2 ms·
I don't think the fingerprinting capabilities are caused by malice on the behalf of Mozilla or Google. Even if they made $0.00 from ad revenue, they would stil
by jiggawatts 5y ago
I don't think the fingerprinting capabilities are caused by malice on the behalf of Mozilla or Google.
Even if they made $0.00 from ad revenue, they would still be on the losing side of the battle against tracking. You can't have many features without exposing something about the client. As soon as you have things like multiple versions, optional features, plugins, and UI metrics, you've lost the battle already. Just your fonts alone can identify you to a reasonable accuracy.
How would you solve this problem? Have everyone run the exact same browser in a virtual machine sandbox, with all traffic running through a common VPN? No plugins, ever? No i18n? No preferences of any type? Upscale a fixed-sized image to your screen's physical resolution and just learn to live with the blur?
That's where you'd have to begin, but I guarantee the ad people would find a way around it. Key press cadence timing. Mouse movement patterns. Something. They'll find a way.
- mathnmusic 5y agoThe first principle should be to separate "documents" from "webapps". An article on NYTimes should be classified as a document which comes with a sandbox with minimal data collection. Of course, as things stand, every site wants to become an app because that's how the incentives are set up. "Apps" - which can collect more data - should come with significant user friction: permissions dialog, standardized ToS, disclosures etc. Similarly, sites that offer "documents" (i.e. no tracking), should be incentivized in other ways (share button, micropayments etc). There's a lot that can be done.
- 0xy 5y agoEvery data point represents more bits of information used to identify users. I would believe Mozilla and Google were good actors if they went back and cleaned up their security vulnerability "Web APIs" when they get used almost exclusively for fingerprinting. They don't make any attempt to fix the vulnerabilities, they simply add more. Coincidentally, their ad clients directly benefit. Ain't that something.