3 ms·
There was an interesting discussion over the weekend about tribal stupidity, prompted by an article by Dietrich Bonhoeffer. Mr. Doctorow perfectly embodies it:
by AlbertCory 5y ago
There was an interesting discussion over the weekend about tribal stupidity, prompted by an article by Dietrich Bonhoeffer. Mr. Doctorow perfectly embodies it:
All of his examples are about the other tribe. "My tribe is science-based! It's the other tribe that has the denialists!"
Actually, both tribes practice all of his behaviors.
- justin_oaks 5y agoFor any particular tribe you'll see members of that tribe use dishonest tactics to try to convince the other side. I find this the most distasteful when science, logic, consensus, etc. is on a particular tribe's side. Member of the tribe don't need to use underhanded schemes to try to argue their side. They are actively undermining their tribe by using dishonesty to attempt to strengthen their position.
- danaris 5y agoWhile it's certainly true that there are some people on the Internet who both agree with the overwhelming scientific consensus on global warming and make bad arguments, a) that does not imply that the position those arguments defend is incorrect, and b) for the science denialists, bad arguments are all they have.
- AlbertCory 5y agoLet me rephrase that for you: "My tribe is correct. It's the other one that's bad."
- danaris 5y ago"Both sides are just being tribal, there's no real right answer" is one of the more common methods used to dismiss the very real differences between the two sides and attempt to prevent progress from being made.
- AlbertCory 5y ago"progress" meaning "my tribe wins."
- danaris 5y ago"Progress," meaning "the things the "tribe" that labels itself as "progressive" wants." So, yeah, you're not being particularly clever by observing that.