8 ms·
58,000 Sign Up for Stanford AI Course
- geoffw8 15y agoI just found it through the database course and signed up. Just got a taste of machine learning etc via http://blog.saush.com/ http://blog.saush.com/ Hoping not all of it will go over my head!
- lylejohnson 15y agoOfficial registration hasn't opened yet, right? I haven't received any additional info since I initially submitted my name and email address a few weeks ago.
- misuse-permit 15y agoCorrect, the real headline was "58,000 Want Course." Kind of sensationalist of mhb to change it like that, unless NYT secretly updated the article, which I've heard they're fond of doing.
- AdamTReineke 15y agoMost likely NYT updated it. Easy mistake for someone not familiar with this topic to make.
- nazgulnarsil 15y agoand just like any math based course at a community college 3/4ths will have dropped by the midterm.
- esrauch 15y agoI suspect more will drop out since they have even less necessity driving them than someone at community college.
- Shenglong 15y agoI think it's safe to say at least 3/4 will not do any work. Another 3/4 of the remaining will drop out after trying, and another 3/4 will not understand a thing. 900 is still a decently large university class.
- mrspeaker 15y agoThat's still 14500 who won't.
- eazolan 15y agoI don't think you belong here. You're supposed to whine and bitch bitterly about "Kids these days". I figure the future of education looks like this. Where anyone can sign up for courses, and if they don't get it, they can either drop it or hire a tutor. 1 teacher per subject per 300 students is an anachronism. It should have gone away when textbooks became ridiculously cheap to print.
- pakitan 15y agoMost likely the percentage will be much higher. I'm saying that as a former dropout :) I've decided to go through the Machine Learning course (the web version) few months ago but it's really too math heavy. It's not that I'm a total noob but having to parse formulas spanning 2 rows and containing half the Greek alphabet is about as exciting as reading an organic chemistry textbook. Nevertheless I signed up! But I hope some day there will be a AI/machine learning course that will have code examples for every concept and every math formula, just like this: http://www.cleveralgorithms.com/nature-inspired/index.html http://www.cleveralgorithms.com/nature-inspired/index.html Maybe it's just me but code is way easier to read and understand.
- mhartl 15y agoWe should run a betting pool for this. I'd bet at even money than more than 90% of online signups fail to complete the course. Give me decent odds and I'll bump that up to 95%
- robryan 15y agoGovernment should sponsor this kind of thing, seems like there are a lot of people out there that want to learn more and these kind of quality courses should scale fairly well. Sure it won't replace the real course but it will teach a lot of people a lot of things. Really the only thing holding this kind of thing back from dramatically improving education efficiency is the old thinking rigid degree requirements.
- smackfu 15y agoYou can get Teaching Company DVDs from a lot of libraries. Basically the same idea but lower tech, and government subsidized. But then, I am a big believer that a great teacher on tape is far better for the students than a good or OK teacher in person.
- wisty 15y agoIt's not really. The most useful thing a teacher can do is give feedback. That said, one student among 300 doesn't get a lot of feedback.
- smackfu 15y agoHow about "great lecturer or speaker" over "great teacher"? Because a 300:1 lecture by an ok lecturer is much less useful (bordering on worthless) than a recorded one by a great lecturer. And that mediocre lecture is what you will get in most schools for intro classes.
- wisty 15y ago... which are often the ones with 300 students, and no useful feedback. I agree.
- pessimizer 15y agoGovernment subsidized? You mean the library? Because IIRC the courses retail at a fortune (but are always on sale.)
- 15y ago
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- smackfu 15y agoI think this is a great idea, but I'm not sure emphasizing the number of sign-ups at this point is smart. They don't even have a CAPTCHA and don't verify the emails besides basic email@doman.tld. So hopefully they are removing bounces from the counts.
- ordinary 15y agoIn fairness, these are AI experts. Surely they, more than anyone, know how to reliably distinguish people from non-people?
- veyron 15y agothat's what they said about financial experts ...
- NY_Entrepreneur 15y agoUh, in "AI", the "I" is mostly just a hope or goal and not yet an accomplishment! We have AI as a field mostly just because of long, aggressive funding by DARPA, early on especially of the MIT AI Lab. Since then DARPA has funded the prize where computer controlled cars chase across a desert. It appears that some people at DARPA are hoping that something good happens from their funding. Tough to say something good will never happen! If something okay leaks out of the research, then some lives of some US soldiers might be saved and, by now, may have already. In that case, good. DARPA is likely some of the very best money spent, even if for some years the work looks weak. At least with the money so far, a lot of quite bright people have TRIED to make progress in AI. Some years ago, I was one of three researchers in an AI group that did some of the world's best AI work. I had two conclusions: (1) For the practical progress desired now, just use 'traditional' approaches of (A) see problem, (B) analyze problem, (C) find assumptions can make about the problem, (D) do some math starting with the assumptions, (E) take the conclusions of the math as progress on a solution, (F) use the best of what have to wrap up the best solution can see. (2) For the AI part, so far "We dance 'round in a ring and suppose while the secret sits in the middle and knows.".
