5 ms·
Carbon from forest fires is part of the short-term carbon cycle because it came out of the atmosphere quite recently. It is fundamentally different from carbon
by jeffbee 5y ago
Carbon from forest fires is part of the short-term carbon cycle because it came out of the atmosphere quite recently. It is fundamentally different from carbon found underground that was deposited before humans existed.
- DisjointedHunt 5y ago[Edit]: You’re a coward if you downvote to suppress an opinion without having the decency to engage in debate. Jesus. . You actually think carbon released from burning wood is exempt from the whole “making the planet unlivable” effect? Repeat that to yourself while you watch the skies turn red. That’s a ridiculous statement to make.
- heavyset_go 5y agoForest fires are part of forests' natural life cycles and are, in general, carbon neutral. Forests fixate atmospheric carbon and release it through cellular respiration, decomposition and fires. That atmospheric carbon is then fixated again via vegetative growth. The issue is burning hydrocarbons we pump out of the ground, because doing so interrupts the equilibrium between atmospheric carbon and natural carbon sinks like forests in the carbon cycle.
- bleh123 5y agoCan you cite a single reputable source that backs your claim that, specifically, the forest fires in California that released enough smoke and carbon that they reddened skies as far north as Seattle are part of the "Natural cycle" and are "Carbon Neutral"?
- TigeriusKirk 5y agoWhere did you come across this idea?
- heavyset_go 5y agoMultiple classes and professors I've had in college, and textbooks I've read. This is basic environmental science. Here's a short slideshow about the carbon cycle from a meteorology course[1], under short-term carbon cycle you'll see wildfires, decomposition, cellular respiration etc. Here's research from NASA[2]. Here's a paper that cites numerous references to these facts[3]. Here's what the state of CA says[4]: > Fire is an important part of the carbon cycle. Fire consumes organic matter, releasing greenhouse gases including CO2, methane, carbon monoxide, and other materials. Trees and plants not immediately consumed in the fire may be killed and decompose rapidly, releasing CO2. > Although fire produces carbon emissions, it is also a natural and necessary part of the ecosystem, especially in California where plants are adapted to fire. Rather than eliminate fire, the goal is to maintain historical fire regimes and thus avoid catastrophic fires that occur when fuels build up to unnatural levels. [1] https://www.sjsu.edu/people/frank.freedman/courses/metr113/s1/Met113_Spring11_Lect3.pdf https://www.sjsu.edu/people/frank.freedman/courses/metr113/s... [2] https://icp.giss.nasa.gov/research/ppa/2001/tpenafort/ https://icp.giss.nasa.gov/research/ppa/2001/tpenafort/ [3] https://www.fs.fed.us/rm/pubs_other/rmrs_2014_loehman_r001.pdf https://www.fs.fed.us/rm/pubs_other/rmrs_2014_loehman_r001.p... [4] https://www.fire.ca.gov/programs/resource-management/resource-protection-improvement/wildfire-resilience/forest-stewardship/carbon-sequestration-and-a-changing-climate/ https://www.fire.ca.gov/programs/resource-management/resourc...
- speedybird 5y agoIf you think wildfire smoke makes a region unlivable, then consider that before deciding where to live. Wildfires are a natural part of the ecological cycle in some parts of the world. You can fault California for botching their forest management by suppressing fires and consequently causing larger fires later on, but either way you will have to cope with the smoke. (Also, the sky turning red is actually somewhat pretty. The real harm is what it does to your lungs. Better air filtration indoors is the answer to this, and happily, also a good way to mitigate the risk of respiratory diseases..)
- bleh123 5y agoSo . . what is the statement you're making? That those forest fires that could have been avoided are "natural" and that i shouldn't care about the negligent pollution of air or the planet since i should just "move away" ? I'm having a hard time squaring any of this with the outrage you've displayed in your other comments about a well being drilled.
- plorg 5y agoSure, but when the smoke is bad enough to create bad air quality over half a continent away I think it's more than a "you chose to live in the wrong place" problem.
