10 ms·
I thought the passages below were key. Instead of the constant "Tall Poppy Syndrome" that many education "reformers" engage in, would be better to improve these
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I thought the passages below were key. Instead of the constant "Tall Poppy Syndrome" that many education "reformers" engage in, would be better to improve these programs for a wider array of students:
> If advocates of equity are bothered by anything with “gifted and talented programs,” it should be their names. The program’s names might insinuate not every child has gifts; instead, they should be rebranded as “accelerated learning programs” or another name that avoids implying that only certain children are gifted. In addition, equity-minded education reformers could also identify problems within the gifted programs instead of canceling them altogether.
> For example, gifted programs notoriously have a problem identifying the students who are fit for their programs, usually resulting in racial disparities. Reformers could advocate for solutions that better identify which children who are advanced by changing current admittance approaches, considering that students are admitted mainly based on standardized testing performance.
- hintymad 5y agoI don't get it, either. We also recognize that NBA guys are amazing athletes who few people could every dream of becoming, then why can't we acknowledge that some people are born better at academics? Do people really think that anyone can become Terrance Tao, who could clearly articulate what a group is at age 7?
- slownews45 5y agoI think IQ testing is prohibited at least in California for African American's? Is this true? Does this extend to things like admissions exams for gifted programs?
- thegrimmest 5y agoAre you saying you agree? It seems bordering on absurd to me. Why can't it be true that not every child has gifts? Isn't the point of being exceptional having qualities that set you apart from most people? Are there no exceptional children? Adults? In regards to identifying, I fail to see how IQ tests are racially biased, even if the results are not perfectly representative of racial diversity. Do you?
- bcrosby95 5y agoYou know what is absurd? How about the idea that you should segment children at a young age, before they are anywhere close to fully developed mentally, emotionally, or physically, and publicly label some as "gifted" and some as "normal". What could possibly go wrong? Dumbest fucking idea ever.
- mbrodersen 5y agoI was a year ahead in math as a kid and was bored out of my skull with the slow pace of teaching. Being able to join a class of likeminded kids would have been brilliant.
- fighterpilot 5y agoThe only part of that which is dumb is the ill-advised label, which can easily be changed. Everything else makes sense. Borderline intellectually disabled people and Terence Tao-level prodigies should not be in the same class. That is the dumbest fucking idea ever.
- jlawson 5y agoIt's a simple recognition of an observable and predictive reality - that some people are much more intellectually capable than others. Do you disagree that this is a fact? Recognizing reality and adapting to it is the opposite of dumb. The label could change but it wouldn't make much difference except for politically.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoThose people are one in a million. The vast majority of "gifted" programs will never encounter a single child like that in the history of their school.
- angelzen 5y agoThe critique is fair. I suspect the original 'test kids in Kindergarten and fast track the best performing for the next 12 years' has its roots in the Sputnik moment and the need to rapidly create a high performing STEM population. Accuracy wasn't necessarily a primary goal. That being said, not sure what the alternative is. On one hand, challenging students to the limit of their abilities and bump them higher as soon as they exhaust a level is a laudable goal. Alas, as long as the educational pedigree is used in competitive scenarios (grant, internships, jobs), this will simply create an inflationary pressure to bump everyone to the top level and degrade the top level quality to the lowest common denominator. We are missing a objective bar, for example a hard standardized exam to gate college admissions. Such an exam becomes an incentive for developing strong programs. Time to take a clue from China's gaokao. Alas this requires that we come to terms that not all schools, not all programs, not all demographics, not all kids are equal, which doesn't seem to be something XXI century America is willing to publicly accept.
- FFRefresh 5y agoIt does seem like our culture (and perhaps humans more broadly) obsesses over the superficial veneer of words/semantics, instead of the underlying reality that the words represent. For example, I believe this conversation around these programs would be different if they were called something like the "Harder work program".
- TigeriusKirk 5y agoMy high school program was called the Accelerated Learning Program way back in the 1980s. Is that not a common name for it? I hated when any teacher referred to me as gifted, incidentally. I thought it had an implication that my performance was bestowed on me from some outside power. A little too woo-woo for my teenage self.