- robjohnson 15y agoiTunes U was a big step in the proliferation of higher-quality education to the masses. It's nice to see Universities like Stanford spearhead revolutionary innovations to give the opportunity of learning from world class academicians to people who would have otherwise never dreamed of it. Bravo!
- aerique 15y agoWhat did iTunes do? I'm not really up-to-date on all things Apple.
- andysinclair 15y agoiTunes U (as in U for University) is a section of iTunes where you will find a whole host of University courses to download and watch. I mention this to many people and there seems to be very little awareness that all this high quality content is available on iTunes. There are some great courses available (most for free), in fact I have just finished the Stanford iPhone programming course by Paul Hegarty which I highly recommend.
- aerique 15y agoThanks for the reply. While I do have an iPhone I try to avoid iTunes (I used it twice to update my phone since I got it two years a go). The programming course does sound interesting though I could use a good course to supplement my self-thought knowledge of the platform.
- watty 15y agoI don't think iTunes U has anything to do with this.
- javert 15y agoiTunes U was a big step in the proliferation... A big step backwards, from what I can tell. Sharing video recordings of class lectures on the Web is easy: record video, upload to Web. Why is there a need to do it through iTunes? AFAIK, iTunesU is just a way for Apple to try to get campus lock-in. I know this sounds kind of rant-ish, but I'm being 100% serious and honest. My school started using iTunesU, which didn't seem to have any advantages over just putting video online, except that I couldn't use it, since I can't run iTunes on my computer (Linux). I'd honestly like to know what benefits iTunesU has for anyone besides Apple and Microsoft, in the sense that if it became truly widespread, it would prevent any widespread movement to adopt Linux on campus.
- jsavimbi 15y agoSo how many signed up for the DB course?
- bulletsvshumans 15y agoIt would be an interesting twist if someone were to sign up an AI bot, using machine learning to work its way through the course.
- rbanffy 15y ago54.000 entries? I'd bet someone did that.
- AdamTReineke 15y agoThat's the homework for their machine learning class (ml-class.org). ;-)
- xbryanx 15y agoI'm curious if any of the Stanford students who are paying thousands for this course are worried about the diminished return they might get from their professor. Don't get me wrong, I love this idea as the free recipient, I'm just curious if students who are paying, and obviously getting lots more, have any views on this.
- lylejohnson 15y agoNot sure why you were down voted. This seems like it would be a legitimate concern to me if I were a "regular" Stanford student enrolled in (and paying for) this course.
- dpatru 15y agoA regular Stanford student can expect to spend about $50,000 a year [1] or about $200,000 for a four-year degree. In four years, I believe that there will be at least one company that will offer trustworthy certification for a lot less, like maybe $20,000 or $2000. If the primary benefit of a Stanford education is the certification, then in a few years Stanford grads may be like owners of $200,000 cars-- obviously wealthy, but not possessing any significant advantage in transportation over owners of $20,000 cars. [1] http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090416220215AAw60Bs http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090416220215AA...
- SkyMarshal 15y agoThe professors' actual interaction will be limited. Questions from free students will be aggregated and ranked and only the top ten or so answered and posted online. And I doubt the profs will reduce their office hours to make time for this. More details like on the QA section of the announcement site. As far as the paying students are concerned, this probably won't be much different than the profs' other research.
- nimrody 15y agoWhy would they? It's not like you're getting a degree from Stanford. It's very similar to MIT OpenCourseWare (and no way they will grade the assignments with so many students taking the course).
- linhir 15y agoI am most excited about the machine learning course, since I could use the structure to go through Andrew Ng's lectures; also the ones from 2008 are already out of date. As for the AI course, I'm skeptical, frankly. Sign-up right now has meant putting your name and email address. There is a big difference between spending 2 second to fill that in, and spending the amount of time necessary to finish the course. You come to a website that sounds like making robots and turns out the class is about developing pruning heuristics for search trees, do you stick with it? Maybe...but I'm going to save my awe for how many people complete. I praise Stanford (CS) for thinking up this idea. Like Khan, they are going to reach a lot of people, and I think its particularly useful for motivated learners who, for whatever reason, are stuck in a place that you can't take a good AI course or can't afford one. Ultimately, though, the course is going to require drive that a lot fewer than 65,000 have.
- v21 15y agoIf 1% of sign ups complete the course .. that's still 5800 people. Which is pretty good reach. And then add in all the people who didn't complete, or look at the materials afterwards, or who are otherwise affected by the project... These people don't have enough drive to get the full benefit, but they do get some benefit for sure.
- drallison 15y agoHN readers may find another free Stanford course of interest: EE380, the Stanford EE Computer Systems Colloquium. The Colloquium meets w4:15-5:30 throughout the academic year and moves re-runs during summer quarter. Lectures can be seen live, viewed in real-time over the web, viewed on-demand over the web, and eventually find their way onto YouTube, iTunes, and elsewhere. http://ee380.stanford.edu http://ee380.stanford.edu.
