9 ms·
Weaponized Architecture
- qez 5y agoThis is weaponized verbiage. "My opponents are wrong because I assume they have harmful motivations." Way to dodge the actual point of contention: whether modern art styles are ugly vs classical styles. Most people should not and do not care whether the architecture "attacks progressivism", because beauty itself is the goal.
- chrisshroba 5y agoCouldn’t agree more. There are so many unsubstantiated assumptions about intent made in this article.
- qsort 5y agoI'm sick and tired of "weaponized verbiage", as you put it, as much as the next guy, but I don't agree with your rendition: > the actual point of contention: whether modern art styles are ugly vs classical styles This is not the point. The point it (from TFA): > this executive order would place restrictions on the architectural design of federal buildings Which is, at a minimum, weird. Why would anybody want to do that (by decree, no less) is beyond me.
- roenxi 5y agoWhile opinionated, there is nothing weird about liking classical architecture or powerful people imposing their artistic preferences. I'm not sure how anyone could manage to spin promoting classical architecture as some sort of unpleasant scheme, but I'm sure someone is going to try. The stuff is beautiful. At some point there has to be some admission that Trump isn't wrong about literally everything.
- qsort 5y ago> restrictions on the architectural design That's not the equivalent of saying 'classical architecture is beautiful', that's the equivalent of saying 'no architecture except classical architecture is beautiful'. Is St. Peter's Basilica ugly because it is Baroque? Is Notre-Dame ugly because it is Gothic? Come on, far from me to espouse the "neoclassical bad" twitter-tier nonsense take, but the claim that only neoclassical should be allowed is... weird, Trump or no Trump.
- skewart 5y agoThe weird part was banning people from building anything that isn’t neoclassical. The order wasn’t promoting neoclassicism as much as it was attacking everything else. If the Trump administration’s approach was just to build a lot of neoclassical buildings nobody would have cared.
- throwaway59553 5y ago>Which is, at a minimum, weird. Why would anybody want to do that (by decree, no less) is beyond me. This is what governments and rulers have done since Mankind started building stuff. You're fixating in the legal tecnicalities like a law or executive order, but it has always been like that. Governments and rulers always set the style of public buildings. The reason for that, is left as an exercise for the reader.
- rbanffy 5y ago> Why would anybody want to do that (by decree, no less) is beyond me. Identitarian politicians have done it for ages. It’s about shaping a population’s view of themselves based on an idealised past.
- throwaway59553 5y ago>Additionally, the idea that anyone alive today could truly understand “what our founders had in mind” is completely irrational.[...] I cannot believe that someone that writes this has ever read anything the American Founding fathers have written. They were very prolific writers, and pretty much everything is available online for free. The author should read those before trying to imply that people who disagree with him are some tasteless and ignorant fools.
- m000 5y agoThe thing is, it doesn't matter what the founding fathers have written (or not). If you have to appeal to a (supposed) authority, then you're probably talking BS. The founding fathers were important historical figures, but they were also men of their time. Did anyone ever asked "What would George Washington say about electric cars?". No, because he wouldn't have a clue.
- rbanffy 5y agoI’m pretty sure Ben Franklin would be fascinated. Your point still stands, however. To think that the wisdom of white male slave owners is somewhat unquestionable is so deeply flawed i can’t assume good intentions.
- mellavora 5y agoSigh. You question these people's wisdom because they are "white male slave owners". Did you ever think that because they were confronted with the reality of slavery they were much much more attuned to the issues of human rights than say a tech worker in our society who doesn't notice that almost everything they use and touch was made by slaves? Who built that iphone? Sewed your clothes? Who mined the cobalt which allows your lithium batteries? And even in the west, slave labor hasn't gone away. We just hide it in private prisons or "illegal" immigrants. We are much better at tech than the founding fathers, but I have no evidence that we are any better at moral and/or political philosophy (and quite a bit of evidence against).
- bedobi 5y agoModern architecture and urban planning, especially in the US, really has failed, and defending the ugly, unsustainable, car-dependent human-deserted urban hells it has produced in the name of progressivism is really, really strange. Examples of architecture and urban planning that actually aligns much better with progressivism would be the Netherlands and other places in Europe that have banned cars and appreciate the value of quiet, walkable neighbourhoods that are at a human scale, conducive to public life and align with and satisfy the aesthetic tastes of the public. Of course, architects and urban planners really, really hate that last part. They still suffer from megalomaniacal delusions like those of Le Corbusier. They want to make statements, and if that means torturing the public so be it. (they're totally progressives though!) Meanwhile, most people just want to exist in spaces that aren't hostile to human life and joy.
- OneTimePetes 5y agoNeeds more glass gurkens ... sorry, non-constructive, but the architecture appealing to the powerful is always ignoring the needs of the citizens - since medieval times. Look at the noble towers in tuscany.. and you already can see the ugly powers-that-bee-blowjob-architecture that carries through to the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burj_Khalifa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burj_Khalifa.
