10 ms·
> His parents let him buy a PC that he put together himself. It had a big memory card and a lot of processing power. He set it up in his bedroom. Looking back,
by teddyh 5y ago
> His parents let him buy a PC that he put together himself. It had a big memory card and a lot of processing power. He set it up in his bedroom. Looking back, José thinks “that may have been our biggest mistake”.
I don’t think I like these people.
> Occasionally, his parents caught glimpses of what he was doing. Mostly, he played games, especially the kind in which people are violently killed – such as by building amusement parks and then throwing people off the rides. There were also lots of shoot ’em ups.
Ah, yes.
> Edwin’s contacts abroad gave him a confidence boost. He spent hours chatting with people from all over the world about ways to hack websites. Edwin often mocked “normal” life and western society. He denounced materialism and superficial concerns.
As if that’s a bad sign.
- JadeNB 5y ago> > His parents let him buy a PC that he put together himself. It had a big memory card and a lot of processing power. He set it up in his bedroom. Looking back, José thinks “that may have been our biggest mistake”. > I don’t think I like these people. Since I read your comment before I RTFA, it wasn't immediately clear to me what was so awful about this. Just to be explicit, José is the mother of the teenage hacker in question, saying it was a mistake to get her son a computer. (I would think the remark considerably less reprehensible if it came from the hacker himself.)
- syshum 5y agoGiven the audience here I would image the majority of the people on this site had computers supplied by our parents at a young age, and we often played violent video games, or spent hours talking to people online yet we did not become criminals Scape goating video games, or "the internet" for these types of things is a long disproven trope. There are more factors in criminality that just playing a violent game or having computer supplied to you by your parents. Putting the blame on these things however is easier that looking at other more human causes.
- JadeNB 5y agoJust to be clear, I am not arguing that having a computer plays any role in criminality—except possibly that it gives mischievous and easily bored youngsters a healthy outlet for their curiosity and restlessness, which presumably militates against criminality. I was agreeing with teddyh (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28898239 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28898239) and I agree with you. I just meant to clarify (for the benefit of those who, like me, read the comments before the article) that José is the hacker's mother, not the hacker, which puts a different, and much darker, spin on the statement that José thinks that the hacker's getting a computer young was a bad thing.
- erikerikson 5y agoYou can fault the mother for thinking maybe if she never gave her son a computer a different outcome may have occurred? I see nothing of the generalization you accuse the mother of making, only a mother asking what wouldn't have allowed the eventual outcome she observed and we've now read about. Consider that the mother might simply be saying, "I wish reality had gone differently" but adding outcome specific details to say so. Of all the events in the casual chain, the alteration of many of them could have led to a better or worse outcome but the gift of the computer seems salient. I imagine most parents with children that die in car accidents question the gifting of a car. Doesn't mean they think cars are to blame, just fruitless, useless wishing that things had gone better.
- wtallis 5y agoThe parents think giving the kid a computer may have been their biggest mistake. That's not just a matter of them imagining things might have gone differently; they're saying the computer itself was one of the most significant causes of harm. It's like they're deliberately avoiding thinking about the real causes—the factors that led to their son experiencing a different and much worse outcome than the vast majority of people who spend "too much" time on computers as they're growing up.
- 5y ago
- watwut 5y agoI don't understand what is so reprehensible about it. Consequently he isolated himself and went into spiral and then everything went to hell. It is quite possible that had he not he'd his drug of choice in room, things were different. It is exactly the same thing if parents support soccer club and then the kid ends up spiraling with troublemakers. In retrospect the soccer was a mistake for this kid. Just because we like computers and they did good to us does not mean having 100% access to one for him was right decision. In fact, it did caused massive issues. The kid who leaves his room for socialization only is an issue. The kid who spends too much of his time playing video games is an issue. Some amount of playing is fine. Some amount of being alone is perfectly fine. The "out of room only for food and never going outside" is not fine. If there is anything that harms young men, it that the above is normalized instead of being seen as sign the kid is loosing ability to cope with both real life and computer. And then, when they are alone, depressed or bursting angry, everything and everyone is blamed. Parents should be even more understanding, the girls should have go out of their way to meet guys in their rooms, the teachers are horrible for not tolerating them mistreating other kids and so on and so forth. Except that saying that having kids socialization primary online, purely in gaming and hacking communities is a bad idea, because those can be quite atrocious.
- wtallis 5y ago> In retrospect the soccer was a mistake for this kid. Do you not see how the absurdity of this sentence exposes the fallacy in the preceding paragraph? Neither soccer nor computers are at all plausible causes of these serious mental health problems. That's just a simple post hoc, ergo propter hoc fallacy. At most, they could merely be the context in which other issues developed into a serious problem.
- watwut 5y ago> Neither soccer nor computers are at all plausible causes of these serious mental health problems. In some soccer clubs and in some computer subcultures, large issue is peer influence. The values and behavior you learn are causing problems. And yes, removing the child from the peers influence oftentimes in fact makes the child improve a lot. In this case also, the excessive gaming is contributing to mental health problems. It feels good temporarily or while playing, but does not cure the problem. Instead, it makes it worst due to isolation.
