3 ms·
Either evidence or argument would make your post more convincing. "It's so" doesn't move the needle in many minds.
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
Either evidence or argument would make your post more convincing. "It's so" doesn't move the needle in many minds.
- seattle_spring 5y agoWhy did you add this comment to parent instead of GP, which started this whole thing with a similarly unsourced claim?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoWell... I give the first person a bit more slack in that situation. Stating a claim can be interesting, even with no substantiation. (It isn't always, but it can be.) But a rebuttal that just says "no, it's not" is, in my view, considerably less useful or interesting or whatever. I expect more from a rebuttal than I do from a statement of an initial position - partly because not all statements of an initial position will get a rebuttal, but every rebuttal is in reply to a stated position. Maybe that's just me...