2 ms·
Architectural beauty is heavily dependent on context. Ornate gothic architecture, for example, peaked in popularity in the USA around 1870 and fell out of style
by paxys 5y ago
Architectural beauty is heavily dependent on context. Ornate gothic architecture, for example, peaked in popularity in the USA around 1870 and fell out of style in the early 1900s. Interest in it was revived in the late 20th century, so the same neighborhoods that would have been considered ugly and outdated 60 years ago are now "beautiful" again.
A lot of it is also about uniqueness. The author is rightly awed by pre-war architecture in Europe when he travels, but tourists worldwide are similarly fascinated by glass skyscrapers in New York.
Talking at the neighborhood level, houses constructed today are meant to be more transient vs those from the last century. Builders (whether a property developer or individual resident) will consider sale and resale value first and foremost before anything else. A "unique" house will have far less buyer interest.
- perpetualpatzer 5y agoYour transient point is very appealing to me. The line of thinking that people move more-> lower incentive to build custom-> cheaper finishes/less creativity feels logical and can be tidily appended to the Enrico Moretti argument that economic opportunity has concentrated in the cities-> more people detach from their hometowns to chase opportunity. There are two pieces of information that I struggle to integrate into this model and would be interested in how others reconcile: 1) US census data suggests (surprisingly!) that the % of residents moving each year has declined significantly since 1990, and before that was about the same back to the first data collected in the mid 40s (though with some collection gaps) [1] 2) Anecdata: most of the new builds I see around me (Boston MSA) are luxury apartment buildings or way out in the suburbs. The former aren't quaint, but are decidedly custom architecture. The latter, I stereotype as "folks settling down in the suburbs". Maybe McMansions, but I wouldn't expect transient. This one might just be a sampling error on my part. [1]https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2016/cb16-189.html https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2016/cb16-189...
- gremloni 5y agoOn the surface what you’re saying sounds right but the only example I can think of is neo-brutalism though there aesthetics was never the point.