3 ms·
Polygenic screening of embryos is here, but is it ethical?
- uniqueuid 5y agoAs I commented on another relevant link (Gwern's treatment of embryo screening): While this is a very exhaustive and eloquent argument in favor of embryo selection, it seems that (at first glance) some important risks are not really addressed. For example, what if social dysfunctionality is a function not only of individual intelligence but also of the distribution of intelligence across the population? There may be negative consequences from an overall upwards shift. (Crude analogy: Compare the discussion on the threat of a surplus of young males in societies). What if the reported effects are non-linear, i.e. distinct between sub-mean and above-mean intelligence? Given our extremely lacking understanding of how societies work in general (i.e.: financial markets, social unrest, individual happiness etc.), I am really hesitant to believe that we are able to anticipate even a tiny amount of such an approach's implications. And, of course, embryo selection would violate several fundamental humanist values - would society need to penalize people for opting out? Are we confident enough in society's self-regulating mechanisms to trust that such an instrument would be always used ethically? Interfering with children is so terrifying because the fallout lasts a hundred years. That calls for some more humility, I think.
- crate_barre 5y agoIt seems we are headed for level 2 of the abortion debate with stuff like this. Surely in the West we’ll have the open debate, but most of the world won’t. A place like China will do the most practical thing (practical vs humane). I can’t help but think of this Onion article: https://www.theonion.com/autistic-child-ruins-marriage-he-was-born-to-save-1819571355 https://www.theonion.com/autistic-child-ruins-marriage-he-wa... My body my choice will soon morph into ‘Our family, our choice’. I’m pro-choice for what it’s worth, but there are limits to all of this.
- h2odragon 5y agoMore important; if you don't think this is ethical; what are you willing to do, to keep others from doing it? There's folks already convinced we have human clones running around, that was decided to be bad as far as I know but the possibility has existed for a while now... Anyone betting there aren't any clones now? Will you extend that bet another decade?