3 ms·
He does sort of balance it with an opposing point, though: > My biggest worry about all this is that claims of a major result should be resolved in a timely fa
by _delirium 15y ago
He does sort of balance it with an opposing point, though:
> My biggest worry about all this is that claims of a major result should be resolved in a timely fashion, since otherwise unpleasant claims of credit and priority may arise.
In this case it's not too clear to me what's gained from keeping the updated proof private, available only to a few anonymous referees, and not available to folks like Lipton. It might still take a while to sort out even if it were generally available, but that's different from keeping it within a very slow and limited formalized process.