5 ms·
"The responsible life before God" -- I don't think any modern person is capable of understanding what that meant in the 1940s. We just don't think that way anym
by AlbertCory 5y ago
"The responsible life before God" -- I don't think any modern person is capable of understanding what that meant in the 1940s. We just don't think that way anymore.
However, none of the comments so far have really grasped his point, which is that stupidity is a group phenomenon. Maybe a modern equivalent would be "tribe." Of course you can't convince someone of the other tribe to come over and join yours on any one particular issue; that would be betrayal of everything they think they stand for.
So logic is pointless. That representative of the other tribe cannot think and form his or her own opinion because that would mean expulsion from their tribe.
- oblak 5y agoFirst thing I thought when reading your comment was Men in Black Kay : A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals and you know it. Fifteen hundred years ago everybody knew the Earth was the center of the universe. Five hundred years ago, everybody knew the Earth was flat, and fifteen minutes ago, you knew that humans were alone on this planet. Imagine what you'll know tomorrow.
- belter 5y ago"Most of them are just trying to make a living..." https://youtu.be/w2ppyMUlXfM https://youtu.be/w2ppyMUlXfM
- teddyh 5y agoWhat you write is perfectly true, but both tribes read that and think “Yes, that’s how it is for people in the other tribe. We in this tribe, of course, are much better than that.”.
- AlbertCory 5y agoVery true. And of course, no member can admit that their tribe is that way, too, without risking expulsion.
- BobbyJo 5y agoIs there a pattern of thought that makes one immune to this? Like, if I reject every tribe, I become part of the 'everyone is dumb tribe', if I accept the views of every authority, I become part of the 'sheep' tribe, but maybe if one were to employ some pattern of acceptance and contrarianism in the face of other's arguments, then, on average, one's own tribalism would dissolve.
- achenet 5y agoBeing a member of multiple tribes and through that seeing that each has its own goals, beliefs, and communication protocols.
- NalNezumi 5y agoThe partial solution to this is what _used_ to be called "open-mindedness". But it's not a pattern for "immunity" but in analogue, practices to keep you "fit" and prepared. I think CGP grey summarized the pattern nicely, and I quote: (timestamped)[0] "The trick is to keep your identity separate from your opinions - they are objects in a box you carry with you and should be easily replaceable if it turns out they're no good. If you think that the opinions in the box are who you are then you'll cling to them despite any evidence to the contrary. Bottom line: If you want to always be right, you need to always be prepared to change your mind" [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tlsU_YT9n_g&t=72s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tlsU_YT9n_g&t=72s I would also add my personal take that you should also presuppose that the person you're talking/listening to will have that attitude. Most people don't, but by merely starting from that point, conversation can have a positive turn when you get a glimpse of why they decided to put that opinion in to their mind-box.
- julian37 5y agoBrecht had a whimsical take on this. There's a German saying that goes "wer A sagt, muss auch B sagen": he who says A, has to say B, meaning of course you should always try and follow through. Brecht wrote "Wer a sagt, der muß nicht b sagen. Er kann auch erkennen, daß a falsch war": he who says A, doesn't have to say B. He can also realize that A was wrong. https://beruhmte-zitate.de/zitate/126572-bertolt-brecht-wer-a-sagt-der-muss-nicht-b-sagen-er-kann-auch-er/ https://beruhmte-zitate.de/zitate/126572-bertolt-brecht-wer-...
- breakyerself 5y ago"We note further that people who have isolated themselves from others or who live in solitude manifest this defect less frequently than individuals or groups of people inclined or condemned to sociability"
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoThis is compounded by neither tribe admitting the other tribe's good ideas. We focus on all or nothing rejection of the opposing team.
- CoastalCoder 5y agoDo you have a source for what Bonhoeffer would have meant by that? I have my own guess to its meaning, but I hesitate to say it does/doesn't match his definition without seeing some exposition on it.
- AlbertCory 5y agoGiven this layout, I can't tell whom you're addressing this to: the guy who said "folly" was the better translation? In any case, I did study German in college, but I'm far from being able to judge what word is accurate. If the word was "Dummheit" that translates literally as "dumb head" but that doesn't mean a German would understand it that way.
- AlbertCory 5y agoFunny how your mind works. I just realized Dummheit doesn't mean "dumb head" like I said; it's "state of being dumb" or, as Google Translate puts it, "stupidity."
- pugio 5y ago> "The responsible life before God" -- I don't think any modern person is capable of understanding what that meant in the 1940s. We just don't think that way anymore. I would suggest that perhaps you are limiting your scope of possible "we" (21st century human) thought states. The passage seems to me perfectly clear. For reference, the full quote is: > "The word of the Bible that the fear of God is the beginning of wisdom declares that the internal liberation of human beings to live the responsible life before God is the only genuine way to overcome stupidity." He's discussing one way out of the trap of conforming to group/tribal beliefs. If you put your fear of God (in other words, some power higher than, and distinctly external to, any social group) you begin to liberate yourself from caring too much about what other people think. If you believe that God demands that you act as morally (for some definition/code) and as responsibly as possible, and you place that demand/requirement higher than any other motivating feeling, you will ask about any belief or course of action "Is this Right?" (ie. Does this align with God's command), and consider that question more deeply than the creeds or slogans of your fellow mortals. Note that he's not saying that the above state of mind is easy, it's merely something just strive for. Many devout religious people still try to the best of their ability to work towards that exact state.
- Mitzz 5y agoWell said. Personally I imperfectly strive to think this way, and I imagine at least hundreds of millions of others do as well.
- AlbertCory 5y agoWell said. Of course, he was a minister, so he'd spent his life thinking about that.
- bmj 5y agoAnd as a theologian whose work included a book on Christian ethics, and The Cost of Discipleship.
- AlbertCory 5y ago
- analog31 5y agoI think aside from interpreting that prescription, he didn't live long enough to see what actually happened, which is that the power associated with the stupidity was overcome by sheer and overwhelming force.
- richardatlarge 5y agoYes I was taken by his idea that the idiot has an armour made of a potentially massive social network. It gives you perspective of what you’re really dealing with and the difficulty of the job ahead
- xyzzy21 5y agoIt depends on where you were raised. Maybe not in Blue Urban cities but it's trivial in the rest of the USA (where FEW Blue Urban denizen has likely ever traveled).