6 ms·
> If you get a phone on contract, you don't actually own it till you pay it off, and the company is entitled to lock it. No. You don't turn off somebody's phon
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
> If you get a phone on contract, you don't actually own it till you pay it off, and the company is entitled to lock it.
No. You don't turn off somebody's phone while they're using it. You have no idea what they could be doing. Someone could be literally dying in front of your locked out consumer who is now unable to call for help. This is vital infrastructure and you're denying them access. If somebody dies because of this, it's on your conscience.
Would you randomly disable somebody's car's engine because they didn't pay? No. You call the police and get them to repossess the car. The police will do it properly without risking collateral damage.
- jfrunyon 5y ago1) I highly doubt that the app disables emergency calling. 2) Some (rental, probably also lease) vehicles actually do have disablers. They prevent the vehicle from being started, not stop them in the middle of the road. 3) The police don't repo a thing. That's a civil matter and generally outsourced to the lowest bidder with a tow truck. By the way, if someone dies because of it, the only person whose conscience it is on is the person who bought a phone they couldn't afford and then didn't pay for it. Just like if someone died because the car got repo'd and they couldn't drive to a hospital.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> I highly doubt that the app disables emergency calling. Well, I highly doubt that it doesn't. Given how little attention the company paid to these important details, who's to say they didn't simply brick the user's phone? > They prevent the vehicle from being started, not stop them in the middle of the road. Like I said, nobody will randomly disable somebody's car engine. These people at least have enough foresight to wait until it's safe. > The police don't repo a thing. They do where I live. Bank loans money with car as collateral, consumer defaults, bank seeks justice, judge authorizes police to repossess the car so the bank can sell it and minimize losses. Police can enter private property and even use force if necessary. What is even the point of police if they aren't gonna do things like this? Outsourced to tow trucks? Really? When some random citizen reposseses property, it's robbery. > if someone dies because of it, the only person whose conscience it is on is the person who bought a phone they couldn't afford and then didn't pay for it No. The fact that person didn't pay for the phone doesn't matter matter at all. The company can always negotiate new terms or seek justice later. What matters is the fact that in an emergency the only thing standing between the consumer and a call for help was the phone company. Worse, they got in the way on purpose, as if it was their job to punish the consumer. There is no defending this. > Just like if someone died because the car got repo'd and they couldn't drive to a hospital. Not really. If you don't have a car, you can still call emergency services. At least you would have been able to if some stupid company had not locked your phone.
- jpmoral 5y ago1) You don't know that. And there may be emergency situations where you're on the phone with someone other than from the emergency number. 2) How rental cars do it doesn't seem to have anything to do with this. >By the way, if someone dies because of it, the only person whose conscience it is on is the person who bought a phone they couldn't afford and then didn't pay for it. Just like if someone died because the car got repo'd and they couldn't drive to a hospital. This is some fucked up reasoning. People run into financial difficulty for various reasons, sometimes out of their control. But even for the serial deadbeats who don't care about financial responsibility saying "yeah, it's fine that somebody or their loved one died because it's their fault"? I can't imagine thinking like that.
- jfrunyon 5y ago> Would you randomly disable somebody's car's engine because they didn't pay? No. Perhaps you meant to reply to the person I was replying to, rather than me, with your "how rental cars do it doesn't seem to have anything to do with it"? Because the person I was replying to said that repossessors wouldn't disable a car, which is not true. > This is some fucked up reasoning. People run into financial difficulty for various reasons, sometimes out of their control. But even for the serial deadbeats who don't care about financial responsibility saying "yeah, it's fine that somebody or their loved one died because it's their fault"? I can't imagine thinking like that. Saying "yeah, someone else SHOULD pay for their non-necessity"? I can't imagine thinking like that. Just because someone runs into financial difficulty doesn't mean they can just stop paying for things. Nor does it mean that anyone else has an obligation to provide them with something for free. Particularly when that something is a luxury. Heck, if they're so short on money they could've sold their expensive Samsung phone and replaced it with a cheap one. And again, I highly doubt that any of this is even a possibility. And you can say I "don't know" that it doesn't disable emergency calling (never said I did), but the fact of the matter is, it's virtually impossible to disable emergency calling on any phone, thanks to both regulation and technical standards.
