4 ms·
Bit of an aside, but it's only a "1000:1" problem because - The response can't have a blast radius - Human software systems can't be formally verified in a tr
by echelon 5y ago
Bit of an aside, but it's only a "1000:1" problem because
- The response can't have a blast radius
- Human software systems can't be formally verified in a tractable amount of time
- etc.
I'd go as far as to wager that if it weren't for MAD, the US might be sending SEAL or Special Forces teams in to deal with hackers.
When we have an AGI, perhaps it will develop systems impervious to intrusion. Or maybe it'll take the simpler approach and eradicate all humans and other capable AI actors.
This is expensive because it's guerrilla warfare.
- Retric 5y agoAt one point we came relatively close to using a nuke to deal with a hacking attempt, though taking down NORAD is going to get people nervous. Not everyone can respond to hackers by building an independent global network, but it is one model.
- jay3ss 5y ago> At one point we came relatively close to using a nuke to deal with a hacking attempt Do you have a source on this? Sounds like an interesting read
- Retric 5y agoUnfortunately it was a first hand account, solar sunrise 1998 was the event but many of the details aren’t exactly public. The critical bits where it was being routed through a compromised machine in Baghdad, many DoD systems where running email alongside more mission critical applications, and the timing was the lead up to the first Iraq war.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"At one point we came relatively close to using a nuke to deal with a hacking attempt" That sounds like wet dream of a genocidal maniac. There is no way this claim is credible
- Retric 5y agoRead up on solar sunrise, a infosec teacher of mine was involved on the Army side and said it was seriously being considered because of timing and email being run on some extremely mission critical systems. This was lead up to first Iraq war and things where being routed through a machine in Baghdad. So, the possibility that this was a military attack was seriously being considered. And no I don’t think it was likely, but there’s only so many time in history senior military people have referred to nuking something in a non joking manner.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoHaving just read a couple articles about it, I see no reference to nuclear strike anywhere. Do you understand that proposition is to commit genocide at a minimum, and maybe start WW3? If you wanted to use military force, you would create a power blackout in target area by destroying closest substation or powerplant. "In the end, two California High School students were arrested and pled guilty. Their mentor, an 18 year-old Israeli, was also arrested" Surely noone is mad enough to nuke their own country? Or would you nuke the wrong ciutry instead?
- Retric 5y agoArticles are written after the conclusion was already reached. In the moment you don’t know who’s behind the attack just that you can’t tell if ICBM’s are incoming to the US and the attack seems to be coming from a country we are literately preparing to go to war with. It’s that moment the options are to successfully hack the machine, do nothing and hope no physical attack is incoming, try and penetrate serious air defenses with conventional aircraft, or use an ICBM. I don’t mean to suggest people where requesting authorization from the president for a nuclear strike, just that it was considered which is a serious escalation for a cyber attack. As to the articles, you will note Iraq is mentioned many times by military officials even the attacks originated from teens in the US and Israel. Some of that’s timing, but the other part is as I said the machine happened to be located in Baghdad. Also, the press briefing before they arrested the teens shows just how serious this was being taken. It really wasn’t business as usual.