15 ms·
> I hate having to waste time figuring out the type of every variable and hold it in my head every single time I read a piece of code. For the same reason, I’m
by layer8 5y ago
> I hate having to waste time figuring out the type of every variable and hold it in my head every single time I read a piece of code.
For the same reason, I’m not a fan of type-inferring variable declarations.
- dmart 5y agoYeah, when writing type inference is obviously nice, but it can be annoying to try to go back and read. I think the best experience is having a language server annotate the inferred types (like how rust-analyzer does it.) But even then, it can become hard to read code on GitHub or somewhere where tools are not available. Granted that's becoming less and less of a problem, and even GitHub allows using some VS Code extensions now.
- layer8 5y agoWith good IDE support, writing types isn’t that much of a burden. Either write a function call first and use "assign return value to new variable", or use autocompletion where you only type the initials of a multi-word type name. Plus IDE refactoring actions when a parameter or return type needs to be changed.
- lamontcg 5y agoI'm okay with "var = new FooBarBazThingyWithALongName()" because I don't need to see the type name twice there. In an IDE you can get the type annotation from the IDE over every inferred var type, but I don't like requiring an IDE to see that information and like it showing up in 'less' as well.
- layer8 5y agoI agree it's redundant if the type name occurs twice in the same statement. However, further evolution of the code often causes the instantiation to be moved elsewhere, and I wouldn't have confidence that the one doing that change then also changes `var` back to the type name. Instead, it would be nice to have syntax avoiding the duplication in the fashion of `FooBarBazThingyWithALongName thingy = new(...constructor parameters...);`.
- Serow225 5y agoC# 9 now has "target-typed new expressions" https://www.thomasclaudiushuber.com/2020/09/08/c-9-0-target-typed-new-expressions/ https://www.thomasclaudiushuber.com/2020/09/08/c-9-0-target-...
- lamontcg 5y agoIdeally linting tools on PRs show the refactored code as a violation, and it should be easy to rip a cleanup refactoring across the files before submitting a PR to avoid that.