? Else give a source or decrypted pcap please. Last time I checked telemetry code (early 2020) there really wasn't anything interesting to correlate in there. KYC for using Brave Wallet breaks the whole vision of the ad replacement thingy. Ack. I hate it. Most modified Firefox builds are extra buggy or make an easy to match browser fingerprint change that makes you unique. Icecat is severely broken. Waterfox can't keep up with releases. More... I use my distros build with custom settings and disabled backchannels. I dont use Brave because their release management is garbage and their team is kinda opaque.
- bitwize 5y agoMozilla is more of a progressive activist organization and fat paycheck for Mitchell Baker than it is a software development organization these days. Do not expect Mozilla to prioritize maintaining Firefox or helping its user base get off Google.
- Gargyle 5y agoAn activist organization that is so intransparent that I don't even get what they are activists for. I have only ever recognized blog posts about interpersonal matters by them which are rather cringy and don't add anything to the preexisting matter. All about first world problems. Do you happen to know what concrete and half effective activism they actually do?
- skinkestek 5y agoI think they were one of the main drivers behind let's encrypt and maybe some other stuff so all is not wasted. My main criticism is that they "milk the cow dry" by extracting so much money from the browser (which is their single largest source of income) that it starves.
- bitwize 5y agoI don't know if any of it is "half-effective" but it's the standard social-justicey things like "women and BIPOC in tech", as well as more recently, alerting people to the dangers of the open internet and pressuring platforms to take more aggressive censorship actions: https://blog.mozilla.org/en/mozilla/we-need-more-than-deplatforming/ https://blog.mozilla.org/en/mozilla/we-need-more-than-deplat... I think Mitchell Baker would rather chair something like the SPLC than an organization merely devoted to the development and maintenance of open source software, and that's what she's turning Mozilla into.