3 ms·
Natural circulation gets heat from a reactor to X, but now your dependent on X. This often seems like a trivial detail, but Fukushima failed 3 days after the e
by Retric 5y ago
Natural circulation gets heat from a reactor to X, but now your dependent on X. This often seems like a trivial detail, but Fukushima failed 3 days after the earthquake.
The issue is you want several things from a passive system at the same time, don’t lose heat in normal operation, quickly lose multiple GW of heat in an emergency and as much as 200+MW of heat for days after a shutdown. The obvious solution is to have a tank of water that boils if the reactor temperature gets to high, but now you need to keep that tank full.
Thus many designs result in a reactor that is passively safe for some number of hours and at risk after that. They describe this as a passively safe reactor even if it’s got external dependencies.
- i_am_proteus 5y agoNope. Decay heat is below a half percent of operating after about a day. So 200 MW decay heat days later would mean a 40GW (thermal) reactor. That's about ten times larger than the largest reactors in existence today. Also, watts measure power, not heat.
- Retric 5y agoWatts is joules per second be that electricity, horsepower, or heat. Passive systems can’t assume a successful shutdown.
- mlyle 5y agoI can't figure out what you're saying here. You're assuming that the control rods aren't in, days later, for the purpose of calculating heat days after shutdown?
- Retric 5y agoI am saying passive safety can’t assume anything else worked.
- mlyle 5y agoIf you're going to apply "passive safety" globally, sure. But what we're talking about here is passive cooling system safety, not that the entire reactor is passively safe. The multiply-redundant shutdown systems suffice to end the chain reaction. If the chain reaction ends, you're pretty much immediately at 7% of decay heat -- so sure, a 1.5GW reactor will put out 100MW of decay heat, still. But this will rapidly fall off. After about an hour, it's more like 15MW; after a day, 6MW. Your statement of "200MW of decay heat" days later assumes either a ridiculous initial condition (an implausibly large reactor) or assumes you still have an operating reactor, which... isn't decay heat anymore.
- Retric 5y agoThere have been multiple cases where reactors haven’t fully shut down safely. Assuming a scram will 100% work every time in an emergency simply isn’t appropriate or realistic. Also, Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station has 3 different 4000MW thermal reactors, 7% of that is 280MW, though sure if everything shuts down properly it should hit ~15MW. Mitsubishi APWR is aiming for 4.5GW thermal in normal operation though some safety margin needs to be considered on top of that.
- mlyle 5y ago> There have been multiple cases where reactors haven’t fully shut down safely There's Chernobyl, and a few cases where a scram was delayed by 15 minutes or less. How can this produce hundreds of megawatts days later? > There have been multiple cases where reactors haven’t fully shut down safely. Assuming a scram will 100% work every time in an emergency simply isn’t appropriate or realistic. Assuming that every system fully fails is unrealistic, too. > 7% of that is 280MW, You said hundreds of megawatts days later. > Mitsubishi APWR is aiming for 4.5GW thermal in normal operation though some safety margin needs to be considered on top of that. What, they're going to run it over nameplate for days straight? A small excursion over 4.5GW won't appreciably change the amount of power output days later. Now you're just being silly.
- 5y ago
- i_am_proteus 5y agoThe watt is a measure of power, heat (or energy) per unit time.