- jpmoral 5y ago>Saying "yeah, someone else SHOULD pay for their non-necessity"? I can't imagine thinking like that. >Just because someone runs into financial difficulty doesn't mean they can just stop paying for things. Nor does it mean that anyone else has an obligation to provide them with something for free. Particularly when that something is a luxury. Heck, if they're so short on money they could've sold their expensive Samsung phone and replaced it with a cheap one. That wasn't remotely what I was saying. I wasn't advocating for anyone to get non-necessities for free nor that difficulties automatically absolves people of responsibility. I was saying that to dismiss any consideration of life and death situations because any deaths would be on the people not paying is fucked up.
- felipelemos 5y ago> By the way, if someone dies because of it, the only person whose conscience it is on is the person who bought a phone they couldn't afford and then didn't pay for it. Just like if someone died because the car got repo'd and they couldn't drive to a hospital. Sure. What they were thinking trying to buy something without having money, right? And even worse, what they were thinking being poor. They should have bought a very shit phone, closer to what they can afford. And if they lost their job and then couldn't pay for the phone, it's their own fault. /s
- FDSGSG 5y agoIf everyone saw things like you, there would probably not be nearly as many poor people with phones. It is these very consequences (repo, deactivation) that make it possible for these phones to be offered at affordable prices. Sadly we don't live in a utopia, especially the poor people of this world don't. I'm sure they'd rather have the phone that stops working and possibly indirectly kills their family when unpaid than no phone at all.
- felipelemos 5y agoCurious, as I am from a poor country where: 1. Lots of poor people have phones, sometimes very expensive ones (as these are sought as a symbol status) 2. There is no such thing as repossession. And living abroad makes me believe that it is an phenomenon in United States only. It is illegal in many parts of the world. *edit: word
- jfrunyon 5y ago> There is no such thing as repossession sure there isn't. Guess there's no financing, either, then, huh?
- felipelemos 5y agoNot only there is no repossession but almost everything is sold in installments. You can pay in installments even in supermarkets. In that case what makes the system works is the credit system. When almost everything you buy you must use installments then losing your credit is a terrible situation and the only solution is to pay (or try to). In the beginning of my career I worked in a small local ISP and usually the middle/high class were a bigger part of the people with overdue payments, while people living in worse neighbourhoods were almost always paying in time. They can't afford to not pay. Sometimes we live in a bubble that makes we think the way we live and the way things are are the only way things should be. We must be careful to not extend our vision of things to everyone and everything, the world is much bigger than our backyard. *edit: a paragraph
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y ago> Would you randomly disable somebody's car's engine because they didn't pay? I believe that's exactly what some systems for subprime car loans do (they don't shut it down while running, but will prevent it from starting - if they're somewhat clever then only if the car has been off for a certain amount of time).
- Arn_Thor 5y agoYou're confusing ethics and legality
- vadfa 5y agoYou know there is literally a 0% chance of the company that owns the phone getting it back after having it stolen from them. Having a system like this is the only reliable way of making sure people in low trust countries will pay what they bought.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoSo what? Don't loan out phones then. If you do, then don't lock out emergency functions. Incorporate the risk of not getting paid into the product's price or something. In my country, if someone's life is in danger and someone else sees that, they are legally obligated to help. Failing to do that is criminal negligence. When those people are in front of a judge being asked why they didn't help, what will they answer? "Oh, I tried but the phone company locked me out." Will the judge care about the fact that the company locked them out because they owe them money? No, the judge is going to make it even more expensive for them at the very least and that's honestly a pretty generous outcome. Failing to call for help because you don't have a phone? That's tough, a difficulty of life. Having one but being unable to because some idiot company locked you out? Yeah, that's extremely fucked up. Emergency services are rights and no company on earth gets to deny people those rights. Nobody really cares that the user didn't pay for the phone. What matters is that the phone was in the user's possession and could have saved a life had the company not locked the user out. Nobody deserves to die because of some company's entitlement.