4 ms·
It doesn't seem as good. My first search: what's the latest minecraft version Brave: 1.14.4 Google: 1.17 Brave gives me the wrong answer that is outdated by
by charcircuit 5y ago
It doesn't seem as good. My first search: what's the latest minecraft version
Brave: 1.14.4
Google: 1.17
Brave gives me the wrong answer that is outdated by like 2 years.
Second search: 白の意味
Brave: On Japan location 6 garbage search results + irrelevant wikipedia page. On United states 3 garbage search results before a relevant result. The first result is literally a private YouTube video. Seriously?
Google: Has a snippet about the meaning of white and the first result is a dictionary entry.
The indexing for Google seems to be equally as private, so brave search just seems like a downgrade.
- moralestapia 5y agoGood job! $0.01 has been credited to your Google account. On a more serious tone, the quality of Google search results is continuously degrading.
- charcircuit 5y ago>Good job! $0.01 has been credited to your Google account. If anyone should be paying me it should be Brave for pointing out their weak spots.
- gandalfgreybeer 5y agoSometimes I wonder if it’s just me being worse at using keywords to search for what I need but I’ve noticed that it’s so much harder to find things that are actually helpful via google on stackoverflow etc. Most annoying thing is when I restrict keywords and they still show up on the search results. Now when I can’t find something on Google, instead of refining keywords, I give DDG or Bing a go first (both not always successful but half the time I find more useful links).
- gremIin 5y agoIt's not you. Google nerfed search a few years ago. I noticed exactly what you noticed around 2016 or so.
- vincent_s 5y agoAmit Singhal, who was Head of Search at Google until 2016, has always emphasized that Google will not use artificial intelligence for ranking search results. The reason he gave was that AI algorithms work like a black box and that it is infeasible to improve them incrementally. Then in 2016, John Giannandrea, an AI expert, took over. Since then, Google has increasingly relied on AI algorithms, which seem to work well enough for main-stream search queries. For highly specific search queries made by power users, however, these algorithms often fail to deliver useful results. My guess is that it is technically very difficult to adapt these new AI algorithms so that they also work well for that type of search queries.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dx034 5y agoMaybe on an absolute basis, but on a relative basis I still find Google results (esp for localized results) far above any other search engine. And that gap hasn't narrowed at all since I first started using DDG several years back.
- remus 5y ago> On a more serious tone, the quality of Google search results is continuously degrading. Do you know of any publically available analysis that tries to measure search quality? And that shows that google's results are getting worse over time? It seems like a hard thing to measure, and a few people on HN saying "I searched for x and got garbage results" doesn't seem like the most robust thing. Less flippantly, people are notoriously bad at objectively remembering stuff. I certainly have no idea how good google search results were even 1 week ago, let alone 1,2 or 3+ or years.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cyberpsybin 5y ago"Google" "private"; unbelievable someone can put these two words in same sentence. Google cannot even pull pages older than 10yrs old at the moment.
- charcircuit 5y agoGoogle cares a lot about protecting user's privacy. Take a look at their privacy policy. For example, what other API provider requires you to get security audits ($15k-$75k yearly) when handling sensitive user data.
- goldforever 5y agolol...paid for by Google
- y4mi 5y agoi think a lot of people never really understood googles business model. google absolutely wants to protect their users privacy from third parties. their ideal situation would be if they're the only one's knowing everything about their users so they can allow third parties to advertise things to their users. if they'd leak any of this information, they'd be compromising their main business model. so yes, people can trust google to do their everything to keep their information from reaching anyone else, including forcing said third parties to undergo paid audits to verify that nobody is leeching their user data. for some reason, a lot of people got it into their head that google literally sells information. i'm not sure why this ever started, as - at least as far as i am aware - google never tried to do anything even remotely like that
- soundnote 5y agoThis. Big Tech companies or their divisions are advertising service companies and AI cults. They sell targeting, not the raw data. The data is useful for selling targeting services and feeding their AIs, actually selling it to others would be stupid of them.
- skinnymuch 5y ago
- forgotmyoldname 5y agoYeah, I've tried switching to other search engines a few times, but one domain where a lot of them really lack is non-English results. Google has increasingly turned to garbage these past few years. But searching anything non-English on other search engines really feels like randomly populated results. Location and temporal results are also lacking on non-Google results. Google also over-optimizes for them, so sometimes DDG is nice when Google is for some reason absolutely convinced I'm searching from some random town in another country and is only serving up results for that area.
- schleck8 5y agoI agree that the quality isn't comparable yet, but don't forget that this is barely out of beta and that google had decades to imprpve their product.
- _fnhr 5y agoHere is one example in Brave's favour, seach: politics influences the science of covid-19 Brave - first result. Google - no first page, no second page, no third page, stopped checking. Let's try that in quotes - it's the exact title of the article: "politics influences the science of covid-19" Brave: first result Google: no results found, searching without quotes.
- notreallyserio 5y agoAre you looking for the article on scienceblog or here on HN? Those are the first two results I get from Google when using the quoted string.
- _fnhr 5y agoGoogle, when used with double quotes and exact title, finds aggregator sites, but I was simulating looking for the original: https://joshmitteldorf.scienceblog.com/2020/07/08/politics-influences-the-science-of-covid-19/ https://joshmitteldorf.scienceblog.com/2020/07/08/politics-i... Here is one more, search: Ten Elements of the False COVID Narrative Google: nowhere Brave: first result And it's not like Google just didn't index the site, it works for topics that are "less controversial", search: Universal Clock implies Universal Clockwork Google: first result Brave: first result Whatever the explanation - either Google censors some topics, or its search engine works differently - the result is the same, for this example Brave outperformed Google.
- Kiro 5y agoNone of your examples do what you say for me. I see everything on Google including your comments here.
- kkoncevicius 5y agoInteresting, let me share two screenshots of what I see: 1. http://karolis.koncevicius.lt/data/google_example1.png http://karolis.koncevicius.lt/data/google_example1.png 2. http://karolis.koncevicius.lt/data/google_example2.png http://karolis.koncevicius.lt/data/google_example2.png