5 ms·
It he only incentive to do stuff money? Asking because I find myself building a lot of stuff despite not really making money off it.
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
It he only incentive to do stuff money?
Asking because I find myself building a lot of stuff despite not really making money off it.
- sokoloff 5y agoAre you building hobby things for your entertainment (which I do as well) or building things which make society advance and which others benefit from? It’s the loss of incentives for the latter that concern me.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoWell, both. I'm building and running this: https://search.marginalia.nu/ https://search.marginalia.nu/ Paid the server out of pocket, built the code all by myself. I do take donations that currently just about cover the running costs, but at this surplus it will take me something like 30 years to get back the hardware investment (assuming no hardware fails in the interim and running costs don't increase). Don't take this as complaining, it's just a statement of facts. I'm incredibly grateful that so many people are supporting it.
- agumonkey 5y agobuilding what ? I'm curious
- marginalia_nu 5y agoI've built and operate a search engine.
- tibbetts 5y agoThe idea that the only, or even primary, incentive to do stuff is money is an invention of 20th century economics. It was then tragically taught to most educated people, especially business leaders. That made it a sort of self-fulfilling prophecy, along with the shareholder value myth (the idea that companies should be (may even be required to be) entirely short term profit motivated out of a duty to shareholders. These are among the most harmful ideas from the 20th century. To answer your original question, no money is not the only incentive to do stuff. But in Econ 101 that assumption is made to make the math easy.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe incentive to do work is to gain power. The power to feed and house your kids, the power to not be tortured or killed if you are a slave, the power to obtain other things you want. Money is a proxy for power. Has a better alternative proxy to power been demonstrated to exist?
- marginalia_nu 5y agoDo all people want power? Seems like Nietzsche would probably agree, but Damocles would voice objections. Seems like what most people want is something more akin to self-determination. It isn't quite power, and it isn't quite freedom, but somewhere in the middle.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhat is self determination? Having the freedom to do what you want to do is the same as having the power to do what you want to do. Having the power to attract your desired mate is also a power, and it involves showing you have power.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoThe nuance is in the contrast between freedom from compulsion and the ability to compel. Most care about the former but power only grants the latter. Do you want to enslave your partner? Compel them to live with you against their will?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe power to be free from compulsion is also power. I understand the distinction you are trying to make, but it is all on one spectrum. Do I want to enslave my partner or compel them to live with me against their will? No. I am sure others in history have wanted that and still do today. But the important thing is you need power to not be enslaved by others, even if that just means living within the borders of a tribe of people who act against slavery. Since money is a proxy for power, and since resources are finite and we do not live in this world without effecting others, I would say the distinction of having the power to be free from compulsion and the power to compel others is very, very murky. For example, I am not using my power to directly compel someone with violence like a slave owner, but I know that living the quality of life that people in the top 10% to 20% of the US do is for sure compelling others to live with more pollution and/or fewer resources due to me consuming so many resources. I am pretty sure this claim could be made for anyone living in a detached single family house, or even people with more than 2 kids. Or maybe even 1 kid. If we go back to the original claim: > The idea that the only, or even primary, incentive to do stuff is money is an invention of 20th century economics. Yes, people like doing things for their community or helping others here and there, but functionally no one is going to change bed pans in a nursing home without getting something in return.
- readflaggedcomm 5y agoThe author thinks so. Money isn't the only way to be compensated, but it's a measure of value. I wonder if the author would cap all value transfers, or just monetary. What about limiting in-kind compensation by transfers of land, securities, food, or reputation?
- stickfigure 5y agoFor some stuff, the only incentive is money. Nobody's going to haul your garbage away because that's what fulfills them.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoIf nobody wants to do that, that seems like a real big incentive to find a better solution to the problem.
- skinkestek 5y ago> Nobody's going to haul your garbage away because that's what fulfills them. Maybe not directly as individuals but a number of companies makes money from trash ;-)
- bart_spoon 5y agoMoney isn’t the only incentive to do anything, but there are plenty of things for which money is the only incentive, a lot of which are pretty critical for functioning societies.