6 ms·
The total is only 54% to 46% - not too uneven, I'd be very worried if the imbalance was much worse though as it indicates our education system isn't serving mal
by bluGill 5y ago
The total is only 54% to 46% - not too uneven, I'd be very worried if the imbalance was much worse though as it indicates our education system isn't serving males well for whatever reason (the reason might not be the fault of the education system).
However it is very insightful to notice that females are only 25% in engineering, and 76% in public administration. Those are the worst imbalances, but there are others almost as bad. There is a lot of work to do in getting real balance.
- dTal 5y agoIs the optimal outcome 50/50 representation in every walk of life? Or do certain career preferences naturally skew? How can we tell?
- dagmx 5y agoI don't think 50/50 is a realistic goal. For one, it assumes a very binary split, when demographics are very diverse and combinatorial. What instead should be the case, IMHO, is two fold: - at each milestone level (school, college, hiring, promotions etc...) , we should aim to be within a certain small percentage of the previous milestone. E.g if a class in college starts with 20% Indian women, then it should ideally graduate with ~20% Indian women. The next milestones after that (hiring, promotion) should ideally be reflective of that to some degree. - we should analyze the percentage of people entering fields of education, and see how that represents similar demographic locally, and at the state and federal levels. Using that data we should see why certain demographics are skewed towards and against those fields. Using that we should see if there's any systemic issues keeping them away, and try and balance society accordingly.
- DeathArrow 5y ago>Using that we should see if there's any systemic issues keeping them away, and try and balance society accordingly. What's wrong in letting the society balance itself?
- dagmx 5y agoHow would society balance itself if there's no tools for introspection? Would women have the right to vote if someone didn't say "hey this demographic here is not being represented". Would Black people in America be free? Society needs to self reflect and introspect before it can balance. Numbers are a means to achieving that introspection.
- 3maj 5y ago>if a class in college starts with 20% Indian women, then it should ideally graduate with ~20% Indian women So you want to make college classes easier for certain groups so that they don't drop out? I personally believe that everyone should have an equal opportunity... But an equal outcome inherently involves being unfair and disadvantaging a certain group for the advantage for another.
- dagmx 5y agoThat's not what I said at all, and you're purposefully trying to put words there that aren't. We should be aiming for close to equal results, and trying to understand why we aren't getting those. I never said how one should achieve equal results on both the input and output. I just said that's the more realistic goal. I even say that it's not going to be exact. The point is to analyze, and come up with well formed opinions based on data. If a certain demographic is dropping out at a higher rate, maybe it's worth understanding why? Are they simply not as good? Do they have societal pressures from their homes? Do they face harassment from other majority demographics? Do they have other factors like lack of health support? There's many factors that play into it. We need the data to understand the discrepancy, and then to start understanding why that discrepancy exists.
- 3maj 5y agoExcept it's not a realistic goal. Because most of the things you're talking about tracking are 100% subjective and unquantifiable. To some a hard home life is their parents not letting them drink while to others is their parents kicking them out at 18. To some discrimination is a rude comment while to others its something that's actually discrimination. The list goes on. You have kids that didn't get any financial support from their families because the family couldn't afford it (much like myself) that did perfectly fine in school, while others who came from millionaire parents ended up dropping out. This game of "lets see who has it the worst and then try to help them by making life easier for them" never f*cking work. It's a never ending loop. The most you can do is make the standards for acceptance across the board fair and then provide the tools required for success to every student.
- bluGill 5y agoHard to say. However if we are not close to 50/50 we should ask questions. Any imbalance could be a sign of something deeper being wrong - perhaps there is some discrimination of some sort? If the answer finds a genetic reason that males prefer engineering, then that is okay, so long as the genetic influence's affect are equal to the affect on society. Right now I have no idea. I don't think there is a genetic reason for females to not become engineers, but I haven't studied it so I have to remain neutral on the question.
- seph-reed 5y agoSupposedly multitasking and hyper-focus are two distinct and differently useful skills that can't be done at the same time. Hyper-focus tends to lean towards STEM. Boys tend to lean towards hyper-focus. Whether this is cultural or biological is questionable, but given the natural duties of the common sexes (male/female)... it's definitely not unfeasible that the critic with options (and children) would multi-task, while the performer would be more focused on a single task.
- nwah1 5y agoIf these are a result of real preferences in the context of equal opportunity, then there is no particular reason to seek equal outcomes.
- tablespoon 5y ago> However it is very insightful to notice that females are only 25% in engineering, and 76% in public administration. Those are the worst imbalances, but there are others almost as bad. There is a lot of work to do in getting real balance. Of course, all the work will go to fixing the "females are only 25% in engineering," and whatever effort is spent fixing "females are...76% in public administration" will round down to zero.
- CodeGlitch 5y agoJust a guess here, could it be because people find more success / public exposure in engineering? We can all name famous engineers, not sure I could name a single famous public administrator...
- rjsw 5y ago> We can all name famous engineers, not sure I could name a single famous public administrator... I can think of several female politicians with a doctorate in subjects like public administration.
- cronix 5y agoWait until you see how many women aren't in the plumbing industry. > There are over 276,986 plumbers currently employed in the United States. > 5.1% of all plumbers are women, while only 91.1% are men. Women already have 5x as many engineers as they do plumbers. Maybe we should start concentrating on other sectors critical to modern society. I've never heard anyone complaining about this massive, massive disparity. I can only conclude that we care about women being in some professions, but not others, so it's not really about general parity. It's selectively targeted parity. There are many industries with numbers like this, not just plumbing. https://www.zippia.com/plumber-jobs/demographics/ https://www.zippia.com/plumber-jobs/demographics/
- ModernMech 5y agoI am in CS education, and the efforts to decrease gender disparities in my field, from my perspective, are being driven by academics. People have this perception that maybe this is being forced on us from on high or by outsiders with an agenda, but the reality is my colleagues are very motivated to solve this problem, and they don't need outside motivation or directives to do so. We are targeting academia because that's the industry we know best, we have the power and knowledge to change it, and we believe it will help our community. That we or others are not targeting the plumbing industry doesn't mean no one cares about that issue. Academics are very loud, and major media loves to amplify what we are saying and doing. I don't think plumbers and the plumbing industry enjoy the same status in American society. But it's probably an issue that plumbers and the plumbing industry should champion first rather than outsiders. With 5% female representation, there might not be a critical mass of women in that industry to start a movement for change, it will probably be up to male plumbers to see any effort get off the ground, so I am curious what their general feeling is. My female colleagues are the most motivated to solve this issue, as they are invested personally to see that future generations of women have an easier time in our industry. They host conferences and write papers about the issues most important to women in our field, and they derive solidarity and purpose from this comradery that motivates them. That kind of dynamic probably is harder to recreate in industries with 5% female participation.
- 3maj 5y agoLol theres nothing "bad" here. Pick up any intro to psychology of gender textbook and you'll learn real quick that men and women have different - often evolutionary based - qualities that make them interested in different things.
- DeathArrow 5y ago> There is a lot of work to do in getting real balance. How about letting people live their lives the way they want to instead of trying to artificially change the society?
- politician 5y agoSome groups will have worse outcomes if everyone is allowed to live their lives they way they want.
- bluGill 5y agoI'm fine with it so long as it is really because that is how they want to live their life. I'm not fine if they want to be, and have the ability to be but something prevents it.
- isitdopamine 5y agoWhy work to do? If the imbalance is the result of different innate preferences (and there’s a great deal of evidence it is) then working against nature is a waste of time and money!