- politelemon 5y ago> Occasionally, his parents caught glimpses of what he was doing. Mostly, he played games, especially the kind in which people are violently killed – such as by building amusement parks and then throwing people off the rides. There were also lots of shoot ’em ups. It's quite clear to me that he should have spent his gaming time watching violence and gore on television instead, like regular people.
- axiosgunnar 5y agoThis, so much
- iso1210 5y agoAre they seriously claiming that Roller-coaster Tycoon is a gore game?
- beebeepka 5y agoJack Thompson is back, baby. This story reads like something straight out of the 90s
- FDSGSG 5y agoI recall him playing Garry's mod, that could definitely fit the bill.
- all2 5y agoNo bathrooms. Sink traps (block in the exit side of a ride), roller coasters that fling entire cars of people into oblivion... Surely I'm not the only one who explored the macabre side of this game?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pen2l 5y agoMaybe comments like these are upvoted because it's fun to be contrarian, or maybe because a significant subset of HN audience consists of outliers like Robbe himself and empathize with folks like him easily. But this does not even begin to make his behavior defensible or something to gloss over. He was a threat to society, and yet in your comment it's only his mother you reserve words of dislike for; a grieving mother no less, by her own admission technically inept, who probably tried her best. The ugly nihilism to which YUI and others adhered to is something we should look at to prevent future YUI's. Was it the violent video games that turned him this way? I don't know, but it's worth thinking about probably. Why did he refuse to participate in a social society? Maybe if he took the time to work out in a gym and keep on top of his game this all wouldn't have happened.
- FDSGSG 5y ago> maybe because a significant subset of HN audience consists of outliers like Robbe himself and empathize with folks like him easily. I am one of those people. I knew YUI as a kid, I logged into those KPN computers too. I'd always thought he'd moved on, I never found out about his death until now, or perhaps someone told me and I assumed they were kidding. Now, I can't help but wonder how many other friends who I thought to be retired are actually dead? Despite - or perhaps because of - my experiences I couldn't help but agree with you more. I found it deeply disturbing to see all the comments here berating his grieving family for wondering if they'd made a mistake letting him on the computer. I know my parents must have thought the same every time the cops came to our home, they would've been entirely justified in that. I turned out okay, but as far as I can tell most of us didn't.
- wtallis 5y ago> I don't know, but it's worth thinking about probably. No, it's not—at least not for more than a few moments. This is really obviously not a useful red flag to worry about. Violent video games are very widely popular, and have been for many years now. It's still quite rare for their users to turn into criminals. Highlighting things like playing violent video games is merely shining a spotlight on something we already know won't help anyone identify future criminals. That spotlight should instead be focused on traits and behaviors that aren't very common in the general population. A lot of the critics of the general category of violent video games are people who wish to censor them, without any real evidence that a social good would result. These parents—or at least the journalist reporting on them—have lumped themselves in with the would-be censors by presuming that the son's video game preferences were a warning sign they should have been paying attention to.
- f480045a12b8 5y agoI truly hope that you never lose a child. However, you can at least understand that "these people" lost their son, and are grieving. A bit of fucking empathy is appropriate.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wtallis 5y agoIt seems likely that their grieving is not why they're laying the blame in such inappropriate places. They've probably had those misconceptions for a long time. Now that their son is dead, it would be rude to criticize them in direct communication, but it doesn't really make them any less wrong.
- PicassoCTs 5y agoGrieving by lashing out at all he ever touched and associated with, to absolve themselves from being a failure as a parent in times of need?
- metagame 5y agoThey didn't help their son while he was alive, and blamed the bad outcomes of his life on the single object that seemed to bring him joy. They even turned him away when he came home for help, according to the article. They allowed their child to degenerate in front of them and it wasn't because of the computer; it was because they didn't do anything for him. Empathy should be encouraged but in this case the mindset of the parents contributed to their son's suicide, and empathy should be had for the child instead of the parents.
- bettysdiagnose 5y agoSeems wildly reductive to assume that over 22 years they didn't ever really try to raise him. I mean you could be right, but chances are, they did try.
- metagame 5y ago
- throwawaygh 5y agoI think this is a highly uncharitable read of his step-parents: 1. Adopting children and raising them as your own is already an act of extraordinary personal sacrifice and blind love. 2. His parents were supportive of his hobby and interest in computers, but were also concerned about his social and behavioral development. They weren't the only ones -- folks at his school were similarly concerned. He had trouble sleeping and had no friends. Neither of those is normal and both indicate Edwin was in serious pain. 3. His parents likely weren't wrong that he was using video games and hacking as crutches instead of addressing the root causes of his depression and anxiety. They likely weren't wrong that these crutches were beginning to form a vicious cycle. There's nothing inherently bad about video games, but IMO his parents were probably correct to be concerned in his case. 4. Forming all of your closest relationships around involvement in destructive and unproductive activity that's criminal and driven by ego is a bad sign! Hacking websites is a crime; almost never violent, but also not victimless! Would you say the same thing about a child whose only friends are folks who he breaks into buildings with? 5. Turning away even a grown child is beyond sad, but at that point he was 22 and cooking up drugs in their house. And they had younger children.