5 ms·
Audio tape interface revives microcassettes as storage medium
- hammock 5y ago>common disturbances like speed variations (which cause wow and flutter) Had to look that up. What they call "slow wow" that is common in turntable records makes sense though as onomatopoeia. https://www.britannica.com/technology/flutter https://www.britannica.com/technology/flutter
- anyfoo 5y agoSuper common terms for analog media, tape in various forms (like reel to reel) is very old after all, and it's easy to imagine that the motors driving them exhibit significant speed variations during playback. There were also dedicated wow and flutter meters that measured both: You'd play a fixed frequency tone and it would display the frequency variation of what actually came out. Technically that's a form of frequency modulation, with wow and flutter being modulated with low and high frequencies respectively[1]. Later "quartz locked" high precision drives for example got rid of most of it, but as I recall that got widespread briefly before or even at the same time as CDs, and was far from ubiquitous. [1] The "high" frequency here still being much lower than what you usually think about when you read "high frequency" even in an audio context.
- p1mrx 5y agoI wonder what the maximum bitrate of an audio cassette is, using modern encoding techniques like OFDM with error correction? I searched once, and saw estimates in the 25 kbps range, but no usable implementation.
- LeoPanthera 5y agoThe sound quality of an audio cassette is at least as good, and almost certainly better, than the quality of an analogue telephone line. So I bet you could set a lower bound of at least 33.6kbit/s, since that was as fast as telephone modems went. 56k modems relied on your phone line being digital after the switchboard, but I would imagine that 56k should be doable as well.
- p1mrx 5y agoI wouldn't automatically assume that tape is better than a phone line. For instance, a phone line will always clock at 1 second per second, because everything runs in real time with no storage.
- LeoPanthera 5y agoI can’t imagine that clock recovery would make a huge amount of difference.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoAnalog phone lines were limited to 4 KHz frequency range in the US. Compare that to tapes close to 20 KHz.
- Const-me 5y agoNot sure it's directly comparable. When modem flips one bit, the CRC checksum in IP packet becomes incorrect, someone drops the IP packet, the condition is detected and the packet is re-transmitted. This slows down things substantially but user still gets their data. I think tapes need more reliability because there's only 1 try.
- LeoPanthera 5y agoI remember back in the 80s when my BBC Micro would miss a bit it would just beep and tell you to "Rewind tape", which meant, go back about 10 seconds. And then it would figure it out from there.
- tenebrisalietum 5y agoThe Commodore 64 (and possibly earlier Commodore systems such as the PET and VIC20) actually recorded each "block" twice on the tape, and could correct up to 31 errors per block as long as an error didn't affect the same exact byte in each block (it didn't do anything like ECC). This also made loading/saving from tape really slow - 50bps.
- sprash 5y agoI was able to fit about 60 MB per channel on a 90 min audio cassette [1]. The bias frequency of that particular deck was about 60 kHz. This means bypassing the recording circuitry could lead to much higher data rates. 1.: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28193079 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28193079
- tyingq 5y agoThey were getting 33.6kbps out of a fully analog phone line with 300Hz-4Khz usable frequency range. Depends on the equipment and tape, but I imagine even cheapish equipment would have at least twice that amount of bandwidth to work with, maybe even up to 10-12kHz instead of a 4kHz top end. High end equipment and high end tape shows up to ~20kHz or so: https://audiochrome.blogspot.com/2019/12/cassette-tape-comparative-measurements.html https://audiochrome.blogspot.com/2019/12/cassette-tape-compa...
- femto 5y agoS/N for a cassette is variously given as 50dB, 58dB or 67dB [1,2]. Bandwidth is given as 12kHz (standard), 16kH (medium Fi), 19kHz (HiFi) for different quality cassette systems [3]. Let's simplify by assuming the frequency cutoff is a brick wall and the S/N is constant across the band. The maximum channel capacity for a cassette can be calculated using Shannon's Theorem [4]: C = B*log2(S/N+1) Cheap and cheerful (S/N=50dB, B=12kHz): C= 199kbit/s Mid range (S/N=58dB, B=16kHz): C= 297kbit/s Hi Fi (S/N=67dB, B=19kHz): C= 422kbit/s Modern coding (LPDC) can achieve within a fraction of a dB of the Shannon Bound, so those numbers will be close to what a state-of-the-art encoding could do with a cassette. (A new hobby for someone?) [1] http://www.tapeheads.net/showthread.php?t=35390 http://www.tapeheads.net/showthread.php?t=35390 [2] http://www.muzines.co.uk/articles/choosing-a-cassette-tape/1249 http://www.muzines.co.uk/articles/choosing-a-cassette-tape/1... [3] https://arstechnica.com/civis/viewtopic.php?t=848978 https://arstechnica.com/civis/viewtopic.php?t=848978 [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shannon%E2%80%93Hartley_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shannon%E2%80%93Hartley_theore... Edit: Here's a dose of reality from another forum: https://dsp.stackexchange.com/questions/70700/why-can-so-little-digital-information-be-stored-on-a-cassette-tape https://dsp.stackexchange.com/questions/70700/why-can-so-lit... My guess is the the Shannon based predictions are realistic, as they are lower than the same rates as achieved by specialised data recording systems. They are also a bit better than what a narrow band radio system can achieve, and a cassette will be a better channel than a typical radio channel.
