4 ms·
> That is called "barter". From the Wikiepdia page on "Barter"[1]: > In trade, barter (derived from baretor) is a system of exchange in which participants in
by rjknight 5y ago
> That is called "barter".
From the Wikiepdia page on "Barter"[1]:
> In trade, barter (derived from baretor) is a system of exchange in which participants in a transaction directly exchange goods or services for other goods or services without using a medium of exchange, such as money. Economists distinguish barter from gift economies in many ways; barter, for example, features immediate reciprocal exchange, not one delayed in time.
The "immediate reciprocal exchange" criterion means that exchanging chickens now for apples later is not barter. When we talk about money replacing barter, we are talking specifically about the ability to immediately exchange physical tokens for goods or services. This refers very specifically to money as the medium of exchange, not as the medium of account.
In the traditional story, money was needed because Farmer A wants to exchange chickens for apples with Farmer B, but Farmer B doesn't have any apples right now. Money is useful because they can exchange that instead. But this story loses a lot of its force when you understand that they could have simply exchanged credit, without any need for money at all. The systemic change is not barter -> money, but credit -> money, which has very different implications for how society is organised. And, as I mentioned, we can see transitions from credit -> money and back again occur many times in history, whereas we see barter occur only in extremely rare circumstances.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barter
- Nevermark 5y agoThanks for the clarification! I was not aware of the "immediate" condition for barter. Reading from your link, there seems to be a gap in terminology for a situation separate from bartering, gift giving, and money based exchanges. Specifically, delayed exchanges where an account is informally kept but based on what was taken, not any unit/money. The wikipedia entry for "Gift economy" rules out "explicit agreement for immediate or future rewards". [1] So what to call the situation implied by "delayed barter", or "gifting with explicitly expected reciprocity"? That situation can still happen without money. (Not claiming it was the basis for any particular economy, as it wouldn't scale well past trusted or enforcable relationships.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gift_economy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gift_economy