3 ms·
Do all people want power? Seems like Nietzsche would probably agree, but Damocles would voice objections. Seems like what most people want is something more ak
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
Do all people want power? Seems like Nietzsche would probably agree, but Damocles would voice objections.
Seems like what most people want is something more akin to self-determination. It isn't quite power, and it isn't quite freedom, but somewhere in the middle.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhat is self determination? Having the freedom to do what you want to do is the same as having the power to do what you want to do. Having the power to attract your desired mate is also a power, and it involves showing you have power.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoThe nuance is in the contrast between freedom from compulsion and the ability to compel. Most care about the former but power only grants the latter. Do you want to enslave your partner? Compel them to live with you against their will?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe power to be free from compulsion is also power. I understand the distinction you are trying to make, but it is all on one spectrum. Do I want to enslave my partner or compel them to live with me against their will? No. I am sure others in history have wanted that and still do today. But the important thing is you need power to not be enslaved by others, even if that just means living within the borders of a tribe of people who act against slavery. Since money is a proxy for power, and since resources are finite and we do not live in this world without effecting others, I would say the distinction of having the power to be free from compulsion and the power to compel others is very, very murky. For example, I am not using my power to directly compel someone with violence like a slave owner, but I know that living the quality of life that people in the top 10% to 20% of the US do is for sure compelling others to live with more pollution and/or fewer resources due to me consuming so many resources. I am pretty sure this claim could be made for anyone living in a detached single family house, or even people with more than 2 kids. Or maybe even 1 kid. If we go back to the original claim: > The idea that the only, or even primary, incentive to do stuff is money is an invention of 20th century economics. Yes, people like doing things for their community or helping others here and there, but functionally no one is going to change bed pans in a nursing home without getting something in return.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoIt is questionable whether these two ever actually met, but the moral of the story is relevant so I'll repeat the tale. Alexander the Great, the embodiment of power, approached notorious hobo philosopher Diogenes the Cynic and asked if there was anything he can do for him. Sunbathing Diogenes asks Alexander if he wouldn't mind stepping to the side a bit, as he is blocking the light. Alexander is able to compel armies and lay countries to ruin, but Diogenes is resistant to all compulsion but is without land, possessions, rank, title, nobility, reputation, and so on. There is nothing you can take away from him he hasn't already given up, no hardship you can impose on him that he does not willingly endure. Even the times he is de facto enslaved, he is still free, because he willingly subjects himself to any punishment. It would be an absurd conclusion that the reason Diogenes is able to make a mockery of this request is because this homeless man is more powerful than Alexander the Great.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> It would be an absurd conclusion that the reason Diogenes is able to make a mockery of this request is because this homeless man is more powerful than Alexander the Great. The only moral of this story I understood is that it is nonsensical to compare two different metrics. I do not know how one would come to the above conclusion, comparing Alexander’s power over many others to Diogenes’ power over himself and presumably pain receptors. Alexander being able to kill Diogenes more easily than Diogenes being able to kill Alexander would be a proper comparison, or Alexander being able to compel more people than Diogenes, but even then, I fail to see the utility for this discussion.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoWell let's go back to the statement you made a few comments ago > Money is a proxy for power. Has a better alternative proxy to power been demonstrated to exist? Here the a man with no possessions suddenly has power, and the richest most powerful man in the world struggles to exert power.
- 5y ago