2 ms·
> It would be "better" to burn coal and plant new trees than to burn wood and plant new trees. From a purely CO2 perspective, trees are just stores of carbon,
by wongarsu 5y ago
> It would be "better" to burn coal and plant new trees than to burn wood and plant new trees.
From a purely CO2 perspective, trees are just stores of carbon, just like coal. I don't get how one is better to burn than the other? If anything that should come out in favor of burning trees, because wood contains more hydrogen bonds (that oxidize to H2O instead of CO2) and because newly planted trees grow much better in logged forests than they do in coal mines.
- dvdkhlng 5y agoThe difference is that coal contains carbon that has been locked inside the earth's surface for at least a few million years (if not longer). Trees on the other hand contain carbon that those trees extracted from atmospheric CO2 while growing. Burning those trees merely returns CO2 to the atmosphere that was taken from it a few decades ago. If you do that in a balanced way (growing the same amount of trees that you burn at any point of time), you may create a cycle that does not affect long-term atmospheric CO2 concentration.