3 ms·
> In those cases your credit score could be based on just about anything. What you post on social media, whether you recently visited a doctor, or whether or no
by PragmaticPulp 5y ago
> In those cases your credit score could be based on just about anything. What you post on social media, whether you recently visited a doctor, or whether or not you live in a wealthy neighbourhood. Suddenly, your most recent Google search history, or your latest post on TikTok could influence whether you can get that loan.
It's strange to see Facebook and Google being invoked in these hypothetical examples when neither company sells user data. Big advertising companies aren't interested in releasing their proprietary user data to other companies. They sell ads on their own platform, but they don't sell user data.
Meanwhile, financial institutions openly share your personal information with "business partners" unless you opt out. The FTC has done a decent job of forcing disclosure of these data sharing arrangements and giving consumers a standard form to opt-out [1] These companies are actively selling user data as much as they can get away with, but Facebook and Google are getting demonized for something they're not even doing.
As for this blog post: It's a fine example of Betteridge's law of headlines (and yes, I know it's not actually a law).
[1] It looks like this: https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/rules/privacy-consumer-financial-information-financial-privacy-rule/privacymodelform_optout.pdf https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/rules/privacy-con... inside of your mailed statements. You can also find it on the financial institution website if you search long enough.
- Spooky23 5y agoThey don’t need to sell anything. They aggregate and collect data, and sell value added services. Facebook in particular always states they do not sell data. There are plenty of documented examples about how various datasets are used to target people in different ways. Google was contracted to deliver anti-extremist messaging, data from insurance claims, insurance background checking and web behavior has been used for opioid diversion.
- dboreham 5y agoThis isn't totally hypothetical. I ran into a guy at a tech get together a few years ago who was doing exactly this. He told me they could produce much more accurate credit score data from examining some number of a user's FB posts than is achievable by Equifax. When I asked how they got the data he said they got users to give them their account credentials. Obviously violation of FB ToS. I don't know what happened to his startup but clearly what the article describes has been seriously considered by some in the lending business.