8 ms·
7-Eleven breached customer privacy by collecting facial imagery without consent
- uoaei 5y agoNow do the rest of the corporations who have installed cameras in their stores.
- avalys 5y agoAm I breaching the privacy of the people I saw at the grocery store yesterday because I can remember what their faces look like?
- holknas 5y agono, nor are you doing it at a massive country wide scale into a datacenter.
- mistrial9 5y agomore than one country-wide; side note, Southland Corp was convicted of slavery-related charges at a US location.. no similarity to stores in Asia of course! source: daily news, details on request
- capableweb 5y agoAre you a corporation going around asking for answers, photographing them and storing the images for long term storage without informing them about this? If not, then no, you are not breaching the privacy of anyone. I know in the US corporations are basically the same as humans, but the rest of the world haven't gotten than dystopian yet.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoAs much as I dislike this line of argumentation, I think it is important to address it, because people seem to be applying wrong standards and comparisons, when it comes privacy.
- devmor 5y agoNo, and neither would the corporation be if they were doing that. But you are not a corporation, nor are you a computer, nor are you storing that data in any appreciable amount or manner in which it could be referenced for the purposes of operating a corporation.
- onemoresoop 5y ago> Am I breaching the privacy of the people I saw at the grocery store yesterday because I can remember what their faces look like? You remembering faces is fine as it doesn't allow you to share with others what your mind "recorded". The amount of detail is questionable and you'd probably not remember everyone and everything but what strikes you as unusual/suspect etc.. Second, since you're not a machine you wouldn't be able to run algorithms on the data you recorded, you'd make a few inferences here and there and that is normal but you wouldn't be able to study the psychology of every customer that entered your store and use it against them.
- blitzar 5y ago> you wouldn't be able to study the psychology of every customer that entered your store and use it against them. Is that not the role of the greeter that hounds you at the door?
- munificent 5y agoIf a bit of mayo falls off my sandwich while I'm at the beach, have I created an oil spill? Scale and context matters.
- LeifCarrotson 5y agoNo. It was wonderful when the person who worked the deli at a customer site where I worked for a few weeks learned my face and remembered what I liked to order. If I wanted privacy, though, I could get it. However, scale matters. An action being condoned between two individuals does not imply that it's acceptable when repeated millions of times. It shouldn't generate any outrage if a police officer tailed a suspect from a vehicle description and (publicly visible!) license plate number. It should generate outrage if the police department installs automated license plate readers at intersections throughout the city, and it becomes impossible to drive anywhere without being tracked.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago>and it becomes impossible to drive anywhere without being tracked. Might want to start with the mobile networks saving your phone’s location history. I do not mind the use of license plate readers on cops’ cars, if cops are actually going to start pulling over people who have not paid car taxes or are not displaying license plates or do not have insurance. I would also like automated variate rate congestion tolling with license plate readers. That would help manage road capacity and grid lock, and make the costs of commuting more transparent.
- pengaru 5y agoI've noticed not only the local 7-11 PoS terminals now have embedded cameras, but also Home Depot's newer all-in-one computers at the self-checkout include an embedded camera. It's obnoxious and rude. You wouldn't be OK with anyone shoving a camera point-blank in your face while doing business with them. That's exactly what these businesses are subjecting their in-person retail customers to.
- hammock 5y ago>I've noticed not only the local 7-11 PoS terminals now have embedded cameras, but also Home Depot's newer all-in-one computers at the self-checkout include an embedded camera. Starbucks card readers too. Pointed right up at your face. I emailed the local store manager about it, who said he'd get back to me but never did.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhat did you expect the local store manager was going to be able to say or do?
- hammock 5y agoGet me a policy or some sort of response in writing from their corporate overlords. Edit: just got an update. Here's what he said: >So sorry for never responding! We are not using the cameras on the POS card readers. You will see when it asks you to swipe the card that it has an eye crossed out to signify that it is not actively using the camera to look at the customer.
- black_13 5y agoFunny I could see anyone of people ive worked with coming up with some idea like this and saying “cool”.
- nmstoker 5y agoMaybe the article has missed detail but it seems to imply that 7-Eleven was only asked to stop and to destroy the inappropriately collected data and was not given a fine nor any other punishment. Is that correct?
- encryptluks2 5y agoIsn't that the benefit of being a large company. You do something bad, you get a slap on the wrist and they politely ask you to stop. You do it again, same slap.. and they say pretty please. Eventually, you just realize that as long as you keep paying the politicians you can do pretty much whatever you want with little to no consequence?
- leppr 5y agoDepends on the country. For instance in Europe, GDPR enforcement is way more lenient towards small companies, to the point where it makes no strategic sense for a startup to invest anything but the bare minimum required to feign "good intentions". Striving for actual compliance with the letter of the law is something only huge companies do.
- hkai 5y agoI don't see an issue with learning the age of the customers who come into the store. I think a much bigger issue with tech is censorship and surveillance of political opposition, not the recording of someone's age and gender.
- bastardoperator 5y agoAll I wanted was a Pepsi!
- mistrial9 5y ago> https://soundcloud.com/deivid-dos-santos-fernandes/8-2-institutionalized-suicidal https://soundcloud.com/deivid-dos-santos-fernandes/8-2-insti... song lyrics :D
- czbond 5y agoWalmart is bound to be collecting facial images - but I don't know if they have a consent clause somewhere in store / receipt.
- nitrogen 5y agoTheir self-checkout systems have an insane number of cameras per station, including one pointed right at your face. I don't doubt it's being saved for expression analysis as each product is swiped.
- heavyset_go 5y agoThey are and they share those images and data with other retailers in order to build up dossiers on "problem" customers.
- reaperducer 5y agoExcept in Illinois, where that is illegal. If it's not illegal in your state, it's time to start petitioning your elected officials. If you don't, then you're part of the problem and shouldn't complain about the situation on the internet.
- crysin 5y agoAnother fun fact of Illinois protecting its citizens with that law is that schools like DePaul and Northwestern are currently being sued for violating Illinois' biometric laws with the use of facial recognizing proctoring software. https://dailynorthwestern.com/2021/02/18/campus/nu-faces-lawsuit-for-improperly-capturing-and-storing-students-biometric-data/ https://dailynorthwestern.com/2021/02/18/campus/nu-faces-law... https://depauliaonline.com/52893/news/depaul-sued-over-facial-recognition-tech-used-for-online-test-proctoring/ https://depauliaonline.com/52893/news/depaul-sued-over-facia...
- LambdaTrain 5y agoSame with Rite Aid stores around my school. The auto checkout machine has been equipped with cameras since pandemic (about one yr ago). It gave me a sense of intrusion.
- jackson1442 5y agoThat’s the point. The self checkout cameras are just there to let you know you’re being watched; why else would they make them as in-your-face as they are?
- aaron695 5y agoStill makes me laugh the time the store put cameras on every fridge door and also replaced the glass with screens as a misdirect and all HN could go on about was how smart they were they knew about glass. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27636773 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27636773
- ajay-b 5y agoThis occurs in America routinely, dating to 20+ years ago.
- hellojesus 5y agoAnother reason to wear Reflectables on the daily.