- adrianmonk 5y agoThere's also stereo to consider, right? So you could get up to 2X bandwidth. (Channel separation issues might mean less than 2X in practice, though.) If you want to stretch the definition of "cassette", tapes are two-sided, and there were 4-track recorders that used all 4 tracks in one direction. They weren't anything too exotic. Musicians used them for cheap recordings for demos and such.
- hulitu 5y agoYou don't want stereo. Only as an error correction maybe.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoThose were great little recorders. Pricy, but good. I bought one from a guy at work for $190. He paid $269.00 They are extremely well made. It still works today. I think he was trying to get our possed boss to say something incriminating. I didn't have the heart to tell him being a a-hole in America is legal.
- LesserEvil665 5y agoI remember 6/7-year-old me begging my father for a tape deck to use with CoCo3. He refused, saying they were too expensive. Were they really in the early 90s? I doubt it. I lost interest in writing basic on that thing since I couldn't save programs. Anyway, I fully intend to try this out if only to close that loop.
- sedatk 5y agoI had a similar experience with disk drives. They were too expensive, so I had to stick to the built-in tape unit of my Amstrad CPC464. I could save programs, which made a huge difference, but tape was very limited in capability. For example, I couldn't write programs running other arbitrary programs, or programs working on databases. What I wrote was very limited in utility, usually games. Even running an assembler (which I got to hold on very late anyway) was a quite complicated process on tape. Now, after reading your story, I can't imagine being even without a tape. I at least managed to learn BASIC and Z80 Assembly with just a tape.
- tyingq 5y agoThe "ready to use" one with the 5 pin DIN connector/adapter was probably expensive.[1] Otherwise, he would have had to find an adapter or fiddle making one himself. And even that would require a cassette player with all the right jacks (mono in, mono out, remote). They didn't all have those. [1] This thing: https://colorcomputerarchive.com/repo/Documents/Manuals/Hardware/CCR-82%20Manual%20(Tandy).pdf https://colorcomputerarchive.com/repo/Documents/Manuals/Hard... Edit: An old ad...$59.95 Or $142 if inflation adjusted to 2021 from 1987. http://www.trs-80.com/images/desc/desc-cat-rs-26-1208.jpg http://www.trs-80.com/images/desc/desc-cat-rs-26-1208.jpg
- rahimnathwani 5y agoNo one here can tell you whether your father was right or wrong. A tape deck and connection cable would have cost $35-$60 in the early 90s, which your father might have seen as closer to: A) A week's groceries for the whole family, or B) A single evening's entertainment for one person.
- deleted 5y ago
- LeoPanthera 5y agoMicrocassette, despite being best known for use in answering machines and voice recorders, was briefly a pre-recorded music format. There was even a microcassette deck component you could put in your hifi. A video about it: https://youtu.be/ZZYpPlpD3ow https://youtu.be/ZZYpPlpD3ow
- fnord77 5y agoI remember data storage on regular cassette tapes was painfully slow.
- kabdib 5y agoI used audio cassette for a few years (1978-1979) on my home-built Z-80 system. Upgraded to a wacky cassette transport called a Phi-Deck. It was faster and had automated head control and seek; you could do a real file system on it. 9600 baud equivalent, for the setup I used; could get 100K or so on a cassette if you were patient. https://bytecollector.com/dg_phideck.htm https://bytecollector.com/dg_phideck.htm
- squarefoot 5y agoI did something similar in the early nineties by using the venerable AM7910, an old modem chip often used in vintage computer and Ham Radio gear, to make an interface to store and retrieve data on tape from my Amiga 500. I used a normal cassette deck for storing, but the chip was really slow at 1200 bps, even for an old system like AmigaOS, and per data sheet it didn't offer higher speeds, however I tried anyway to change its clock frequency by testing a few Xtals in place of its 2.4576 MHz standard one, and eventually settled to an old PAL color TV Xtal (4.433619 MHz) that would nearly double the speed without introducing errors. Good old times...
- huachimingo 5y agoTangentially related: Minimodem http://www.whence.com/minimodem/ http://www.whence.com/minimodem/ There is an option to translate files to audio and emit them.
- brian-armstrong 5y agoOut of curiosity I tried to do this using Quiet Modem, and the clocking was so much worse than I could have anticipated. I got a used deck from ebay that was in reasonably good condition. Listening to a tape on it, it didn't sound too bad, but when I did some analysis on a waveform on a tape, the playback speed was very uneven. Clock recovery is an absolute must with these, and in general I think it's worse than you'd imagine. Maybe if you had completely bulletproof internals could you actually make full use of the bandwidth.
- eggy 5y agoI had a normal size cassette player built into my Commodore PET 2001 back in 1977/78. Tape speeds are slow, but then again most of my programs were under 100 lines with some outliers at 250 to 350. Not a lot even for a cassette drive. Nostalgia of having to hit 'Play' button to load the program!