3 ms·
Intel’s hope for recovery reminds me of Apple’s back in 97. They have one asset which is (greatly diminished but nonzero) momentum. An absolutely enormous num
by gumby 5y ago
Intel’s hope for recovery reminds me of Apple’s back in 97. They have one asset which is (greatly diminished but nonzero) momentum. An absolutely enormous number (though slowly diminishing) number of people can’t switch away from their product. So they have time to try and do something new.
Apple’s had a much shorter fuse. They really needed that $150MM from MS (who needed Apple to fend off antitrust). Talking to ppl in Intel that sense of urgency hasn’t made it through the organization (and why should it? There are tons of other jobs around). But they could pull it off.
The momentum is what allows you to avoid the (mythical?) “Osborne effect”: the only thing Intel can brag about is the future; today’s products will still be bought by a lot of people and so hopefully that will stem some of the design losses.
MS was able to do the same thing (though their situation was far from dire). Motorola and HP couldn’t.
- grishka 5y ago> An absolutely enormous number (though slowly diminishing) number of people can’t switch away from their product Aren't AMD CPUs more or less drop-in replacements for Intel though, as far as software compatibility goes? Yes, you need a new motherboard. But you probably need one even if you stay on Intel.
- neogodless 5y agoDisclaimer: I f***ing love AMD. But... between mindshare, supply constraints, and OEMs being slow to make compelling products with AMD, it takes a long time to switch large numbers from Intel to AMD. With AMD laptops, you'll struggle to find the ideal combination of display (resolution, quality, brightness), ports (Thunderbolt) and other attributes. They only got high-end discrete GPUs and 4K screens this year. And often not in the same machine. Thunderbolt is technically available for AMD platforms now, but still exceedingly rare. For desktop, yes... I switched to AMD fifteen years ago and I haven't looked back. That's as someone who builds their own. In the consumer space (outside DIY), desktops are like laptops. You need to find OEMs putting things together in the right configuration. Not to mention selling them at your local Best Buy for a mainstream consumer to come across it and pick it up. And not turn away because it's missing the "Intel Inside" sticker seared into their brain from decades of marketing.
- gumby 5y agoWell the people designing the boards care. Many huge enterprise companies care (for reasons I don’t completely understand but I don’t work in that space any more). And AMD’s volume is nothing like Intel’s — one of Intel’s lucky breaks. I think AMD is mostly a consumer brand and consumers aren’t buying a lot of PCs these days (except for a small transient due to Covid).
- WoodenChair 5y ago> Apple’s had a much shorter fuse. "Shorter fuse" is a great understatement. Intel's situation in 2021 is not even remotely comparable to Apple in 1997, except in the abstract. Apple was months away from bankruptcy, losing money every quarter, and had <5% market share. Intel has >50% market share in some markets, is extremely profitable (24 billion last year), and has enough cash in the bank to ride this out for years. Apple had to execute near perfectly immediately when SJ came back. Intel could make the right strategic decision a year from now and turn things around. Or it could probably make the right decisions two years from now and still be fine.
- CoolGuySteve 5y agoIntel seems more like Sun, they once produced competitive products but are now entering a period of stagnation and decline due to confusing product offerings and executive mismanagement. Most of their sales come from legacy entrenchment.
- reacharavindh 5y agoTo me, Intel is starting to look more like IBM. Still showing engineering might in some areas, holding onto a huge trove of patents, making decent money, but losing growth, momentum and appeal over a long period of time. Sure, they will exist and refuse to die, but will they be a significant part of the future? I’m not optimistic.
- toast0 5y agoConfusing product offerings aren't the reason for stagnation and decline. Intel did great when they had confusing and competitive product offerings. They're in decline because their product development pipeline for CPUs depends on their fabrication pipeline, and their fab pipeline was stalled for several years. It seems like the fab pipeline has been unblocked, maybe, as Intel 10nm products are starting to appear in bigger numbers. We'll see if that unblocks their CPU pipeline in the next year or two, I guess.