4 ms·
Last time I ran through the numbers I was remembering that you'd have to eat a ridiculous amount of wild boar and/or wild mushrooms (assuming all were irradiate
by godelski 5y ago
Last time I ran through the numbers I was remembering that you'd have to eat a ridiculous amount of wild boar and/or wild mushrooms (assuming all were irradiated) on a daily basis to even approach dangerous levels.[0]
These stories make the rounds and constantly sound dangerous but the fact is that people just don't understand nuclear physics. I mean why would they? Everyone isn't taking college level physics classes, let alone ones on medical physics. If I wrote an article about how radiation levels in tuna doubled after the Fukushima disaster then people would stop eating tuna. This literally happened even though that doubling was to 5Bq/kg and Japanese limits are 100Bq/kg (US is 1.2kBq/kg). The fact is that our instruments for detecting radiation are extremely sensitive. You can measure radiation in everything. Yeah, the tuna got more radioactive after Fukushima, but that doesn't mean they got more dangerous. That's not how it works. And I'm tired of people that know absolutely nothing about nuclear physics talking as if they are experts on radiation. Both people in the pro and anti-nuclear camps do this and neither are helping.
[0] Cs137 has a dose factor of 0.014mSv/kBq and the high radiation had 600Bq/kg. So that's 0.0084mSv/kg of boar. European rose limit is 20mSv/yr, so that's 6.5kg of boar a day. And we need to note that 20mSv is well within the safety limit. 1 Sv is a 5.5% chance increase of cancer within your lifetime (LNT model which over estimates), so that's 6.5kg (14.3lbs) of boar a day to raise your lifetime risk of cancer by 1% (body shows to actually deal with these low levels of radiation fine).
Edit: If you're eating 14lbs of wild meat every single day, you probably have larger health issue than a 5% increased risk of cancer in your lifetime (the meat is probably giving you a higher chance of cancer).
- forgotmypw17 5y agoI think it is really arrogant to assume that you know what the dangerous levels are, and to claim that under a certain level is not dangerous or harmful. Time and time again, this type of thinking has been proven naive at best, and often criminally misleading: synthetic food additives, tobacco, opiate painkillers, radiation, leaded gasoline, and many, many more. When it comes to the health of myself and those close to me, I'm going to err on the side of caution, and disregard what the "official numbers" say.
- godelski 5y ago> I think it is really arrogant to assume that you know what the dangerous levels are, and to claim that under a certain level is not dangerous or harmful. Really? Because I have a degree in physics, studied radiation, and worked for years on radiation transport simulations and shielding. I think I have an above average knowledge of radiation physics and the effects on the human body. > synthetic food additives, tobacco, opiate painkillers, radiation, leaded gasoline, and many, many more. I mean yeah, don't trust Shell, Marlboro, or Purdue about their own products. Listen to the actual scientists. Because each of these examples has cases like these where there were other scientists demonstrating how these things were harmful. And each of these cases got political and a bunch of non-experts fought referencing papers they didn't even know how to read. Spoiler, there's no "big nuclear." > I'm going to err on the side of caution, and disregard what the "official numbers" say. Cool. But eating 3kg (6.6lbs) of wild boar a day is an absurd amount and under half of what I said was the "official numbers." Even 1kg/day (2.2lbs) is ludicrous. You're going to have way more health problems if you're eating that much boar every day. Be cautious. I'm not saying don't. I'm saying that you could be stuffing your face all day and you wouldn't come anywhere near "official numbers". You're going to kill yourself if you're eating 15lbs of meat every day.
- forgotmypw17 5y ago> Really? Because I have a degree in physics, studied radiation, and worked for years on radiation transport simulations and shielding. I think I have an above average knowledge of radiation physics and the effects on the human body. That is exactly what makes you an unrealiable source in my eyes, because you are biased towards the "we know what we're doing" perspective. You know a little more than others, but you think you know a lot, enough to make others' decisions and opinions for them.
- godelski 5y agoDon't trust scientists, got it.
- 5y ago
- cozzyd 5y agoFor context, a typical banana has about 15 Bq of activity (with a dose factor about a third of CS137).