4 ms·
Ah I remember when I thought like this. I was so young and naive. Good times. Fact of the matter is, software is NOT like building a bridge, or any other engin
by phendrenad2 5y ago
Ah I remember when I thought like this. I was so young and naive. Good times.
Fact of the matter is, software is NOT like building a bridge, or any other engineering discipline, it's much, much more complex. We'll never achieve high reliability for anything but the simplest software (reactor control rooms come to mind). Accept the fact that software is hopelessly broken, and find tactics to deal with it.
- d0ugal 5y agoIIUC NASA achieve high reliability for problems that don’t seem simple.
- Madmallard 5y agoYeah, because their incentives strongly align with it. The argument is that the incentives don't align outside of mission critical systems.
- d0ugal 5y agoRight, agreed. I was replying to this from the comment. Which seemed to claim it was impossible. > We'll never achieve high reliability for anything but the simplest software Sorry, I wasn’t very clear!
- AniseAbyss 5y agoSometimes your seemingly non mission critical software can be exploited in such a way that the entire system is cracked wide open.
- resonious 5y agoTrue and unfortunately this doesn't often result in any damage until way later when someone buys your sensitive documents and commits fraud. By the time the fraud happens, we likely have no idea which breach the info even came from.
- slx26 5y agoAgree and disagree. On the one hand, I do agree a lot with the idea that software is a moving target, and it's not enough to build, but you have to maintain it. The whole ecosystem is continually changing, needs are changing, best ways to do things are changing. Formats change, protocols change, etc. I believe acknowledging that is vital in being able to become an effective software developer (I mean, if you are working with a microcontroller or a very well defined and fixed environment, it's another story, of course). But on the other hand, I don't want to accept that we will never achieve high reliability. I've heard and read multiple times that software goes through an expansion phase (an exploratory phase), until we eventually manage to gain enough insight and clarity as to be able to go back and simplify to something that we can wrap our head around again. Certainly, while developing, I often find myself in this situation. For many problems, you don't understand them until you have written the solution, come across new problems, and are able to rewrite again with much greater understanding... a clean solution. Now, there are many very complex problems. Some solutions will never be clean. But we do definitely have light years of room for improvement. Networking is messy. OpenGL / Vulkan / low level graphic APIs are unwieldy and inelegant. Same for most databases and SQL. Audio APIs are not much more pleasant. Real time systems are mythical creatures for the average developer. Filesystems are not as homogeneous and standardized as we would like. Browsers are monsters. We can't even agree on what units use for UI elements. We don't really have much idea of how to handle screens of different sizes. Common file formats shouldn't even be a software concern most of the time. We talk so much about type systems but still define most protocol specs in plain text. Interoperability is mostly C or die. Unicode is many things besides a standard for symbols. Too many. Permissions and privacy are... well, maybe it's better to stop for today. And that's indeed the reason why software must be a moving target. Because we can't accept these foundations to stay as our original, unerasable sin. But I do believe there is a real possibility to do better. One day devs will unite in a mystical place outside the realm of "pressure to deliver", we will agree on what are the main priorities and opportunities for improvement, and we will coordinate to start changing things and make our asylum a saner place. Coordination might be both the biggest technical and non-technical problem we will ever have to face, but I find no reason to believe we can't handle it.
- fsflover 5y ago
- resonious 5y agoI pretty much agree with this and I also think the reality is people don't care. The stakes are so low that there's no money in well-built software (most of the time). The average user isn't paying out of their pocket and wouldn't even if you offered a more stable experience in exchange for cash.