3 ms·
I'd be interested to know if this was intentional. I can very much see that the all-in-one device has some "initializeHardware()" function that tests and sets
by londons_explore 5y ago
I'd be interested to know if this was intentional.
I can very much see that the all-in-one device has some "initializeHardware()" function that tests and sets up all the internal components, which probably requires ink to run (firing an ink jet as part of the initialization with no ink present usually burns some ink and it'll permanently clog with carbon deposits).
Likewise, I suspect if the light bulb in the scanner was faulty, it wouldn't print. Or if the chip controlling the fax functions was unresponsive, it may not scan, copy or print.
Designing a device which can self test every component, and then have a matrix of exactly which components must be present and working to do each function is very possible... but it's extra engineering effort, extra testing, and an extra source of bugs.
For example, if an ink cartridge is missing, the weight of the carriage will be different, which will need different motor control parameters to ensure the movement speed is suitable (they're DC motors, so require quite complex control algorithms to move at a close-to-constant rate across the page).
Overall, it might not be Canon management requiring this behaviour, but rather the engineering teams deciding that all these corner cases are not worth the effort of supporting.
- wly_cdgr 5y agoThe reasons don't matter as it's absolutely unacceptable user experience that breaks a major implicit product promise. I get that engineers may be too people-stupid to understand that it's a non-negotiable blocker, but that's why you employ UX designers
- mthoms 5y agoPrinter companies have long lost their right to getting the benefit of the doubt. At any rate, if your theory is correct then they are knowingly selling a defective product. Using the scanner is not a “corner case”, it’s one of the devices’ primary functions.
- misnome 5y agoYes, clearly this is just a bug that will be fixed as soon as they are made aware of it in 2016
- LordAtlas 5y agoFrom the article: "Since at least 2016, other customers have contacted Canon about this exact problem [1, 2] and were told by support agents that ink cartridges must be installed and contain ink to use the printer's features, as shown by the agent's response below." I'm inclined towards malice and not incompetence.