4 ms·
I wonder what the politics of it is: Who benefits in politics and in business? Also, afaik renewable energy is advancing quickly. Nuclear made more sense a dec
by wolverine876 5y ago
I wonder what the politics of it is: Who benefits in politics and in business?
Also, afaik renewable energy is advancing quickly. Nuclear made more sense a decade ago. Why switch to it now?
- goda90 5y agoNuclear still makes sense now. We can't just aim to have our current electricity needs be filled by renewables, we need to plan for even more electricity for vehicles and industrial processes that currently depend on fossil fuels. Not to mention the large amount of residential furnace and water heaters that also depend on fossil fuels. And if we're ever going to start really sequestering carbon, having excess energy from nuclear is going to help a ton.
- throwawayboise 5y agoCarbon sequestration makes more sense for intermittently-available renewables since it can happen when the sun is shining or the wind is blowing and doesn't need massive battery storage otherwise. Nuclear makes much more sense for base load electric needs for homes and industry.
- fmajid 5y agoCarbon sequestration is inefficient if you are doing it on diffuse CO2 in the air, as opposed to a concentrated stream from an industrial process like a cement factory. Battery electric storage, or redox flow batteries, or even hydrogen are more likely to work in remote locations.
- wolverine876 5y agoBoris Johnson isn't doing it because it makes sense, but for political benefits. Who benefits? Who is making money? 10 years ago I thought nuclear was the clear answer - that we should do a moon-shot style massive project to develop a new generation of reactors and build them worldwide. I'm not against nuclear. But there's an important political dimension also, and to talk as if it's decided on technological merits is to implicitly spread the BS.
- tomp 5y agoBecause it works, today. Sure, it's hard to build and expensive, but that's much better than being nonexistent as grid-scale "green" technology is today.
- epistasis 5y agoI think you've got that reversed. Grid scale wind solar and storage are dominating all new equipment on the grid. Check out the interconnection queue for ERCOT or PJM, the few competitive markets where there's public information like that, and where the choices are made purely based on profit, rather than the preferred whims of crafty utility executives that get guaranteed profits and don't have to pay for bad capital allocations. In contrast, new nuclear is nearly impossible to build. Nobody even wants to attempt to build it unless they get massive blank checks from governments to backstop all the massive cost overruns. Even China, the one country that has the capability to build big things still, is only building a tiny tiny fraction of nuclear in comparison to their massive renewables builds. Building new nuclear in the UK means either going with designs that have proven to be very difficult to construct, like the EPR, or going with completely unproven SMR designs, that are the last ditch effort to save nuclear as an energy source.