6 ms·
Ask a Librarian
- blakesterz 5y agoThe LoC is great, and so is your local library! Public and Academic libraries all have some kind of "Ask A" service. They are a great resource!
- ytdytvhxgydvhh 5y agoIf your question is history-related, /r/AskHistorians is great too: https://old.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/ https://old.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/
- paulpauper 5y agothis has to be the most heavily moderated sub I have ever seen. all the comments show as deleted .
- Claude_Shannon 5y agoIt is, but at the same time - when you get an answer, you can be sure it is of a high quality.
- mkmk 5y agoTry looking at some older posts that have had time to accumulate high quality responses. The “remind me later” and Weekly Review features work quite well, if you have a Reddit account.
- leeoniya 5y agoI drink and I know things.
- shellback3 5y agoMy wife's mother was a head librarian and 'Ask a Librarian' is her motto. Thanks for the link.
- yummypaint 5y agoLibrary resources are the best information finding tools that hardly anyone uses. I frequently see even grad students who should know better futility trying to google for relevant academic papers. Use the subject headings! They are assigned by real humans who actually understand the content! It's night and day vs whatever web search engines are doing these days. If you have never used these kinds tools before to discover new information, give it a try, you will be pleasantly surprised. It's incredibly refreshing for every result to be a long form exploration of the topic instead of mindless clickbait copied from Wikipedia intro sections.
- tasogare 5y agoI'm a grad student and I don't know what you are talking about. The local library software is not better than Google Scholar, in fact it's only good when you know what you want to find already and there is a paper version in some of the libraries of the university (top-3 of the country). Otherwise GS and Sci-hub are doing the job very fine.
- math-dev 5y agoI wanted to come and say the same thing
- suchow 5y agoThe parent comment says that, of all the information-finding tools that hardly anyone uses, library resources are the best, not that library resources are the best information-finding tools; there's no contradiction between what the two of you have noticed.
- chillpenguin 5y agoI think you misunderstood one or both of the comments. The original commenter was saying that for certain use cases, the library tools are far superior to typical web search tools. Then the other commenter was saying they disagree, saying that the library tools are only good if you know exactly what you want, and how they prefer Google Scholar.
- hikerclimber1 5y agoEverything is subjective. Especially laws.
- mattowen_uk 5y agoI've been married to a qualified Librarian for 20 years and I can say first hand that it's not about the information, but the skills required to find it. You and I can spend hours trying to hunt down a worthy well cited resource on a topic, whereas a good Librarian can find it in minutes. Then there's the cross referencing skills, the cataloguing skills, the ability to digest information and produce an accurate summary... It's a whole heap of data and information management skills not just confined to books. Being a Librarian is one of the world's oldest professions, and technology is a long way off replacing them. Also, support your local library!
- rackjack 5y ago> You and I can spend hours trying to hunt down a worthy well cited resource on a topic, whereas a good Librarian can find it in minutes. This is kind of a silly question, but do just say to a librarian something like, "I'm looking for a book on implementing compilers." And they'll give you some? And when you finish those, can you say "Wow, I really liked so-and-so book, and I'm especially interested in so-and-so optimization. Do you know any books on that?" I've basically always worked out what I needed on my own, so I'm not sure how to talk to librarians.
- sushsjsuauahab 5y agoI think their skill lies in being able to filter the entire library's contents down to a handful of best guesses. If you ask them "give me all the books whose main topic is compilers", you might have too large of a result set, and maybe they would prompt you for a more specialized keyword that they can use to further narrow down the results. I suppose it is better than brute-forcing an entire shelf of books :)
- wolverine876 5y agoYes, and they'll find the authoritative books. Of course a general reference librarian is most helpful to a general audience. If you are a professional developer, you want a specialist reference librarian, for example, one in computer science. IME the specialist librarians are generally at university libraries, but they will answer respectful questions from the public up to a point (they aren't going to do a research project for you), especially those in public universities. For example, I was looking for a history of a specific time period of a certain country. There were books available, but I couldn't discern the credible from the nonsense, the fringe from the consensus from the advocate for a specific theory or cause, etc. I emailed the specialist librarian for that region of the world at an Ivy League school; they had a PhD from Yale in the field, and of course could immediately tell me everything I wanted to know, and even generously shared more recommendations.
- JoeDaDude 5y agoFor those interested in Linguistics, there is also Ask a Linguist https://askaling.linguistlist.org/questions/ https://askaling.linguistlist.org/questions/
- chuckee 5y agoI have a question: Librarians are fiercely protective of reading privacy, and don't want to hand the information on who borrowed which book to the police. Yet they still record that information. Why? Wouldn't it be better to, for example, require a cash deposit equal to the value of the borrowed books, possibly in the form of some token? And if some books were too expensive, you'd still have the option of presenting some personally-identifiable ID. But the record of what you borrowed would be destroyed after you returned the book.
- lwf 5y agoMost libraries do not record that information once material is returned. See SFPL: > 10. The Library does not maintain a history of what a library user has previously checked out once books and materials have been returned on time4. > 11. When fines accrue on a user's account, the Library does maintain records of items that have been borrowed but returned after the due date, or are still outstanding on the user's record. When overdue materials are returned and all associated fines are paid, the information associated with the library card number is deleted. > 4 Library users may choose to opt in and enable My Check-out History. By doing so library users choose to give explicit consent to the storage of their Check-out History from the opt-in date. Library personnel will not access or release Check-out History unless required by law to do so. Library users may opt out of this service and delete Check-out History at any time. (Noted - November 30, 2011) https://sfpl.org/about/privacy-policy#text-40586 https://sfpl.org/about/privacy-policy#text-40586
- thebeardisred 5y agoImmediate thought I have after reading through some of the comments: Sheesh! How many of us (myself included) are partnered to librarians. =)
- 8bitsrule 5y agoResearch is an art top libraries are best at. Many years back, I wanted to write-up an old, long-OOB publisher I was curious about. The internet Schultzed me - "I know nothing, nothing!" Then I remembered how helpful 'Ask NYPL' (still exists) had once been in the past (when I'd called their 1-800 number with a question about where to find instruction.) The publisher question took a while. NYPL weren't able to find a lot on the business but what they did find was key pieces - a business address and a clue that led to the author/owner's -real- name. Following up on that, the puzzle was soon (mostly) unlocked as a result. (Time's passage rubs out many details.)
- flobosg 5y agoThis was a suggestion in the last issue of the Recomendo newsletter (https://www.getrevue.co/profile/Recomendo/issues/ask-a-librarian-list-of-useful-websites-poetry-zine-804452 https://www.getrevue.co/profile/Recomendo/issues/ask-a-libra...), which is full of these kind of tips.
- kashyapc 5y agoA hot-tip: if you live in a town/city with a university, it can be highly worthwhile to subscribe to the faculty library of a topic of your interest. These faculty libraries tend to have far more valuable references. I pay a paltry 20 euros (!) as a yearly subscription for the local university's Arts&Philosophy faculty library. It gives me access to some outstanding books that are often very expensive. I was delighted when I accidentally discovered the facility to this subscription.