- rsj_hn 5y agoOf the many, many differences between modern and traditional architecture is that if you look at a modern building you have absolutely no idea where it is. It could be in Melbourne, Vancouver, Chicago, Santiago, Los Angeles, etc -- it doesn't matter, because there is no notion of working with local materials, using traditional local idioms. It doesn't try to "fit" into a neighborhood, it tries to stand out. Yes, there are some exceptions, but they are very few. The other thing that really bothers me is the lack of proper scale. It doesn't seem human scaled at all. Here walkability is a big problem as it's very unpleasant to walk around modern architecture. In the Federal building in San Francisco, which seems to be designed to intimidate, this is the view of someone walking by the north side: https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7795358,-122.4125483,3a,75y,134.57h,88.67t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sYzpSvRhVg-TN1IPQ4H0ckw!2e0!6shttps:%2F%2Fstreetviewpixels-pa.googleapis.com%2Fv1%2Fthumbnail%3Fpanoid%3DYzpSvRhVg-TN1IPQ4H0ckw%26cb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile.gps%26w%3D203%26h%3D100%26yaw%3D183.33746%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7795358,-122.4125483,3a,75y,... East side: https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7798315,-122.4116884,3a,75y,226.09h,110.67t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sPA-03x8-yufxc4scC9qC0A!2e0!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7798315,-122.4116884,3a,75y,... south side: https://www.google.com/maps/@37.778619,-122.4117745,3a,75y,313.27h,85.19t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1slqttE8VpnqgXVHK2Ti4u6A!2e0!6shttps:%2F%2Fstreetviewpixels-pa.googleapis.com%2Fv1%2Fthumbnail%3Fpanoid%3DlqttE8VpnqgXVHK2Ti4u6A%26cb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile.gps%26w%3D203%26h%3D100%26yaw%3D271.53812%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@37.778619,-122.4117745,3a,75y,3... West side: https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7785627,-122.412846,3a,75y,44.26h,100.69t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sbu4CJUvi2_KXoodv1B_HJQ!2e0!6shttps:%2F%2Fstreetviewpixels-pa.googleapis.com%2Fv1%2Fthumbnail%3Fpanoid%3Dbu4CJUvi2_KXoodv1B_HJQ%26cb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile.gps%26w%3D203%26h%3D100%26yaw%3D43.223248%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7785627,-122.412846,3a,75y,4... Suffice it to say, it doesn't promote walkability. Meanwhile, here is a much older federal building just a few blocks down: https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7808148,-122.4143869,3a,75y,171.88h,77.06t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sNzsSJqKzwNVZNyXW_WkezQ!2e0!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@37.7808148,-122.4143869,3a,75y,...
- ArchitectAnon 5y agoThe ‘Wedding Cake’ style of architecture requires a lot of ‘fondant icing’ stuck to the outside which is made from expensive and highly labour intensive materials, hand carved stone typically. To take my cake metaphor to far, you can put too much icing on it and it becomes a sugar sculpture full of cardboard props and bits of wire, not something you would enjoy eating. A well designed building in the renaissance style is beautiful but this style also places arbitrary constraints on the design, like symmetry, which make them inefficient and very hard to design convincingly while still meeting the brief for the modern spaces inside. That’s why they’re not built like this anymore. There are a plenty of badly proportioned late 20th Century faux classical buildings out there and to me they stick out like poor typography does to a graphic designer or bad punctuation for an editor. As other comments have pointed out the big problem with buildings in many US cities and European suburbs that developed after ww2 is mostly with urban planning failing to create walkable cities. Spain and Holland have had different approaches but I think they are the most successful in Europe.
- Tabular-Iceberg 5y ago>The problem with this order is that it directly attacks one of the characteristics that has always been associated with art – Progressivism That's complete and utter nonsense. What art always has been associated with is passing fads and fashions, usually inspired by previous fads and fashions. If anything Trump is the real avant-gardist here, now that the modernists have held their hegemony over the art establishment for quite some time. I for one feel like we are ready for a more novel architectural movement, both neoclassicism and concrete UFOs seem a bit old and trite to me.
- balsam 5y agoNot an architect, but cursory research on the webs seems to indicate that TFA meant to use the less political and more “art-philosophical” term “Progressive Modernism”. For example, the design brief for the Seattle Tacoma airport mentions on page 4 (section 1.2.3) “The primary aspect of the Design Vision is the commitment to “Progressive Modernism” as the fundamental design approach. This approach is based on the following timeless principles:...” https://www.portseattle.org/sites/default/files/2018-03/Design-Guidelines-2001.pdf https://www.portseattle.org/sites/default/files/2018-03/Desi... “Progressivism”, on the other hand, seems to be a wholly political movement.
