6 ms·
>The Byzantines called themselves “Romans” (Rhomaioi — in Greek) right until their conquest by the Turks in 1453. Cato’s corrupt Greeks had become the saviors o
by coldtea 5y ago
>The Byzantines called themselves “Romans” (Rhomaioi — in Greek) right until their conquest by the Turks in 1453. Cato’s corrupt Greeks had become the saviors of the Roman Empire.
Kind of. What carried on was not the Roman Empire in toto, but the Eastern Empire. Which was placed on the ancient Greek mainland (wider than current Greece, e.g. including southern Italy and Asia minor) and the hellenistic (Greek-speaking, as a result of Alexander's conquests) areas, like Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, and so on.
They called themselves Romaioi (Romans) because (aside from the peaceful state-capital transition to the east instigated by a legitimate Roman emperor himself) the first emperors and many early higher-ups were latin-speaking romans, and because, even those who weren't wanted the state influence associated with being successors to Roman empire.
As for the population, they weren't romans in the large, either by ethnicity (italic), language, or culture (hence "Cato’s corrupt Greeks"). They were "roman citizens" but this wasn't much different from "roman subjects + civic rights". Heck, the barbarians that followed Rome (Franks, Germanic tribes, etc) also called themselves "Holy Roman Empire", while having little to do with Romans, and even Mehmed the Conqueror when the ottomans conquered the eastern empire called himself "emperor of the Romans".
And while the Eastern Roman empire went on for over a millenium (with ups and downs, attacked by Persians, Arabs, and so on), Rome and the actual Roman empire did fell, and there was a very real and measurable loss of population, state function, quality of life, culture, infrastructure, and so on that lasted for many centuries.
So to say "Roman empire didn't decline, it moved east" is not really accurate.
- pasabagi 5y agoThere was no such thing as a roman ethnicity or language (perhaps latin for law? The byzantines kept latin for a very long time in this context). Rome itself was a backwater long before the western empire fell. The difference between Byzantium and, say, the holy roman empire, was that at no point did a barbarian king declare himself the inheritor of roman tradition. The byzantine state was always the roman state, and it was the state that had continued (fitfully) since Caesar (or Romulus I guess).
- emteycz 5y agoHoly Roman Empire is exactly what you're saying didn't happen - non-Romans declaring themselves the direct continuation of Roman Empire tradition.
- shakow 5y agoIt's always possible to argue further, but it's not really what led to the foundation of the HRE. Rather, it was a creation of the pope Leo III which he offered to Charlemagne, as the conclusion of a long feud with the ERE and the wish of the pope to split from it.
- zeteo 5y agoIsn't it a bit presumptuous to declare that people who called themselves and were called by everyone else "Romans" for over a thousand years were not really Romans? By this definition 4th century emperors like Constantine the Great and Theodosius the Great were not really Romans either, since they spoke Greek and ruled from Constantinople. Heck, even in the time of Caesar the Republican elite preferred speaking Greek instead of Latin - hopefully you don't think the Roman Empire fell before it even began...
- emteycz 5y agoPerhaps it is. This is how they taught me at school - and we were part of HRE too. It's definitely not about languages though. HRE switched from Latin to German like nothing happened. It is also important to note that the people called themselves Roman/HRE in addition to their national/tribal identity, not as a replacement.
- coldtea 5y ago>Isn't it a bit presumptuous to declare that people who called themselves and were called by everyone else "Romans" for over a thousand years were not really Romans? Depends. Are we talking about ethnicity? (in which they weren't italic latin-speaking Romans - Greek ethnicity and culture, for example, didn't just vanish when the italic latin-speaking Romans conquered their lands). Or about "nationality" or statehood and claim to lands, and such? In that, they were romans, since their state was the successor to the roman state (aka the "roman empire"), and a legitimate one at that. Mind you, they also started calling themselves Greeks later on, and we have tons of references from them (including emperors etc) writing about themselves as that. >By this definition 4th century emperors like Constantine the Great and Theodosius the Great were not really Romans either, since they spoke Greek and ruled from Constantinople. They were the Roman emperors during the transfer of power to the Eastern Empire - in the time of Theodosius Rome was still in place too, and East and West where ruled under the Tetrarchy. Plus, Constantine didn't speak Greek, he spoke Latin (he used an interpreter in some cases to translate to Greek, and he knew a handful as many romans did, but he personally spoke latin). I'm pretty sure that's true for Theodosius too. >Heck, even in the time of Caesar the Republican elite preferred speaking Greek instead of Latin - hopefully you don't think the Roman Empire fell before it even began... That's neither here, nor there. One is an example of some elites being pretentious, and the other is a state losing its capital (the one it even took its name from), its ruiling ethnicity, moving to another region with a different cultural background and dominant ethnicities, which eventually in a couple of centruries swallowed the previous dominant language and culture -- all while the original capital and land of origin of the culture and the empire suffered devastating fall under barbarian tribes.
- FranzFerdiNaN 5y agoI have no idea how you can come to the conclusion that the ERE wasn’t the Roman Empire. It is literally a direct continuation straight from Augustus.
- coldtea 5y agoReally? No idea? There's a reason why we call the millenium-long state the Byzantine Empire as distinct from the Roman Empire and not just "Eastern Roman Empire" (even if its inhabitans were ok with just Roman Empire or Romania). The state line of continuation is real and legitimate (there wasn't some invasion that started calling itself "Easter Roman Empire" for example). But it's also real that the split of the empire to eastern and western, and then the trasnfer of the empire's capital to the East, and the fall of the western capital, also meant a transfer from the italic/latin-speaking roman core to the hellenistic/greek-speaking populations, that were not the original "romans" but conquered by them, and who eventually established their norms, culture, and language as core attributes of the new empire (not to mention this new-fangled christianity thing, which was anathema to the old empire and quite different from the pagan world).
- dragonwriter 5y ago> There’s a reason why we call the millenium-long state the Byzantine Empire as distinct from the Roman Empire and not just “Eastern Roman Empire” Mostly, I think, rationalizations of attitudes shaped by anti-Eastern propaganda in the West, both before and especially after the East-West schism in the Church.
- coldtea 5y agoI'd say it's both. There was up to the 20th century an anti-Eastern bias (as the western wannabe successors to the Roman Empire wanted no legitimate competitors and felt the presence of ERE as de-legitimizing them). But also because the transfer from a roman/italic/latin/pagan/Rome-based to a hellenistic/greek/christian/Constantinople-based state was quite a big transition, which only legally and nominally one would accept as the same empire.
- jltsiren 5y agoThe unified Roman empire effectively fell during the Crisis of the Third Century. It was too large to be ruled from a single capital. The capital would always be too far to respond effectively to threats at distant borders, or from disloyal generals ruling over distant provinces. Diocletian eventually managed to stabilize the empire, but it was almost always split into 2-4 parts afterwards. The western capital was moved from Rome to Mediolanum, while Diocletian chose Nicomedia in the east as his capital. Rome was never a capital again, and eastern parts of the empire tended to be more important than western parts, because they were wealthier and more densely populated.
- goto11 5y agoA lot of identity politics hinge on whether the Eastern Roman Empire is considered the evolution of Rome or if the Roman Empire fell with the city of Rome. Of course this is a "Ship of Theseus" situation, so the discussion typically descend into hand-waving and vague and anachronistic notions of ethnicity.
- billfruit 5y agoThe Easterns had taken parts of Italy, and even Rome itself during Belisarius time. So there was a point of time Eastern Roman Empire expanded westwards enough to include Rome itself and beyond.