8 ms·
Einstein writes hypothesis. Hypothesis gets submitted to peer review. Peer review passes and grows in acceptance. Peers challenge the idea and try to poke holes
by godelski 5y ago
Einstein writes hypothesis. Hypothesis gets submitted to peer review. Peer review passes and grows in acceptance. Peers challenge the idea and try to poke holes, better proving the hypothesis stands. Peers test implications of hypothesis. Eventually this becomes a theory and consensus is born. That's science working in action. Science depends on consensus. Consensus doesn't mean you're right, but it does mean that no one can find a serious flaw.
- b215826 5y ago> Consensus doesn't mean you're right, but it does mean that no one can find a serious flaw. This assumes a very naive view that the average university researcher is trying to challenge prevailing theories on a daily basis. The reality is that challenging prevailing theories of science is near impossible in today's grant-chasing arena called academia. Do you really think a grant proposal that questions some of the prevailing views in climate science is going to get funded? And even if does get funded, good luck getting it published in any mainstream journal.
- addicted 5y agoThis is hilarious considering there’s trillions of dollars invested in assuming climate change doesn’t exist.
- slt2021 5y agoIf you think that the market is wrong, you are free to bet your money in an opposite side and get rich from being right about climate change. Put your money where your beliefs are, so to speak
- wolverine876 5y agoDo you have solid evidence of these claims?
- tasogare 5y agoAnybody who had a feet for more than 5 minutes in a lab know he's right. Heck I can't even challenge my own supervisors when they make swallow statements that are in fact contradicted by a bunch of papers, how could I get funding from external entities by submitting socially unpopular ideas? Impossible, especially in highly politicized fields.
- wolverine876 5y agoSo, any solid evidence? And even if you did, it wouldn't disprove the consensus on climate change in any way. Or are you also saying that all the research was falsified? Any evidence of that?
- godelski 5y agoReally? I challenge the beliefs of my advisor all the time. There's no ill will between us. In fact, I think he thinks higher of me because I'll challenge him if I think he is wrong. Don't get me wrong, we agree on a lot more than we disagree on, but when we disagree I'm not afraid and we go try to prove who's right. Sometimes it is him, less so me haha.
- jpgvm 5y agoI think your problem here is framing it as "questioning prevailing views". You are setting yourself up for failure by trying to make it about opinions before even doing any science. The correct way to accomplish this is to take something that you think you can disprove, design an experiment that would show that the existing theory may be incorrect and then successfully defend that. Say for instance you hypothesised that methane doesn't in fact act as a greenhouse gas, you design an experiment that shows that increasing the % methane in the upper atmosphere doesn't result in additional heat being captured. You would then need to collect the results, properly show they are consistent with your hypothesis vs your control data and then defend that in peer review. In this case you would most likely be wrong because we are pretty damn sure methane isn't great but if you had an idea that had a chance I am sure you could get funding. It is worth mentioning that the ability to get funding is somewhat correlated with the interestingness and likelihood of a groundbreaking finding. Finding methane is not contributing to greenhouse effect would be a massive finding, however the likelihood it isn't is low because there already exists a huge body of evidence that supports the opposite conclusion. TLDR: You can definitely work on attempting to prove climate change isn't happening but you probably need a very clever idea as everyone else that has looked at it thus far hasn't come up with anything capable of disproving it.
- bryanrasmussen 5y ago>Do you really think a grant proposal that questions some of the prevailing views in climate science is going to get funded? I would assume that there are organizations that try to fund proposals that question some of the prevailing views in climate science otherwise where do all these papers come from that anti-climate change people like to refer to?
- crummy 5y ago> Do you really think a grant proposal that questions some of the prevailing views in climate science is going to get funded? Wouldn't there be a bunch of companies with a lot of wealth and strong incentives to fund that sort of thing?
- addicted 5y agoBut here’s the thing. Why does every fossil fuel company accept the science of climate change. Not just that they are unable to get their contrarian studies published in academic papers. No, they literally spend a ton of money in Super Bowl ads trying to convince the world that they are trying to reduce climate change. And they have pages on their websites: BP: https://www.bp.com/en/global/corporate/sustainability.html https://www.bp.com/en/global/corporate/sustainability.html Exxon: https://corporate.exxonmobil.com/Sustainability/Environmental-protection/Climate-change https://corporate.exxonmobil.com/Sustainability/Environmenta... There’s almost no organization other than the American right in the world that currently denies the reality of climate change.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- proc0 5y ago> Science depends on consensus. No, science depends on falsifiable theories being tested and proved. The whole point of science is to remove flawed, human bias, of which consensus depends on.
- addicted 5y agoAnd who decides whether a theory is “proved”? I’m guessing you think God comes down to earth to announce that yea, this theory is proven!
- wolverine876 5y agoDo you only rely on God? Where do you get information, other than from other humans?
- proc0 5y ago> And who decides whether a theory is “proved”? The tests passing or failing. And sure, the tests are designed by humans, but that's why there are controls, and there is no limit on how many tests per hypothesis. Each test can improve on the previous one, every time removing more and more of the bias, if needed.
- godelski 5y ago> The tests passing or failing. This is what I'm calling consensus btw. Because in science we don't just trust the experiments of a single person or group. They present it, we say "wow that's cool. Let me try to poke holes in it" and then a bunch of people do that and we gain strong evidence that that person was correct.
- bjt2n3904 5y agoThe scientific method cannot "prove" things, only disprove.
- areyousure 5y ago> Einstein writes hypothesis. Hypothesis gets submitted to peer review. Peer review passes and grows in acceptance. This is ahistorical. The Annalen der Physik, where Einstein's four Annus Mirabilis papers were published, did not have peer review. Only one paper by Einstein was peer reviewed. It was -- in effect -- rejected from Physical Review. While the paper ("Do Gravitational Waves Exist?", with Rosen) was mistaken (in its conclusion of "no"), even then the referee wrote that Einstein "is a man of good scientific standing, and it would seem to me that if he insists, he has more right to be heard than any single referee has to throttle!"
- godelski 5y ago> papers were published, did not have peer review. We post papers on ArXiv now and they don't have "peer review", except they do because our peers read them and talk about them, open issues on GitHub, exchange emails, and write blogs. If that isn't peer review, I don't know what is. Your definition of peer review is far too limited and not what science actually is doing.
- areyousure 5y ago"Peer review" these days usually refers to pre-publication peer review. This is the mainstream usage, as demonstrated by Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peer_review#Scholarly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peer_review#Scholarly or even better by Wiktionary: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/peer_review https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/peer_review However, I agree that in the context of this thread, post-publication peer review -- usually referred to by another name -- is very important, as it plays a strong role in the formation of consensus being discussed.
- godelski 5y agoThat's the usual case, but not the only case. Like you said, publication review didn't happen back then. But yet peer review has still been happening in science for thousands of years. People still judge researchers based on h-index, which just means number of citations. Yeah, publishing in high impact conferences helps influence that, but it isn't necessary to the process. But peer review (in the more broader sense) is still essential to the process of science. Publication review is really only one step in the peer review process.