5 ms·
I had my facebook account taken over a couple months ago. The person used my compromised password to log in to facebook. Facebook sent me an email saying "hey t
by mrguyorama 5y ago
I had my facebook account taken over a couple months ago.
The person used my compromised password to log in to facebook. Facebook sent me an email saying "hey this doesn't look like you, here's a '2fa' code to put in before you can log in".
Then, despite my email account not being compromised, such that the person COULD NOT have gotten that code, facebook let them in anyway, let them change my backup phone number and email accounts, take off my phone number and email accounts, change my password, and fully take over my account.
What the hell was the point of that "code" if facebook let them in anyway? As the account no longer has my email address or phone associated with it, I can't recover it through those channels. I got the the point where you can send in a selfie with your ID, sent that, and got an email (with zero "case ID" or communication channel) that said verification normally takes 2 days. It's been over two MONTHS. So I guess there's nothing I can do?
- twobitshifter 5y ago2fa isn’t as useful as people had thought it would be and actually causes more problems for people like me with secure passwords. Probability of having my 24 alphanumeric university alum account pw hacked: | Probability of me losing/destroying my phone/not remembering the right 2FA app/having DUO mobile fail: ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
- tpmx 5y agoRegarding the password hacking probability: Did you really account for the malware/keylogging risk properly?
- pawelwentpawel 5y agoI'm in the same position with Instagram. Been sending them selfies with codes forever now with completely no response. My account had a large following and I can't even seem to start a new one with the same username. Process of account retrieval is like talking to plants - you kinda know they're there but they're actually not. It makes sense though - they have colonised enough internet by now not to care about a couple mere users. If you loose access to your account you're likely not to get it back. On the bright side though, I don't scroll that much anymore. Maybe they lost a couple $ on advertising by loosing a user but I have regained a small portion of my time I spent there. The only real drawback is that I kept in touch with some people via Instagram only. A situation like this makes you realise that an account in any of the FB owned companies can be taken away at any moment and you shouldn't get attached to it too much nor make it a single point of failure in your business / creative strategy. I'd advice to: - Keep a copy of your data (contacts, content posted etc.) and try to diversify as much as possible. - When using Facebook auth on 3rd party websites, make sure to have another method of authentication available to avoid getting locked out. - Try to get phone numbers of important contacts so in the worst case you can contact them via iMessage / Signal / Telegram. - If you have a large following, try to stream some of the traffic to other platforms too. If loosing one account means loosing your entire audience you're risking a lot. In short - have a backup.
- zht 5y agoalso I'm sure many at HN know this but the same applies to the Google accounts
- fighterpilot 5y agoYep got locked out of Google for no reason and it was impossible to get in touch with a human. Extremely rage-inducing. There needs to be far better consumer protection on a government level with big tech (mostly Google and Twitter/FB, not so much Amazon or Netflix or Apple). Some of this is just unacceptable. I was reading one case of a person who had their name/image associated with a convicted rapist on Google and they couldn't get hold of a human to have it fixed. This kind of thing just shouldn't be allowed and there needs to be large fines going out. The onus should not be on a small time individual to fork out tens of thousands of dollars on a lawsuit.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> I was reading one case of a person who had their name/image associated with a convicted rapist on Google and they couldn't get hold of a human to have it fixed. Suing Google apparently does the trick in my country. Google fails to respond? Police shows up at their local office, arrests some executives and makes them 100% available for comment. https://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/26/business/global/top-google-executive-in-brazil-faces-arrest-over-video.html https://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/26/business/global/top-googl... I wonder why the US doesn't do this. Tarnishing an innocent person's reputation by associating them with rape they didn't commit is obviously criminal. They MUST fix it. Doesn't matter how much it costs them either. They also get plenty of lawsuits over images in the search results. Lawsuits over celebrity nude photos have made the news before. They were removed. A local Facebook executive was also detained after the company failed to disclose the contents of encrypted WhatsApp messages to drug trafficking investigators. To me this was major proof that WhatsApp wasn't lying about its end-to-end encryption. > The onus should not be on a small time individual to fork out tens of thousands of dollars on a lawsuit. Agree. Government should always provide free lawyers really. Not just for murder cases. Otherwise, only the rich will ever go to court and seek justice.
- citizenpaul 5y agoFunny I had something similar happen. Though they didn't change my email. Once FB started asking for me to send gov ID I just said forget this. About two months later I got an email saying my account access had been restored. With me doing NOTHING. It seems FB is simply using some sort of automated too long for hackers to care about or be profitable system to monitor account fraud.
- mroche 5y agoHad a similar thing happen to me back in 2019, but it never got resolved: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24954602 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24954602 I'm beyond caring at this point, but if for whatever reason I get Messenger stripped I'm in for a fun time to try and communicate with some of my west coast friends' group chats.
- clairity 5y agothat’s actually a blessing in disguise. you have somebody else poisoning your personal information without you having to do anything. i haven’t logged into facebook (or instagram or gmail) in at least a couple years. i hope the same has happened to my accounts.
- cwkoss 5y agoI wonder if it there are facebook internal 'admin' type employees that are stealing accounts in this way. That would be a way to get the code. Wouldn't be too surprised if facebook was skimping on oversight. Do you know what the behavior of the account was after takeover? Was there a clear monetization strategy (ex posting links, sending spam messages, etc)?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- notyourwork 5y agoPerhaps coincidence, same thing happened to me. I was able to recover my account but the entire thing was head scratching. Granted I don't use my account but I also didn't want someone to have it and turn it into a shill for nefarious purposes.
- xer0x 5y agoYes! Yes! This happened to my wife. It was exactly the same. As her tech support team, I have wasted endless hours trying to recover her account. Facebook support has never responded, and we can see the account, yet we have no way to click any of the supposed "recovery options". This is horrendous. I'm sad to see other people live through the frustration here, yet glad we're not the only ones.
- crossroadsguy 5y agoThese behemoths - Facebook, Twitter, Google [1] - are running businesses where scale matters and cost saving is the supreme goal. You, as an insignificant normal user, is, well, just insignificant. There’s no incentive for them to invest in infrastructure where cases like yours can be dealt with. It’s like the game that you can never win. So the only way to not be losing is not playing. [1] I’ve always been able to reach a human being at Apple, so far, so I didn’t mention them. Even for help with out of warranty devices. That’s why the recovery/backup email with my domain registrar and mail host is my @icloud.com email. Earlier it was my Gmail account. Right now my Gmail account is used in places where I even suspect I’ll get spam. I open it only when I am expecting an email i.e movie/travel ticket booking etc. Though I’m not really sure what happens to this @icloud.com email if I own zero Apple devices at some point?!