3 ms·
Why? I feel like you're just asserting disagreement without argument here. I think this is primarily a philosophical dispute on the nature of symbols, where bo
by bawolff 5y ago
Why?
I feel like you're just asserting disagreement without argument here. I think this is primarily a philosophical dispute on the nature of symbols, where both are just different foundations leading to the same concept. But if my take is backwards or wrong, then it should lead to some disconnect between it and what people mean by symbol in practise. So what is it?
> The whole point of symbols is that they retain their essential properties through a variety of changes in their physical appearance.
Whether they keep essential properties through multiple physical forms or whether many different unique symbols all point to the same (non physically realizable) "form". Doesn't seem materially different to me, just different foundations for the same idea.
- lisper 5y ago> Doesn't seem materially different to me It isn't. It's the same idea expressed with different words. But what matters about symbols, the thing that makes them useful, is that there is a mapping from a potentially infinite number of physical things to a finite number of Platonic ideals or whatever you want to call them. Whether you want to call "4" and "four" the "same symbol" or "different symbols denoting the same concept" doesn't matter. What matters, the source of the utility, is that there is a finite number of equivalence classes that the physical things can be unambiguously mapped to.
- bawolff 5y ago> It isn't. It's the same idea expressed with different words. But one is "backwards" and one is not? > is that there is a finite number of equivalence classes that the physical things can be unambiguously mapped to. Unambigious is quite a claim. Is 3.0 and 3 the same symbol on your view? Depending on context they might denote the same idea (the number three). Other times maybe 3 is an integer and 3.0 is a float and their types are important. Sometimes my computer spits out 10 to mean the sixtenth natural number, sometimes the second natural number, sometimes the tenth natural number. Its all the same physical thing, however what other physical things its equivalent to depends on context.
- lisper 5y ago> Unambigious is quite a claim. No, it's not. The symbol systems used for math are deliberately engineered to make this true. > Is 3.0 and 3 the same symbol on your view? Depending on context Exactly. It depends on the context. Sometimes "A" and "a" ArE tHe SaMe SyMbOl, SoMeTiMeS tHeY aReN't. (Sometimes "Y" and "TH" are the same symbol! [1]) Likewise, sometimes "3.0" and "3" are the same symbol, sometimes they aren't. But within a given context, in order to qualify as math, the mapping has to be unambiguous. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVVTk7yy4kU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVVTk7yy4kU