3 ms·
Why must you persist in trolling Microsoft articles on HN? I don't get the discontinuity between your comments regarding WP7 and WebOS. They both came late to
by runjake 15y ago
Why must you persist in trolling Microsoft articles on HN? I don't get the discontinuity between your comments regarding WP7 and WebOS.
They both came late to the game, were largely lacking and underpowered. WebOS devices have shown similarly dismal sales to WP7 devices. Something doesn't have to fly off the shelves to be a shame.
Your first gripes accurately describe the iPhone, by the way, and it hardly ended up being a market failure, especially after it matured a year or so.
PS: And WebOS is no PalmOS, IMHO. PalmOS was the definition of simple and elegant.
- rbanffy 15y ago> They both came late to the game, were largely lacking and underpowered. I happen to own a Pre 2 and it's really sweet. While the original Pre may have been a little bit slower, the 2 is very comfortable to use. It had multi-tasking and a functional clipboard from day one too (it baffles me how would anyone launch a smartphone without it) and came from a company with very limited resources that was literally betting itself on the product. The only problem I see with WebOS is the lack of applications. WP7, OTOH, was aimed at phones with better specs than the Pre and it is very comfortable to use from the little I played with it, but was launched without a clipboard years after the iPhone had one and multi-tasking was introduced only in Mango. It comes from a company with pretty much unlimited resources and that has been developing mobile operating systems (they ate Palm's lunch once) for more than a decade. Are you sure you want to contrast what Palm achieved with what Microsoft did? > PS: And WebOS is no PalmOS, IMHO. PalmOS was the definition of simple and elegant. I can tell you from my own experience it's orders of magnitude more practical to use (as in "less typing/swiping/touching) than either iOS or vanilla Android. The attention to every little detail is absolutely impressive and the "Just type" interface, simply brilliant.
- polyfractal 15y agoI fail to see how the size of the company should affect one's perception of an OS. If WP7 was made by two greasy dudes in their basement, I would still think it is just as nice. I've used the clipboard once since they've updated WP7 with it, but perhaps I'm just not a smartphone power user. Regarding multitasking, frankly I like iOS/WP7 solution far better than Android. Android runs fully background tasks, meaning all those poorly coded applications can chew away at your memory, cpu and battery life. The iPhone forces apps to hibernate, or at most keep one thread open for background processing or streaming. The rest of the app is suspended. WP7 allows tombstoning your application and you can push updates through Live Tiles. With Mango WP7 will operate basically like the iPhone.
- rbanffy 15y ago> If WP7 was made by two greasy dudes in their basement, I would still think it is just as nice. It would be a lot more impressive. > I've used the clipboard once since they've updated WP7 with it I use it regularly with e-mail. Without it, e-mail becomes that long sausage of quoted text and most readers can't quite figure out what are you taking about. It spares me a lot of re-explaining. Not to say re-typing (which, in a small keyboard, is great) > Regarding multitasking, frankly I like iOS/WP7 solution far better than Android. I tend to agree with that. There is something in the Android way of killing apps that feels wrong, but the way it manages the app lifecycle (inactivating, preserving state, killing) automatically has its own intrinsic virtues. I like the way WebOS does it with cards. I feel iOS is a little bit confusing. Never experimented with Mango (WP7 has more registered developers in Brazil than phones sold), so, no first-hand experience with it here.
- runjake 15y agoAnd this is why he prefers WP7 and you prefer WebOS. But then again, this was a WP7 topic -- perhaps you should submit more WebOS topics to evangelize in?
- rbanffy 15y agoI started this thread pointing out how silly is the idea that phone makers will invest money in a product that has been, so far, a failure (because, let's face it, the general public doesn't want it) from a company that is doing patent extortion with them, that already has a partnership (and that's quite an understatement) with a huge competitor - Nokia - just because the largest contributor to the open-source software you use bought one of your competitors, despite the fact it has, repeatedly, stated the acquired company will operate as a separate business and will not enjoy privileged status. Ignoring the fact that now Google has 17000+ more patents to defend its partners against extortion. And don't forget, even desperate as it was, Nokia wouldn't have gone WP7 without the billion or so Microsoft paid them. I mentioned WebOS just to point out it's slick too. Sadly, this has not translated well in sales. There may be some more WP7 phones in the future, but I am quite sure it's not because companies fear Motorola will enjoy preferred partner status.
- runjake 15y agoI've spent quite a bit of time with a Pre2 and a pre-production Pre3 (and a TouchPad, but you'll probably use that "we're talking about smartphones, not tablets" line on me). I'm not overly impressed with WebOS. It's sluggish and not that nice to look at. The development tools are outstanding, though. WP7 ... was launched without a clipboard years after the iPhone had one and multi-tasking was introduced only in Mango. The iPhone was launched years after the multitasking, clipboarding mobiles OSes Symbian, Windows Mobile, BB OS etc. Again, I'm not sure you have a point, other than feeling the need to express your bias. I can tell you from my own experience it's orders of magnitude more practical to use (as in "less typing/swiping/touching) than either iOS or vanilla Android. The attention to every little detail is absolutely impressive and the "Just type" interface, simply brilliant. FOR YOU. But people have different tastes. Sorry, I'd take iOS, Android, or WP7 over WebOS any day. It was a nice dream, but Palm has had 2 years to pan it out and they've failed. About the only thing I find brilliant is the app card switching and dismissing. No WebOS smartphone or tablet has sold well. The Pre3 hardware is already outdated and it's not even out in the US yet. You tend to share your thoughts quite a bit in the WP7 threads, so you have a pretty high interest in it. I assume you're considering switching over? ;)