- speedybird 5y ago> bad air quality over half a continent away If you mean that Californian fires are smoking out states like Nebraska, that's something I haven't heard of. But if you mean smoking out Seattle, the example used above by DisjointedHunt, that's not right. All of the west coast burns; from California all the way to Alaska. The smoke in Seattle mostly comes from fires in Washington and British Columbia. And it really is a "you live in the wrong place" problem because there isn't a solution to that other than humans completely re-engineering the ecology of the west coast, which simply is not going to happen for a myriad of reasons. So either you learn to cope with it (as I and many others have) or you move further East. The fires won't stop.
- hutzlibu 5y ago"[Edit]: You’re a coward if you downvote to suppress an opinion without having the decency to engage in debate." The other explanation would be, that your arguments and discussion style are not the best and not worth engaging with.
- DisjointedHunt 5y agoEnjoy the internet points counter go to zero then while you and the hive mind declare that one kind of fire produces different carbon than the other based on the political affiliation of the cause. Maybe that's the uncomfortable debate? Idk, what do i know man? I'm just a guy with questions for idiotic sounding arguments without a citation.
- agar 5y ago> the hive mind declare that one kind of fire produces different carbon than the other...Maybe that's the uncomfortable debate? Just a random reader here, but no one is saying this. Either you're willfully ignoring the point, or you missed it. It has nothing to do with "a different kind of carbon" or "the political affiliation of the cause." Here is another explanation. I hope you find it not idiotic, and you'll find a citation for everything I say (including quotes from the source to back up my specific comments): Hydrocarbons in the form of fossil fuels have been stored for millions of years. They reflect carbons that have not been extant in the atmosphere for so long that they have been irrelevant to the climate. These fuels also developed over geological time, so the creation of /new/ fossil fuel (i.e., carbon) stores is also irrelevant to our climate in human-scale years. On the contrary, carbons in the form of trees, bushes, and grasses have been pulled from the atmosphere within the past years or decades (plant mass comes from atmospheric carbon, not the ground) as the plants and trees grew. When grasses and trees burn, yes - that carbon gets released into the atmosphere. But it then gets photosynthesized back into grasses and trees over the next years and decades, recapturing that carbon in a time period that is relevant to human lifespans. However when fossil fuels burn, they release net-new (from an atmospheric perspective) carbon with no recapture mechanism available for perhaps millions of years. Of course there are exceptions. Old growth forests have an outsized impact on atmospheric carbon vs. grasslands. Additionally, the climate change-driven increase in forest fire frequency, combined with our already-high carbon levels, mean the short-term increase in carbon may have an outsized influence on drought and other negative climate changes before it can be recaptured. So yes, recent environmental research is looking far more carefully at forest fires' impact on carbon load and climate impact. But no, this has nothing to do with "trimming" or "raking" our forests. Nor does it have to do with the "politics" of fossil fuel vs. forestry, nor is it "different carbon." I hope this helps answer your questions. Reference: https://www.futuredirections.org.au/publication/wildfires-greenhouse-gas-emissions-and-climate-change/ https://www.futuredirections.org.au/publication/wildfires-gr... > In Australia wildfires may well be GHG emission neutral over time. A recent report released by the Australian Government Department of Industry, Science, Energy and Resources concluded that based on existing evidence, “… bushfires release significant amounts of carbon dioxide, but generally recover over time, generating a significant carbon sink in the years following the fire.” > For millennia fire has been a feature of the natural environment. An equilibrium existed whereby the quantity of CO2 released into the atmosphere by burning and the quantity stored in plant material by photosynthesis remained neutral. > This view, while appropriately conservative in the context of the Kyoto protocols in 1997, now still understates the importance of wildfire related GHG emission in two ways. Firstly, CO2 released into the atmosphere by wildfires can remain there for a period of approximately seven months before it is re-captured by photosynthesis. During this time it will contribute to the warming of the planet. Secondly, and most importantly, there is compelling evidence from a number of sources that the incidence and intensity of wildfires is increasing.