3 ms·
No. There is a (IIUC, recently floated, and non mainstream) theory that inflation did in fact precede the big bang. No, I don't understand how that's possible
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
No. There is a (IIUC, recently floated, and non mainstream) theory that inflation did in fact precede the big bang. No, I don't understand how that's possible, or even a meaningful statement.
There was an article on it here on HN, almost certainly within the last month. I don't recall more.
- chaps 5y agoOne of the theories is that inflationary cosmology leads to inflationary cosmology: where one universe's big bang's inflation leads to pockets of inflation that can extend beyond the universe they came from -- effectively creating their own universe. Then a big bang extends from that, which repeats into their own inflationary systems, which repeats into their own system, etc. It's a theory from the 80s IIRC.
- andreareina 5y agoInflationary cosmology[1] is mostly accepted in its basic form [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation_(cosmology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation_(cosmology)
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoRight; that has inflation beginning after the big bang.
- andreareina 5y agoI think "the big bang" has a problem of changing meaning. Here's my understanding: - Naïve extrapolation of GR backwards in time results in a singularity at a finite point in time. Call that the big bang singularity (at t = 0) - Using current accepted theory, we're able to simulate what was going on at t > 10^-32 or so. Before this, the implied densities and temperature are beyond what our theories can handle and we're less confident about how we got to that point (with an excess of baryons, smooth distribution of energy and matter, and the other parameters that obtain in our current universe). - Inflation is one of the favored explanations for what happened before, but it doesn't address its own cause ("what happened before inflation?"). There's a theory of "eternal inflation" (local regions that have stopped inflating surrounded by regions that are still inflating), which explains the fine-tuning problem (each region that has stopped inflating can have its own fine structure etc). This is less accepted, maybe this is what you're thinking of? - There's a push to redefine "the big bang" as all the stuff we can explain with current physics, i.e. as starting after inflation (but still using t=0 at the big bang singularity everyone's pretty sure doesn't actually exist). Or maybe it's been like that for a while and it's just pop science that perpetuates the big bang = singularity idea. Like how relativistic mass has fallen out of favor as a concept.