- rendall 5y agoIt is an interesting idea, but incomplete. I'd like a definition of Progressivism, and for the essay to explore the idea that modern art promotes this Progressivism. Only then could I really evaluate the assertion that Trump's executive order was an attack on it. As it stands, any argument here whether it is or is not an attack on Progressivism stands on shifting ground. Some extras/links: the full text of the executive order; pictures of the specific buildings the EO refers to; the full text of the NCAS arguments. These would help me to get a full context of what's at stake, if anything. To my mind, modern art is largely apolitical, with some very specific exceptions (e.g Diego Rivera, Frida Kahlo, Dadaism et. al.) In fact, Futurism was self- consciously Fascist; whatever the definition of Progressivism would turn out to be, I'm certain it would not include Fascism. It seems to me, the writer is doing that which he declared to be irrational and deceptive: believing himself to know what modern artists (or supporters of the EO, for that matter) "had in mind".
- cratermoon 5y agoProgressivism, in this context, can be defined as "the idea of progress in which advancements in science, technology, economic development and social organization are vital to the improvement of the human condition"[1]. In particular is reflects the sort of 1939 World's Fair enthrallment with technology and the post-WWII "we can science our way out of all our problems" attitudes. The "World of Tomorrow" of the late 30s Progressivism definitely informed Fascism. See e.g https://brill.com/view/journals/fasc/8/2/article-p179_179.xml?language=en https://brill.com/view/journals/fasc/8/2/article-p179_179.xm... 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressivism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressivism
- rendall 5y agoI do appreciate the definition. Still, even there, "The meaning of progressivism has varied over time and differs depending on perspective". I don't know what the author Ben Soto meant when he wrote Progressivism. Enlightenment faith in the civilizing influence of technology? Bernie Sanders-style progressive taxation and social justice? Something else? It's a guess as to what he actually meant.
- vincebowdren 5y ago> The order is not targeted toward actually changing the design of federal buildings. Rather, it is being used to attack modern art and suppress the ideals that it stands for. Strongly disagree: it's both. The makers of the order, and its supporters, really do care about architectural styles and they really do think modern buildings are ugly. The essay-writer is assuming that their political opponents are acting in bad faith, but that kind of suspicious conspiratorial thinking does little to help understanding here.
- sebastianconcpt 5y agoGood point, except Progressivism was what weaponized architecture deceitfully attacking what's beautifully human and inspiring.
- theonlybutlet 5y agoThink the whole argument on both sides is a bit extreme, traditional planning permission should consider whether a building proposal/modification is in keeping with the character of an area, this being just one aspect means its application is dynamic and can change with the times and needs for the area.
- bobthechef 5y ago"The problem with this order is that it directly attacks one of the characteristics that has always been associated with art – Progressivism." Whatever the rationales of the order, this, I think, is a preposterous remark. Big "P" Progressivism is divine providence for atheists. All manner of hideous things have been justified under the woolly mantle of "Progress". That Progressivism has invaded art and turned it into a fad-driven enterprise full of inscrutable fluff and pretense does not mean that is what art is or what it has always been. That art can change, improve, discover new beauty, etc. does not mean that it must, and even here this is not the same as Big "P" Progressivism because the Progressive, despite the misleading appellation, worships change. Change, for him, is this mystical Progress. Just look at his political slogans, but don't ask him for the measure of the Progress. That is his undivine mystery. That is the his Faith. To inquire is to blaspheme. At least Christianity holds mystery to be thoroughly intelligible, if exceeding human capacity to exhaustively know. The author then writes: "The supporters of this order only wish to retain the classical architecture that is found around the capital because for them it represents a distant past that is always superior to the present and cannot be interrogated." As noted, if there is anything that resists interrogation, it is Progressivism. Note how the author, out of malice or out of foolishness, reduces support for the order to some nostalgia for a mythical past that never was. People like that surely exist, but this is not only uncharitable, it is an unjust dismissal of all those who have better reasons for preferring such architecture. Some modern architecture has its merits, it has its interesting contributions, but there is also a great deal, a great deal of anti-humanism and downright nihilist, to despise in it. The Progressive star architect is more interested in building monuments to his proverbial cock than he is in serving the people who will need to use that building and look at it for years to come. "it is counterintuitive to assume that a progressive group of individuals would prefer to embrace outdated designs as opposed to new and progressive forms of modern architecture." That word, "outdated", is one of the most pernicious words in the English language. It conflates the passage of time with improvement. You can only speak of something being better relative to an end, and the end itself must either be the nature of a thing, or in service of the thing (technology, for example, is in a sense an extension of man; you cannot make sense of technology except in terms of human nature). So you tell me what is so "outdated" about the Stoa of Athens and yet so great about the Strata Center? Believe me, in two hundred years, people will still admire the timeless beauty of the Stoa and will look at the Strata with laughter, amusement, and disgust, if they even remember it at all. Maybe that's the lesson: we ought to reach for the timeless within our own time and place.