4 ms·
No observational consequences means t=0 is zero though - if no events from before then can have carried through consequences, then they might as well have not h
by XorNot 5y ago
No observational consequences means t=0 is zero though - if no events from before then can have carried through consequences, then they might as well have not happened - certainly no information about them can ever be recovered.
You are making a very strong assertion that something did carry through - what are you basing that on?
- knodi123 5y ago> then they might as well have not happened "Might as well not" is different from "Did not". That's all I, and Mr Hawking, are saying. In fact, your first sentence is literally just a paraphrase of my quote from Hawking. > You are making a very strong assertion that something did carry through No, I most certainly did not. All I said is, there could have been something, or could have not been. I did not say something did happen prior to the big bang, just that it is wrong to say that it could not have.
- chaps 5y agoYou're also making a pretty big claim about whether a universe makes noise if no dimension is around to articulate it.