2 ms·
Sokal did lose the Science Wars, but TFA has no idea why. The clearest way to see it is this: who was he fighting against? Derrida? He never heard of Sokal. So
by jfengel 5y ago
Sokal did lose the Science Wars, but TFA has no idea why.
The clearest way to see it is this: who was he fighting against? Derrida? He never heard of Sokal. Social Text? Have you ever heard of Social Text except in the context of Sokal?
Sokal lost the science wars because he was the only one who showed up. He defeated nobody, because there wasn't anybody there.
Social Text published a paper they didn't understand... because that's what they do. They are looking to get outside conventional patterns of thought. They're the kinds of things that sound silly by definition. If it was something you understood at first glance, it wouldn't be very interesting.
That made them easy to hoax, and he did. Their mistake was publishing somebody who didn't read their journal and engage with the material. More broadly, the whole movement tended to be disconnected: people spoke and few listened.
And that's the mistake Commentary is making now. They're not listening. Social Text, and the movements that it spawned, are trying to solve real problems facing society. People suffer, and that's harder to solve than a physics problem because the solutions are murky even in the best case. The murkiness is genuine cause for caution -- but Commentary uses that to dismiss the problems, and that's even worse.