4 ms·
> Modern software’s humdrum lack of identity has resulted in users craving more interesting, opinionated tools, tools that feel like us — or a better, more inte
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
> Modern software’s humdrum lack of identity has resulted in users craving more interesting, opinionated tools, tools that feel like us — or a better, more interesting, wackier version of us.
The above is the kind of sentence that you'll see in almost any fashion or arts magazine.
Pretty fluffy stuff. Not really the kind of thing we're used to, in the engineering community.
That said, I firmly believe that there's always a place for good graphic and interaction design, in technology.
I don't feel that it's a problem. Some companies will stick to "the classics," while some will go overboard with the "chrome"[0], so to speak.
[0] https://www.mprove.de/script/99/kai/2Software.html https://www.mprove.de/script/99/kai/2Software.html
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andybak 5y agoSo I read the first sentence and my immediate reaction was "Well I don't. And I'm not sure anyone has ever expressed that opinion to me" and I stopped reading.
- agumonkey 5y agoThere's a bit of truth. The era of extremely engineered everything gave birth to flat design for instance. I'm not pro skeumorphism but I remember how odd software felt good in a way. As long as it was fun (good boards, useful programs) you ended up liking the quirks.
- andybak 5y agoI don’t disagree but I didn’t get any of that from that opening statement. It seems to be arguing for diversity in UI which I happen to think is usually a terrible idea.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago> It seems to be arguing for diversity in UI which I happen to think is usually a terrible idea. I have to agree with this sentiment. I loved KPT, but that was more for the "adventure" aspect. I actually had difficulty using a lot of functions (don't ask me to remember which ones). It's frustrating, designing innovative UI that also follows convention. It's a joy, when it works. I have this iOS widget that I wrote[0]. It's really, really cool. Works a charm, and is easy to implement. But I keep on not using it in my projects. It's too "in your face." I think that UI needs to get the hell out of the way, and just let the user do what they want to do. I have a couple of more, more conventional widgets, that I use all the time[1], [2]. KPT was "in your face," like no other UI I have ever experienced. [0] https://riftvalleysoftware.com/work/open-source-projects/#RVS_Spinner https://riftvalleysoftware.com/work/open-source-projects/#RV... [1] https://riftvalleysoftware.com/work/open-source-projects/#RVS_AutofillTextField https://riftvalleysoftware.com/work/open-source-projects/#RV... [2] https://riftvalleysoftware.com/work/open-source-projects/#RVS_Checkbox https://riftvalleysoftware.com/work/open-source-projects/#RV...
- coldtea 5y agoWell, here's that opinion: today's flat UIs all look the same, boring, and bland. I wish there was more quirkiness too. Perhaps not to Kai Power tool's levels, but I enjoy the functional quirkiness of many VST UIs. Now you can continue reading. Seldom anybody learned much, when they stopped reading at the point they disagreed with.
- andybak 5y agoI want my UI’s to be usable. I want it to be immediately obvious what I need to do. I want them to become invisible in the same way good tools do. I don’t want my hammer to be quirky, I want it to be an extension of my hand. EDIT - Yeah. I have a certain fondness for Kai’s. But I had time to get used to them. It’s one UI in a thousand where I have time to get bedded in with it’s quirks. For all the rest - be boring.
- Randosaurus 5y agoThe flat UI's you're complaining about are an example of the form over function philosophy.
- coldtea 5y agoThe opposite could be argued as well: it's design supposed to focus on function alone (after all that was their pitch: put the content front and center, remove aesthetic touches from the "skeuomorphic" UIs, etc.) but with no redeeming aesthetic qualities (which are also important for actual human users). So, it's not exactly form over function (besides thought into form is necessary for function - you can have a real world lever that is e.g. thin and crooked and it will still function as a lever, but a good lever also has good form -- e.g. be designed to have a good grip). It's "design ideology and novelty for some manager's sake" over form and function.
- prox 5y agoI am going to make a claim as someone who works in both the crossroad of devwork and design that there is not one piece of software that caters truly for the artist. Every piece of software for artists / designers is not intuitive. It’s sliders, knobs, modals and panels. Programmers making design software is Not A Good Idea. The way forward is something like ProCreate, so just the software and the pen, and maybe more auxiliary devices (a color palet for instance) to become more analog again.
- pjc50 5y agoIt's been a long time since the unique and slightly bizarre Kai's Power Tools: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kai%27s_Power_Tools https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kai%27s_Power_Tools
- prox 5y agoYeah, and in many ways, we haven’t seen many more trials like that.
- jimmaswell 5y agoWhat do you want, an AI that reads your mind and generates the exact art you want? Barring that, a perfectly intuitive tool is impossible past a certain point of complexity. If you want something in front of something else you're going to have to learn what a layer is. If you want something at just the right transparency you're going to have to adjust the transparency. Maybe some kind of virtual art studio in VR would be helpful for people who want a more physically intuitive experience with some extras like undo and saving copies, but even then you're still going to have to learn a thing or two about the tool to use it, like any tool.
- ksec 5y ago>The way forward is something like ProCreate You mean [1] ? I dont disagree with your point but I dont understand how pro create is any different to any other design software on iPad. [1] https://procreate.art https://procreate.art
- 5y ago
- Akronymus 5y ago> That said, I firmly believe that there's always a place for good graphic and interaction design, in technology. Form should come after function. But often times form actually contributes to function. (In the sense of making the "right" thing intuitive to do) Function is IMO always paramount.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI've found the process to be iterative. Chicken->egg-chicken->egg... etc.