4 ms·
I think you highly overestimate the amount of research the average person does on a printer purchase. Yes, some people will buy a CR magazine or ask their frie
by kube-system 5y ago
I think you highly overestimate the amount of research the average person does on a printer purchase. Yes, some people will buy a CR magazine or ask their friends/relatives opinion for a $30k car, but will they do that before buying a $60 printer?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoTrue, but I would have figured that by now, so many people would have had bad experiences with inkjet printers from HP/epson/canon that they would have sought out that information. Or maybe even retailers would promote it so people are more satisfied with their purchases.
- ethbr0 5y agoHere is the average printer purchaser: "Hello Best Buy / Staples / Office Depot salesperson, I need a printer." "Well, I'd recommend (insert whichever manufacturer currently cutting retail most margin)." "No, a friend had a bad experience with them." "Oh, then (insert second highest margin)." (Repeat)
- kube-system 5y agoMeanwhile the most economical printers aren’t even on the shelf because their high purchase price causes them to have low sales volumes.
- lazide 5y agoYup, though those tend to be purchased by large corps in bulk via industrial channels, so the companies still make good money. Most large corps have done the math and know their TCO all in is much lower (since they have the scale that they need to hire staff and explicitly account for dealing with issues like printer problems). The printer companies have also done their market research and math, and know how much they can squeeze out of these corps while still having the math clearly make sense for them. Can you imagine the logistical and end user support nightmare if they gave everyone their own cheap inkjets? Lolz. It’s bad enough as it is, and per-page the problems are way less frequent.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dylan604 5y agoSomeone needs to make a QAnon post about the scam, then it'd be over for ink jets /s
- kube-system 5y agoMeh. Knowing about “the scam” is not enough to avoid it. People already know ink cartridges are expensive. To get a good deal you have to calculate TCO which requires understanding consumable prices, yields, and print volumes, and doing the math to figure out all of your options. Being mad is easy. Being analytical requires work.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoI don't think it's that complicated in that case as you just need to know how many pages you are going to print. If the amount is greater than the one provided for in your inkjet starter pack, go buy Brother. Any other option will make you suffer as these cheap laser printers are disposable pieces of junk designed only to sell ink.
- kube-system 5y ago> need to know how many pages you are going to print. If the amount is greater than the one provided for in your inkjet starter pack aka print volumes and cartridge yields, as I said. In any case, if you're not calculating TCO, then you're not calculating TCO. Brand loyalty is just brand loyalty, even when tech savvy people do it. There are economical and uneconomical printers from nearly any brand depending on use-case.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoIt's not a bad idea. Prepare a few memes about this and post it to anti-vaxx and conspiracy groups - they will take care of the rest. And they will do it well - making sure the message gets right through to your parents and grandparents.
- ecpottinger 5y agoYou are right. I remember in particular when the company I was with sold the Panasonic home printer. For a student is was great, but ALL the parts were made of the type of plastic that could not take heat in the long run. The user manual clearly said no more than 100 pages at a time and less than a 1000 a day, no problem for a student. Yet time after time someone would come in and want one for office work. We would point them to the better printers that have hard metal parts in all the key areas and would print all day nonstop if needed. Yet time after time they insisted on the cheap home Panasonic printer. Then a few months later they would show up screaming and yelling that we sold them a piece of junk. Shame that the printer kept track of how many pages it printed. And the manual clearly stated the limits. We never saw the court cases they threaten us with. :)
- kube-system 5y agoYep. Duty cycle, as an engineering concept, is notoriously misunderstood by the general public. It seems every day that there's some sort of outrage in a blog or article: "Did you know that [large organization] spends $[x] for their [equipment]? Wow, you can buy [consumer version] at Walmart for 1/100th of that price!" No, outraged taxpayer, your school district isn't wasting money by purchasing a $10,000 copier. Your HP all-in-one can't replace their use-case, despite how you imagine it could.
- RealityVoid 5y agoI am still skeptic, honestly, are some metal gears worth the 20x-10x cost increase? Yes, you can make it more suited for long term use for _some_ cost, but that much? At what point is is actually fleecing customers? Some products surely are just fleecing, but how can you tell? Usually, you can't.
- lazide 5y agoIt isn’t that the metal gears alone are worth 10-20x. It is that if you do the math over a long period of time, use it somewhat often, and include things like your time (at any reasonable labor rate) fixing issues, tracking down replacements, etc. it almost always makes sense to have something that will have fewer issues, last longer, and is designed to be more durable even at greater expense. In things with moving parts, that may mean metal gears and reinforcement in wear areas, but not always. This of course depends on how frequently you are going to use it, how hard, for what, and how severe or expensive the consequences of it breaking on you unexpectedly are. ‘Commercial’ or ‘pro grade’ is usually more durable and expensive because the market demands it - employees are often harder on equipment than someone who bought it directly, it gets used at a much higher duty cycle, maintenance is often neglected at least as much as a residential user, etc. and the market is willing to pay more because it breaking stops them from making money, or requires them to spend more money on labor getting it fixed. They also tend to have horrible UX or require specific steps to work, since they know it is being bought for it’s utility not because it is pretty (most of the time), and someone will have to figure out how to use it or get figured after the company is already paid. They still do get scammed sometimes of course. The printer equivalent of harbor freight tools has a place if you’re going to toss it in a year anyway due to a move, or need it for a single job and then never again, as long as it isn’t a safety/critical path item anyway.
- jerkstate 5y agoMy Consumer Reports (online) subscription is probably the best $10 per year I spend
- coffeecat 5y agoReviews and anecdotes can be misleading in some cases. I bought a cheap secondhand Xerox Phaser printer, which has some horrible reviews online, and its previous owner was getting rid of it because of network connection issues. The network connectivity issue was fixed with a firmware update, and I've found it to be an excellent printer - useful documentation, supports every printing protocol under the sun, and the cost of aftermarket drum/toner replacements work out to less than half a cent per page.
- kube-system 5y agoIf the average consumer can't be bothered to read a review before making a purchase, they're certainly not reading about firmware updates, or buying a secondhand Phaser. Regular people go to a big box store, look at the items on the shelf, read the marketing material on the box, and fork out $79.99.