- NY_Entrepreneur 15y agoLearning is not a spectator sport. For material that is solid and clearly presented in a book, for a good student with good preparation and good motivation, it is enough for the student to study the book independently or nearly so. Indeed, such is nearly necessary. E.g., in 'research', how do you think the necessary background material is obtained? By signing up for 'courses'? Nope! Instead, the researcher gets the background materials, learns what is needed, and then gets on with the research. A researcher can't get paid just for getting the background material; instead, the researcher has to just do that seemingly effortlessly! Well, students, once they reach a suitable level of educational 'maturity', can too! E,g,, here on HN are many thousands of programmers who use computer hardware and software they never saw in a course. So, HN readers learned on their own. Such self-education has long been a central feature of the US computer industry. Net, researcher, HN reader, or serious student, all can learn solid material without a course, and do. Actually, learning outside a course is sometimes in academics considered almost 'cheating'! So, if a course is to be a 'filter', a competition, a 'stress test', then for a student to have worked carefully through solid texts on the material before the course lets them in the course effortlessly blow away all the students who started with the material only in the course. So, can get comments such as "Best student in the class by a wide margin, but apparently knew most of the material before the course.". So, there's commonly no doubt that it's possible to learn the material outside the course and to learn it well enough to lead the class in a corresponding course. Indeed, such self study can move forward at the student's own pace, faster some places, slower others, and, net, learn without gaps or wasted effort. Net, course or not, the actual learning is mostly or entirely from what the student does with the material alone in a quiet room. Of course, again, to get this good situation of self learning, need solid material clearly presented in, say, a book. Some subjects, sadly, are so vague that no such book can exist; in that case, maybe a course is 'needed', i.e., so that a student can soak up nonsense that couldn't be written down in solid form! For such, wander over to one of the 'humanities' departments and take one of the courses in 'political correctness'!
- dvse 15y agoCertainly nothing beats a good book, but often a good lecturer can give some intuition or motivations that are not customarily written down. I think a great example of this would be material on convex optimization released by Stephen Boyd (http://www.stanford.edu/class/ee364a/videos.html http://www.stanford.edu/class/ee364a/videos.html), also from Stanford - certainly his style is not as precise as e.g. Bertsekas, but probably much better at helping students to get a sense of how to actively work with those ideas.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ahalan 15y agoI bet ~5% will complete the course here is the number of views for Andrew Ng's Intro to machine learning course on youtube (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UzxYlbK2c7E http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UzxYlbK2c7E ) lec 1, 206612 lec 2, 91234 lec 3, 49000 lec 4, 36823 lec 5, 27782 lec 6, 26347 lec 7, 22075 lec 8, 20713 lec 9, 15665 lec 10, 14142 lec 11, 16573 lec 12, 14296 lec 13, 12401 lec 14, 15022 lec 15, 12290 lec 16, 10760 lec 17, 8986 lec 18, 13639 lec 19, 10219 lec 20, 11373
- czzarr 15y agothats a ton more people than the usual number of stanford enrolled students, it's a win for education in my book.
- nplusone 15y agoThese lectures are also available on iTunes U. It would be interesting to compare the number of YouTube views to the number of iTunes downloads. I watched the first two classes on YouTube, and downloaded the rest on iTunes, though admittedly I'm still only on lecture 6.
- jmilloy 15y agoThis sort of thinking is supported also by the fact that the number of views is not strictly decreasing.
- tassl 15y agoAny reason on why they are compacting the courses during the Fall quarter? It could be interesting to have AI and ML separated in Fall-Winter quarters. Anybody knows if they plan on doing something similar in future quarters? I love the idea, and I am excited to see the results of this methodology.
- Homunculiheaded 15y agoI'm really curious what affect this will have on Universities with relatively poor teachers in these areas. I remember taking algorithms with a very nice but not altogether great teacher, so in the evenings I would follow up class with the appropriate lecture of from the MIT OCW algorithms course. I've worked in higher-ed awhile and been a student for many, many years and noticed that independent of the quality of the school there are always smart, ambitious students to be found (the density just changes). I can imagine a relatively near future were the brightest students start class having already finished the course material at Standford, smiling and nodding at a relatively clueless prof. I've heard that there are highschools that assign their students the khan lectures for homework and in class do the exercises together, it would be interesting to see universities start to go this direction (where poorer profs would essentially become long distance TAs for Norvig et al.)
- puredemo 15y agoIt's absolutely a revolution in education. None of what you mention was possible ten years ago when I was in college.
- derrida 15y agoWhat is the name of the Stanford Course on compilers? I WANT I WANT!
- ChuckMcM 15y agoI really love this experiment. When I was in High School I was fortunate to be able to audit some University classes for which there wasn't an equivalent in my school district (numerical analysis and fortran programming). That allowed me to 'bank' time which would have nominally been wasted waiting to reach 'college age' or 'post HS diploma'. This is much more common today and my kids have all benefited from it. This experiement is sort of the next step. If we can combine that with free access to a syllabus of seminal papers (vs paying $36 each from some Journal publisher) it will allow a lot of people more time to do great things.
- bane 15y agoSo is this the eventual commoditization of a university education on the horizon or what?