4 ms·
The difference is that construction is largely doing the exact same thing that has been refined over thousands of years and we know very well how it goes and ha
by Gigachad 5y ago
The difference is that construction is largely doing the exact same thing that has been refined over thousands of years and we know very well how it goes and have formulas to precalculate everything. So you can have a set of building codes which if you follow, are very likely to produce a perfectly fine building.
While software development is completely making things up as you go because it hasn’t ever been done before. Any kind of government regulation would end up as a box checking exercise that wouldn’t add any more safety and probably introduce problems when products have nonsensical decisions added in to fit with some requirements.
- blippage 5y agoI'll add that we expect software to work on highly heterogeneous systems, too. If you're working on a bridge, you known exactly the terrain you're required to span. The engineers battle with a lot of integration issues, but at least they know what they're dealing with. With software development, well, who's to say what integration issues that millions of people might face?
- wongarsu 5y agoOn the other hand our ability to precalculate everything in construction seems to be fairly novel, in the sense that complex geometries are very hard to calculate without computer simulations. And most buildings we build today are nothing like those we built 200 years ago. The necessity of modelling building behaviour has pushed the field forwards. For software we know that modelling and verification works in principle, but little time is spent on improving the methods because there's no demand
- p2t2p 5y agoI counter that with that we’ve got methods of developing relyable software and we’ve got examples of success. We’ve got all sorts of different tiers of testing and verification, we’ve got various CI/CD approaches and NASA seems to be landing one rover after another and flying an freaking helicopter on a freaking another planet, autonomously. We’ve got the tools to explore unknowns. Now, as to regulation. It could be written in a way that would relieve that “developer-of-record” out of responcibility provided they did their due diligence and, if new unknown happened that wasn’t foreseen the regulations will adapt and change and make a learning out of it, just like it was with building industry and road rules.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> I counter that with that we’ve got methods of developing relyable software We don't have methods for reliable spelling, however...
- p2t2p 5y agoMy spelling is horrible, especially when I write on the phone, I know, sorry
- DaiPlusPlus 5y agoYou're fine :) it's just ironic